Pixelation
Critique => Pixel Art => Topic started by: Asturias on March 19, 2008, 07:54:30 pm
-
Here is the main character of my Rpg.
(http://img383.imageshack.us/img383/8695/25070348fm3.png)
Any comments or suggestions to improve it?
Thank you in advance. ;D
-
he looks sad
-
i think you've kept the color count low, which can be great, but for right now i'd say hes feeling a little jagged. don't be afraid to buffer your transitions and smooth shapes esp. the highlights on the armor and the eyes but really everywhere.
also this is just a guess from your aesthetic, but are you from spain, portugal, or southern france?
-
Thank you for your suggestions, i'll do my best to improve it. :)
And no, i'm from Quebec (Canada), the only french province in North America :lol:
Edit:
(http://img514.imageshack.us/img514/6522/blackgu4.png)
Is it better now? ::)
-
i like it before :o
the eyes seems very big
i love hiss skin, but try to work on his metal parts
they need more contrast :)
-
I can't figure out what the dark blotches around the eyes are for. I think he should have eyebrows.
(http://i2.photobucket.com/albums/y13/tocky/asturias.png)
Parts of it look a little off to me, that aren't casting shadows: his hair casts no shadow on his face, his nose doesn't, his head doesn't cast much of a shadow on his neck. The armor, too.
-
Thank you for your help tocky, i really appreciate.
Here's my update:
(http://img135.imageshack.us/img135/2357/untitl333ed1jp1.png)
Is it better?
-
yuck ... your first one looks so much better. Go back to that version.
Don't you think that hammer is too big to carry like that?
Here is an edit. It might help you with how to smooth the transitions for eyes. It also shows fully closed outlines (unlike yours where you only outline where there is shadows sometimes). Using outlines your way is fine, I just can't manage to do that successfully.
(http://i39.photobucket.com/albums/e199/sharprm/boy.gif)
-
Well, sharprm.. why do you say he looked better in the first version?
Because of his cute looking, or because he had less colors, less contrast and such things?
Your edit is pretty nice, and I love the way you did his gautlet and his spaulder, for exemple. Also, the way you smooth the transitions seems pretty good. I'll definitly take a closer look at that. ;D
However, I don't know if i should keep the design of the first or the last version... I agree that he's cuter in the first one, but the last one look much more mature... ???
Could other people give me their opinions? I don't know what I should do... :'(
PS: As for the way he's carrying his hammer... let's say he's really strong
-
sharps version is the first to effectively address the biggest issue - smoothness.
adding colors and then using them in large swaths leads to the same issues that previous sprites had. the closer you use colors, the smoother it will be, which can sometimes include as sharps does using a color (that gray-pink) as nothing but an edge smoother. Color conservation is good, but pixelling a nice smooth face is better :y:
-
Yeah, I agree... :D
But also, should I keep it outlined... or not?
I'll try to edit it tonight. I'll post it when It will be done.
-
It doesn't make a difference how strong he is, he will fall over backwards. You need to pick a more appropriate pose: legs apart and hammer held at an angle so that it is closer to his head. This post might help you to understand where i am coming from:
http://www.wayofthepixel.net/pixelation/index.php?topic=5996.msg70637#msg70637
Why is the first one better? Hard to say. But I would suggest using that one with an added color to smooth eyes. Work on other characters to get a better feel for whether you want to outline fully or not. edit: at the same time, you might find pulling off a more mature character succesfullly requires more muscles on body etc.
-
Alright, i'll read about it and i'll redo the pose (with the hammer), but first, I'll finish the character himself. :D
Here's my edit:
(http://img301.imageshack.us/img301/5975/blacksmithfinalbs9.png)
I think I'll remake his gauntlet from scratch though, because i'm still not satisfied with it.
-
I still think the eyes are too blotchy:
(http://i2.photobucket.com/albums/y13/tocky/astur_2.png)
-
Well to be honest, I love the eyes the way they are.. :P
Here's my last edit (I have redone his gauntlet):
(http://img175.imageshack.us/img175/9034/finalbsjg9.png)
Also, here is a quick sketch of a house. I know it may seem too common, but what do you think about the concept..?
