Commercial Critique Suggestion Thread

[Scotteh]

final fantasy 10-2 heres a screenie:


sorry if i dont understand the concept of this post

[snake]

sorry if i don't understand the concept of this post

This is a voting poll for a game made in pixels. The game that is selected in the end will be analysed on it's pixel art and how it relates and works in the game. Final Fantasy X-2 is not made in pixel so I'm afraid you can't place that vote.

I think it was snake who said that CT is already all over the internet, and could be observed at several places.

I don't recall saying that. From what I remember, it was mentioned that Crono Trigger was allready critiqued at an earlier point.

[Scotteh]

oh ok sorry about that then but anyway, shadow of the beast got me

[goat]

Dodonpachi, for the following reaons:


(btw hotlinking is bad)

Who among us would rather learn how they did Beast than learn to create awesomeness as shown above?

I loved Shadow of the Beast as a game, but even when I was 6 I knew the graphics were mostly ass.  I understand that the point of a commercial critique is to point out the good and the bad, but if we wanted to critique glaringly bad pixel art, we wouldn't need an activity-driven collaborative effort to find it. 

[Jad]

I Vote DoDonPachi!

[Oded]

dodonpachi should get critiqued...donpachi is also good...same graphics diff game, just some of the ships/designs are different...yeah...

i also worked on a dodonpachi-esque ship back in the day when i could pixel.

[Gil]

I always liked that piece, it's pretty cool. Actually, yeah, change my vote to Dodonpachi...

[Cow]

I'm actually changing my vote to Shadow of the Beast. Just because of what Helm said, it'll be a lot better to fix bad art than oggle great/good art.  Sorry to whoever's keeping track of the votes.

[Akira]

Hrm. i'm torn between dodon and SotB. on the one hand i want to see dodon broken down to see how they achieved the look but i also fear the surface readings and not being able to get past the 'looks good' stage. SotB is easily taken apart and perhaps more relative to the restrictions on it's platform?

Shadow of the Beast because i'm thinking people are voting on dodon because they like the look. pfft. thats not what this is about.
EDIT: this echos mccow28 who posted while i was writing

[.TakaM]

I'll vote for Dodonpachi too