311
General Discussion / Re: BrotherInWar campaign
« on: August 21, 2005, 05:29:44 am »I'm unsure that we can prevent an individual from posting further to a thread if they misbehaved in it once.How reps will respond to the power of the ability to lock threads can only be found out in due time. "The best to teach your kids discipline isn’t through physical abuse its mental abuse that causes the longest lasting scars," err wait now, this quote, "The best way to teach a kid to not play with matches it to let them burn themselves."
I'm not clear on your question about locking, but I'll try to respond to what I did understand... you believe that representatives may be corrupt and lock quality threads for inappropriate reasons? Will working with other representatives be a problem if they share such a power?
It's difficult to set an appropriate punishment sometimes. Absolutes like member/non-member are too sharp a contrast, but post zaps tend to only make people resistant to making reparations for an offense they have committed. They usually begin to resent any authority.
In the case of two sides caving to a fight, would it be better to provide multiple choices that encourage an improvement in relations before resorting to punishments? If they can undo the damage, what harm is there to provide mediation toward that end before an end is chosen for them? A spoken contract cannot substitute a state of peace, but setting a warning for further disruption may prove most effective?QuoteAs in the participation of Reps in these mediations I feel yes but, the position shouldn't be handed to them, all forms of forum government should take part in resolving conflicts between members.I agree. Representatives should remain a vestige of parallel with the membership, getting involved with an issue when sought by a member.
I wasn't saying the mediation didn't help. Fights without mediation usually included cops, drugs, baseball bats, and candy; if that’s what you were asking. There was still a round' a 25% chance of success. Yet it doesn't hurt anything if it’s tried. Mediation should be tried before anything else in most cases. I say most because I've seen people do something that they were perm banned so fast very few saw what they posted. I believe a combination of peace treaties and harsh example punishments work the best. Where peace treaties are set in place and harsh punishments are there for the slightest toe out of line in breaking the treaty.