Twenty years is a long time to wait. Most people expected Stephen Chbosky to stay the "Perks of Being a Wallflower" guy forever. That slim, epistolary novel basically defined a generation’s worth of teenage angst. So, when the news broke that he was finally releasing a follow-up, everyone braced for another coming-of-age tearjerker about high schoolers in Pittsburgh. What we got instead was Imaginary Friend. It’s a 700-page, sprawling, religious-themed horror epic that feels more like Stephen King on a fever dream than Charlie writing letters to a "Friend."
Honestly, the shift was jarring.
If you haven’t read it yet, or if you’re trying to figure out why your book club couldn't stop arguing about the ending, you have to understand the scale of what Chbosky attempted here. He didn't just write a scary story. He tried to build a mythology. Imaginary Friend by Stephen Chbosky is a weird, dense, and often terrifying look at the bond between a mother and son, but it’s wrapped in layers of Christian allegory and "upside-down" world-building that makes Stranger Things look like a Saturday morning cartoon.
The Long Road to Imaginary Friend
Stephen Chbosky didn't just sit down and crank this out. It took him nine years to write. Think about that for a second. In the time it took to finish this book, Chbosky directed the film adaptation of Perks and wrote the screenplay for the live-action Beauty and the Beast. He was busy. But this story about Christopher and the "Nice Man" was clearly a different kind of obsession.
The plot kicks off with Christopher, a seven-year-old boy, and his mother Kate. They are running. Not from a monster, at least not at first, but from an abusive relationship. They land in Mill Grove, Pennsylvania. It’s the kind of town that feels safe until it isn't. Then Christopher disappears into the Mission Street Woods for six days.
When he comes back, he isn't the same.
He’s smarter. His dyslexia is gone. And he has a voice in his head—the "Nice Man"—telling him he has to build a treehouse in the woods before Christmas, or something terrible will happen to everyone in town. It’s a classic horror setup. But Chbosky pushes it into places most horror writers avoid, specifically heavy-handed religious themes that have left a lot of readers feeling... conflicted.
Why the Horror Elements Hit Differently
Most horror fans go into a book looking for a specific kind of dread. Chbosky gives you that, but he uses "the hiss" to do it. The Hiss is the primary antagonist—a sort of ancient, whispering evil that lives in the "imaginary world" Christopher accesses.
What makes the horror in Imaginary Friend work is the sensory overload.
Chbosky uses repetition. A lot of it. He’ll repeat phrases over and over until they feel like a heartbeat. Or a headache. It’s an effective way to simulate the feeling of a child’s intrusive thoughts. The stakes aren't just "will they survive?" but "will they lose their souls?" That’s a big jump from a book about kids listening to The Smiths and feeling infinite.
- The Nice Man: Christopher's guide who might not be as nice as he seems.
- The Hissing Lady: A terrifying entity with her eyes sewn shut.
- The Imaginary World: A mirror version of Mill Grove that is decaying and dangerous.
One of the coolest, and most polarizing, parts of the book is how Chbosky handles the "imaginary" aspect. It isn't just a dream. It's a literal place that requires a specific kind of logic to navigate. You have to build things. You have to follow rules. If you break the rules, the Hiss gets in. It's almost like a dark version of The Phantom Tollbooth.
The "Perks" Connection: It’s All About the Mother
If you look past the monsters and the bleeding trees, this is actually a companion piece to The Perks of Being a Wallflower.
Wait, hear me out.
Perks was about a boy looking for a community to help him survive his trauma. Imaginary Friend is about a mother—Kate Reese—doing literally anything to protect her son from a world that wants to eat him alive. Kate is arguably the best-written character in the book. She’s broke. She’s tired. She’s been beaten down by life. But she is a "warrior mother" in the truest sense.
The relationship between Kate and Christopher is the emotional anchor. Without it, the book would just be a series of weird occurrences. Chbosky understands that horror only works if you actually care about the person being chased by the monster. If you liked the empathy in Perks, you'll find it here, too. It’s just covered in more blood.
