Thanks for the feedback. (Is it not clearly a girl?

)
The clothing is meant to be very loose-fitting like the girl's in this picture, so I think It should move quite a bit:

Do you think that explanation is sufficient, or do you still think it looks wrong?
I smoothed out the motion of the ponytail and improved the bangs. Also experimented with some specular highlights:

>

Can't decide how I feel about the highlights... What say y'all?
EDIT: Made some minor tweaks.