You've probably felt that specific sting of annoyance. You walk into a store, or refresh a browser tab, looking for that one specific item—maybe a limited-edition sneaker, a specific GPU, or even just a particular brand of oat milk—and it’s gone. Then, two days later, it’s back. Then it’s gone again. This "in and out stock" cycle isn't just bad luck. It's actually a high-stakes game of inventory chicken that retailers play with their supply chains, and honestly, they're losing more often than they'd like to admit.
Stockouts cost retailers an estimated $1.2 trillion globally every year. That is a massive amount of money left on the table simply because a box didn't arrive at a warehouse at 4:00 AM on a Tuesday. But it's not just about losing a sale; it's about losing you. When a product is in and out of stock constantly, brand loyalty dies. You stop checking. You go to the competitor.
The Chaos Behind the "Out of Stock" Sign
Retailers hate empty shelves. It looks like failure. But keeping a shelf perfectly full is surprisingly expensive. This leads to the "in and out stock" phenomenon, which is usually a symptom of "Just-in-Time" (JIT) manufacturing hitting a brick wall.
JIT was the darling of the 90s and 2000s, popularized by Toyota. The idea is simple: don't hold extra stuff. Extra stuff costs money to store. It gathers dust. It might break. So, you order exactly what you need exactly when you need it. It’s a beautiful, lean system until a boat gets stuck in the Suez Canal or a factory in Taiwan has a power outage. Suddenly, that lean system has zero "safety stock," and your favorite product starts flickering in and out of availability like a dying lightbulb.
There’s also the "Bullwhip Effect." Imagine a consumer buys one extra gallon of milk. The grocer sees this and orders two extra from the distributor to be safe. The distributor sees the grocer's order and asks the dairy for four extra. By the time it hits the farm, they’re trying to double the herd. When the demand settles back to normal, everyone is drowning in milk. They stop ordering. The product goes out of stock because the system overcorrected.
Why Tech and Fashion Suffer the Most
Electronics are notorious for this. Take the Sony PlayStation 5 launch or any major NVIDIA card release. These aren't just high demand; they are victims of complex "in and out stock" cycles caused by "wafer starts" in semiconductor fabrication. You can't just "make more" chips on a Friday afternoon. It takes three to four months to finish a single batch of silicon. If the demand spikes, the stock vanishes. When the batch finishes, the stock floods back in.
💡 You might also like: Canada Tariffs on US Goods Before Trump: What Most People Get Wrong
Fashion is even weirder. Zara and H&M have mastered "fast fashion," which is basically a controlled version of in and out stock. They deliberately under-produce items to create a sense of urgency. If you see it and don't buy it, it’ll be gone by Thursday. This is "artificial scarcity," and while it’s a brilliant marketing trick, it’s a nightmare for the average shopper just trying to find a pair of jeans that fit.
The Ghost of Phantom Inventory
Sometimes, the computer says the item is there, but the shelf is empty. This is "Phantom Inventory," and it’s a leading cause of the in and out stock headache.
How does it happen?
- Theft: Someone walks out with a bag of coffee without paying. The computer thinks it’s still in Aisle 4.
- Damaged goods: A jar of pickles breaks in the backroom. If the employee doesn't scan it as "waste," the system keeps waiting for someone to buy it before ordering more.
- Misplacement: Some shopper decides they don't want frozen peas and leaves them in the electronics section.
Because the system thinks the item is "in stock," it never triggers a reorder. It’s only when a manager does a manual cycle count—basically counting every single thing on the shelf by hand—that the error is fixed. Suddenly, the system "discovers" they are out of stock, orders a massive shipment, and the item reappears. In and out. In and out.
The Problem with "Safety Stock" Math
Mathematically, retailers use a formula to decide when to reorder. It looks roughly like this:
$SS = Z \times \sigma_{LT} \times D_{avg}$
Where $Z$ is the service level, $\sigma_{LT}$ is the standard deviation of lead time, and $D_{avg}$ is average demand.
📖 Related: Bank of America Orland Park IL: What Most People Get Wrong About Local Banking
Basically, it's a way of saying: "How much extra do we need to keep so we don't run out if the truck is late or people go crazy for this item?" Most companies aim for a 95% service level. But that 5% gap is exactly where the in and out stock frustration lives. Increasing that to 99% sounds easy, but it can literally double the amount of money tied up in a warehouse. Most CFOs would rather you be slightly annoyed than have $10 million in unsold inventory sitting in a cold storage unit in New Jersey.
How to Beat the In and Out Stock Cycle
If you're a consumer, you have more power than you think. First, stop using the "Notify Me" buttons on the main brand sites. Those emails often go out in batches, and by the time you click, the bots have already cleared the inventory.
Instead, use third-party trackers. For tech, sites like NowInStock or various Discord bots track API calls from major retailers. They know the stock is back before the website even updates the "Buy" button.
For everyday items, honestly, just ask the department manager. Most big-box stores like Target or Walmart have specific "truck days." In many regions, grocery stores get their main shipments on Tuesdays and Fridays. If you show up at 10:00 AM on a Wednesday, you're picking through the leftovers of the Tuesday shipment.
Real-World Data: The Cost of Inconsistency
A study by the IHL Group found that "Overstocks" (too much stuff) and "Out-of-Stocks" (not enough stuff) combine for a $1.75 trillion loss in retail. It's a "Ghost Economy." Interestingly, about 70% of out-of-stock events are caused by poor in-store practices—like not moving items from the backroom to the shelf—rather than a failure in the global supply chain.
👉 See also: Are There Tariffs on China: What Most People Get Wrong Right Now
We saw this peak during the 2021-2022 period. Remember the "Great Cream Cheese Shortage" in New York? Or the baby formula crisis? Those weren't just supply issues; they were massive failures in "in and out stock" management where the entire system's fragility was exposed.
Actionable Steps for Business Owners
If you're running a business and struggling with erratic stock levels, you have to stop relying on "gut feelings." You've got to automate your reorder points.
- Audit your lead times. Don't just assume the supplier will take five days because they did in 2019. Check the last six months of data. If it’s actually seven days, your reorder point is wrong.
- Invest in RFID. It's getting cheaper. Tracking items with radio frequency instead of barcodes means you can scan an entire room in seconds. No more phantom inventory.
- Diversify your suppliers. If all your stock comes from one port or one factory, you're one storm away from an empty shelf. It's worth paying 5% more to have a secondary "back-up" supplier in a different geographic region.
- Buffer for the "Outliers." TikTok can kill your inventory. If a product goes viral, your standard math is useless. You need a "manual override" for when social media starts buzzing.
Retail is shifting toward "Unified Commerce," where the warehouse, the physical store, and the website all talk to each other in real-time. Until that is perfect, we're all going to be dealing with the "in and out stock" dance. It's a balance of math, psychology, and sometimes just hoping the cargo ship doesn't take a wrong turn.
The next time you see that "Out of Stock" sign, just know there's likely a supply chain manager somewhere staring at a spreadsheet, desperately trying to calculate how many more units they need to satisfy a world that wants everything yesterday.
Next Steps for Better Inventory Management
- Perform a "Wall-to-Wall" Inventory Count: If you haven't done one in three months, your digital records are likely 10-15% inaccurate. Start here to kill phantom inventory.
- Calculate Your True Carrying Cost: Most businesses underestimate this. Include insurance, taxes, warehouse labor, and the "opportunity cost" of that cash.
- Implement a Tiered Stocking System: Use ABC analysis. "A" items (high value/high frequency) get 99% service level targets. "C" items (low value/rarely sold) can afford to be out of stock more often.