Dealing With the Length and the Allegory
Let's be real: the book is long. Like, really long.
At 700+ pages, there are sections where the pacing drags. Chbosky spends a lot of time on side characters—the sheriff, the town doctor, the local bully. He’s trying to do what King does in It or The Stand, which is to make the town itself a character. Sometimes it works. Sometimes you just want to get back to Christopher in the woods.
Then there’s the religious stuff.
The final third of the book leans very heavily into Christian imagery. We’re talking literal battles between good and evil, talk of God, and sacrifices. For some readers, this felt like a betrayal of the "grounded" horror established at the beginning. Others found it to be a powerful exploration of faith and the battle for a child’s innocence.
💡 You might also like: Why Patti LaBelle's New Attitude Still Hits Hard Decades Later
It’s not subtle. If you’re looking for a nuanced, metaphorical take on religion, this might feel a bit like being hit over the head with a Bible. But if you view it as a dark fairy tale, it fits the "imaginary" logic Chbosky built from page one.
What Most People Get Wrong About the Ending
People often complain that the ending of Imaginary Friend by Stephen Chbosky is confusing. It’s not so much confusing as it is maximalist.
Everything happens at once.
The layers between the real world and the imaginary world dissolve. The secrets of Mill Grove come out. And the true identity of the "Nice Man" and the "Hissing Lady" is revealed. The key to understanding the end is realizing that the book isn't a puzzle to be solved. It’s a nightmare to be survived.
The "imaginary" friend isn't just a ghost or an alien. It’s a manifestation of the collective trauma and secrets of the town. Christopher isn't just a kid with a special power; he’s the only one who hasn't been corrupted by the town’s history yet.
Actionable Insights for Readers and Writers
If you’re a fan of Chbosky or just getting into horror, there are a few things you should take away from this massive tome.
For Readers:
Don’t try to binge this in one sitting. It’s too dense. Treat it like a miniseries. Read it in chunks of 50–100 pages. Pay attention to the names of the streets and the history of the "Nice Man"—Chbosky hides clues in the first 200 pages that don't pay off until the very end. Also, keep a light on. The scenes with the "mail-man" are genuinely unsettling.
For Writers:
Observe how Chbosky uses "white space." He uses very short, punchy sentences to create a sense of urgency.
Like this.
And this.
It creates a rhythm.
He also isn't afraid to break the "rules" of fiction. He switches perspectives, uses unconventional formatting, and leans into repetition. It's a masterclass in building a unique authorial voice, even if it’s a polarizing one.
For Collectors:
If you can find a first edition, grab it. The cover art and the interior formatting (with the strange symbols and changing fonts) are a big part of the experience. This is a book that was meant to be a physical object, not just words on a Kindle.
Final Verdict on the Mill Grove Mystery
Is it as good as The Perks of Being a Wallflower? That’s the wrong question. It’s not trying to be.
Imaginary Friend is an ambitious, messy, terrifying, and deeply heart-felt epic. It’s a book about the sacrifices parents make, the resilience of children, and the way evil whispers to us when we’re at our lowest. It won’t be for everyone. The length will scare some people off, and the religious pivot will annoy others.
But you can't deny that Chbosky swung for the fences.
In a world of cookie-cutter psychological thrillers, there’s something refreshing about a 700-page horror novel that is this unapologetically weird. It’s a testament to Chbosky’s skill that he can make you feel for a seven-year-old boy in a treehouse just as much as he made you feel for a teenager at a homecoming dance.
If you want to dive deeper into the world of Mill Grove, start by looking into the real-world inspirations Chbosky has mentioned in interviews—specifically his own childhood in Pittsburgh and his fascination with the concept of "unseen" protectors. You can also compare the themes of "Imaginary Friend" to other 2010s "kid-in-peril" horror like NOS4A2 by Joe Hill to see how the genre has evolved.
The best way to experience it? Just start reading. And maybe stay out of the woods for a while.