(http://img175.imageshack.us/img175/4418/wipps3.png)
-
I agree with Tocky about the eyes - maybe use lighter green on the pixels he replaced if you want to hint at the white of eyes there.
Does he have a beard? Maybe you want to rethink the thick outline on the cheeks.
The second darkest brown on skin seems a bit too saturated.
-
I followed your suggestions (tocky and sharprm), I changed the eyes and desatured the brown a little bit. I also modified the lighting of the face.
Oh and yea, he have a beard. I wanted him to look a little more mature, so I added it.
(http://img175.imageshack.us/img175/2816/afterhk9.png)
Better?
-
Edited the character's face and on the third image, I made the head 1 pixel shorter and added few details on his hair. btw Is that a paint or tatoo near his eyes?
(http://xs225.xs.to/xs225/08131/smithedit1757.png)
-
Wow, thank you for your edit, it's definitly better. ;D
I'm not sure if I'll keep the head shorter, but I really love the way you highlight his face and his hair. :)
Oh, and yea: It's supposed to be some kind of painting he have near the eyes, and on his left eye (on the right of the picture) he also have a scar, as you can see.
-
Froli's edit is more accomplished, bu he's gone from being something rather your own to being something more dragon warrior
-
After posting the house this is a 3/4 perspective? I think the character is way too 'straight on' so it gives some perspective issues.
-
Froli's edit is more accomplished, bu he's gone from being something rather your own to being something more dragon warrior
Dragon warrior? Did i really went far from the original by cleaning, placing highlights and adding details? The major change that I did was cutting the eyes <including the head> down by 1 pixel since I find it awkward. :P
-
Dragon warrior? Did i really went far from the original by cleaning, placing highlights and adding details?
when you switch from two relatively flat regions to nearly full modelling, yeah, i'd say its pretty far :P.
don't underestimate the power of an extra shade across such small distances!
(you also switched to that goddawful scowl that all the heroes in those games need to have - that's actually what made me think of it more than the rendering).
Don't get me wrong - it's a good edit! just keep in mind that "small" differences can be huge for style in pixel sizes
-
Thanks to both of you, I'll take your comments in consideration to finish it. I'll post an update soon. :y:
I've also start his portrait. It's not finish at all, and still very unpolished, but what do you think about it?
(http://img301.imageshack.us/img301/497/portraitwipku1.png)
-
Hey, great character, seems kind of amiable, pixel potraits are always great.
I could offer some criticism: It seems to me that the shading could be more defined, I mean for example the shading on the shoulder armor looks vague, I had a blast doing a quick edit to show what I mean, (I did a quick note on the top right for myself to help imagine the light source) (http://i24.photobucket.com/albums/c37/deetech/New-1-1.gif)
later
..and I did a more more complete edit showing a shading approach(or lack of :lol:) with the same palette...(http://i24.photobucket.com/albums/c37/deetech/New-99.gif)
-
Hey, great character, seems kind of amiable, pixel potraits are always great.
I could offer some criticism: It seems to me that the shading could be more defined, I mean for example the shading on the shoulder armor looks vague, I had a blast doing a quick edit to show what I mean, (I did a quick note on the top right for myself to help imagine the light source) (http://i24.photobucket.com/albums/c37/deetech/New-1-1.gif)
later
but where did the nose go?
-
The portrait looks extremely feminine to me. I think it has something to with all the black you've used there. Good job otherwise.
-
The nose? who knows :D?
I always will remember a good life drawing instructor told me to draw what you see, not what you think you see, so instead of drawing an L for a nose, look deeper, if that makes sense, is the light source exactly centered pointed perpendicular to the face?
-
It's still unfinished, but I guess it's already better... **oh, and I changed the light source too, by the way**
(http://img141.imageshack.us/img141/8247/porrw2.png)
What do you think?
-
dtek - what are you talking about? The light source is good except for the hair maybe.
(http://i39.photobucket.com/albums/e199/sharprm/dude.gif)
Asturias - be careful not to lose the original concept when you incorporate advice and edits. The first one fitted with the previous sprite. This new one seems too tanned and doll like for my liking, but it could be because its unfinished.
