Dirt is good?

[Brian]

Your grass is fine! Add more blades, add more shading. Then repost it and we'll see if anything else needs done

[Agent green]

Ok, more changes, still got a few problems but i have to go to work so just posting for crit so i can edit better 



Comment 

Edit. xion i havent sorted that bit out yet, still WIP 

[Xion]

The tiling is way obvious. There's a dark horizontal line running through them.

[Brian]

Looks much better! But, yes, there is an obvious boundary if you look close enough. Also, if you're going for an X look to your grass that's fine otherwise perhaps add more blades, make some current ones move different, to remove its monotony.

[Stefano]

Unless your game is using a camera pointing down at a 90 degrees angle to the floor, it would probably be a good idea to add some overlapping grass blades (for depth) and additionally you could also "lift" the two lower grass blades on the "X"s. This will add a nice perspective to your pixels.

Concerning the tiling, I think you did a pretty good job on hiding the modulation, except for the horizontal darker lines, as Xion has pointed out.

I could make an edit if you want me to, because my crippled English might in the way when I'm trying to explain something less obvious.

[Agent green]

Edit it please  I think i get what you are getting at, but an edit would be nice to. I will have another shot on the grass

[Agent green]

Gave it a try 

[Zero]

Is that just a recoloring of the dirt? Shame on thee.

Still looks better, but if you put this next to the dirt tiles, it'll look strange.

[Brian]

Well I felt your last grass was pretty but it needed more drama (for grass blades) if it wants to measure up to the holy Seiken Densetsu 3 grass tiling--those people who made it are just amazing. I am amazed that they KNEW they could make stuff GREAT and they did it, they didn't give up they made it.

So I took your X grass, took out the dark green background, then I added some highlights to the grass blades and pasted them over the new grass. I came up with this:
Here's the original tile:

Perhaps a little dirty looking, but I feel it portrays grass a little cleaner. I'd also try to more monochrome the colors/reduce the contrast if your characters are meant to stand out particularly well on the tiles. Right now the tiles have some character

[Agent green]

Is that just a recoloring of the dirt? Shame on thee.

Still looks better, but if you put this next to the dirt tiles, it'll look strange.

It isnt a recolouring  did a completly new one, just a coincidence