Next Commercial Critique (MAY 06): Suggestions

[Filax_666]

We did Boktai already.

Oh...too bad. If anyone saved it I'd be really glad to see it...

[.TakaM]

oooh, Im gonna switch my vote to yoshis island

[Dascu]

Hmm, Demon Crest. The Castlevania feel is quite nice.

[goat]

I'm sure someone has Boktai saved, it spawned a big critique and a really awesome challenge.

Voting ends tomorrow at midnight or whenever I get home, whichever happens later :p

[Conzeit]

when the hell did we supposedly do boktai? I sure as hell dont remember it. it must've focused on the perspective because I dont remember any discussion of the simplistic shading style.

ooh wait, was this the discussion before it was even released? I dont think it should even count in that case...

I'm not really content with the options, I propose Comix Zone and Earth Worm Jim however futile that might be

[Sohashu]

Here is a tally.

M&L:SS = IIII
LOZ:TMC = IIII IIII II
DC = IIII IIII IIII
YI = IIII

So demons crest is the winner. 

[Lick]

Hopefully the result is not because of the mass following the big pixelers. I don't like that way of democracy.

[Sohashu]

I think you mean like helm and not people liking games with 2 x 2 pixels.    I personally love all SNES games and personally adore DC, Chrono trigger, and terranigma.  I have no lif apart from these games and forums.   

I would also suggest for next time among TMC, M&L:SS, and YI, Gundam Wing: Endless Duel,  It has a good graphical style IMO. 

IF not that Chrono Trigger.

[ndchristie]

chrono trigger or a seiken densetsu game would be a good game to critique, which is why its already been critiqued half a million times.  id prefer to look at something that you cant find all over the place

im interested to see what people can say about demon's crest

[Sohashu]

Terranigma maybe?  OH well.  I think snes period is a good way to go as far as Commercial Critiqing goes.  It was a time when pixelling was the majority form of game making.  It is then, IMO, that graphics was as good as it gets. 
God bless the 2 x 2 pixel.