-
(http://www.locustleaves.com/anotherdude.gif)
*slow two frame animation, be patient*
Hello. There is no color critique in my post. It's mainly about two things: anatomical correctness, and banding. Banding is an issue we've discussed on this forum a few times. If the term is unfamiliar to you you can check out a few examples here http://www.wayofthepixel.net/pixelation/index.php?topic=5556.msg66232#msg66232
It's up to you if you'd like to stick with banding, from the whole universe so far I have heard a single dissenting voice saying 'banding has its uses' so who knows, there's a person for everything, at at least.
About anatomy: Eyebrows? The nose is a bit simbolic, I have it a bit of a more realistic rendering, see if you like. Same for lips and whatnot. The neck was quite wrong I think, and generally I would suggest a lot of anatomical studies from life!
-
sorry sharprm, I'm can't defend my criticism because I don't even know the specific problems you have with my crit, you could explain the problems more next time...
-
Thank you very much Helm, your edit's really great. I didn't have much time to work on this this week, but I'll try to improve the portrait when I'll have some time. :)
Here's a new character, and an edit of the blacksmith:
(http://img406.imageshack.us/img406/2747/wip12zy1.png)
C+C?
-
Thank you very much Helm, your edit's really great. I didn't have much time to work on this this week, but I'll try to improve the portrait when I'll have some time. :)
Here's a new character, and an edit of the blacksmith:
(http://img406.imageshack.us/img406/2747/wip12zy1.png)
C+C?
hmm, she's a bit mannish, you'll need to change more than the costume to get girl out of this. narrower shoulders, more hourglass-y is how to start, even if this is a bit stereotypical...
-
Thank you very much Helm, your edit's really great. I didn't have much time to work on this this week, but I'll try to improve the portrait when I'll have some time. :)
Here's a new character, and an edit of the blacksmith:
(http://img406.imageshack.us/img406/2747/wip12zy1.png)
C+C?
hmm, she's a bit mannish, you'll need to change more than the costume to get girl out of this. narrower shoulders, more hourglass-y is how to start, even if this is a bit stereotypical...
Not really stereotypical, women anatomically have wider hips. :P I agree with the narrower shoulders too.
Helm, the perspective of your edit looks very different from the original.....
Also, Asturias, I like your original light source a lot better! But I guess that's just a personal preference.
-
Helm, the perspective of your edit looks very different from the original.....
Also, Asturias, I like your original light source a lot better! But I guess that's just a personal preference.
Wait... I don't see how Helm changed the light source nor the perspective here... ???
The highlights on the hair that are just parallel 45 degree lines are really bothering me here they stick out way too much and look very pixelly/grainy (especially on the female). I'd try to smooth the highlight out somehow.
-
Thanks everyone for the comments.
(http://img210.imageshack.us/img210/5032/wippppdh2.png)
Better? :'(
Edit: Here's also a ''wip'' mockup I worked on (don't bother to comment about the grass, I didn't work on it yet).
(http://img393.imageshack.us/img393/9961/wip22ho2.png)
-
not to offer such subjective criticism, but i wouldn't want to play a game with a character that looked pissed off towards me/the camera.
-
your fellow here needs a little bit of sleep. ;D
(http://i203.photobucket.com/albums/aa57/SabataS/wip12zy1.png)
Try making softer outlines whit eyes, merging them more whit his face....
-
Edit!
(http://img232.imageshack.us/img232/1927/wiprpgfemaleuh0.png)
Hope you find this helpful! :)
-
Edit!
(http://img232.imageshack.us/img232/1927/wiprpgfemaleuh0.png)
Hope you find this helpful! :)
yup that's something like what i imagined :y:
the shoulders could still come in slightly i tihnk
-
That's a nice edit tehwexxl0rz, thank you^^
Nobody gave any comments about the tree thought.... Is it that bad? :-[
Some tips about it would be nice. :P
-
You might want to think about the light source for the tree, and the dark leaves; otherwise it could begin to look flat in a hurry when you get to the details. :)