You’ve seen the face. Even if you aren't a history buff, that drooping mustache and those cold, heavy eyes are basically the universal symbol for the American West. But looking at images of Wild Bill Hickok isn't just about staring at an old-timey gunslinger; it’s about peeling back layers of a guy who was part lawman, part showman, and a hundred percent obsessed with his own brand.
James Butler Hickok was one of the most photographed men of his era. Honestly, for a guy living in the mid-1800s, he had a modern-day influencer’s knack for finding a camera. But here’s the thing: those photos tell a story that contradicts the "Wild" nickname.
The Dandy with the Navy Colts
Most people expect a gritty, dirt-covered outlaw. Instead, the authentic images reveal a "frontier dandy."
Hickok stood about 6'3", which made him a giant back then. He didn't just walk into a room; he loomed. One of the most famous photos shows him in a Prince Albert frock coat, looking more like a banker than a guy who’d just survived a bear attack. He wore custom boots. He had his hair long—shoulder length, actually—which wasn't just a style choice. It was a dare. He once told people he wore it long to dare any "hostile" to try and take his scalp.
Talk about a power move.
The Mustache and the "Duck Bill" Problem
There’s a funny bit of vanity hidden in these pictures. Early on, before the fame, Hickok didn't have that iconic mustache. People in Rock Creek, Nebraska, actually used to call him "Duck Bill." Why? Because he had a protruding upper lip that he was apparently pretty self-conscious about.
💡 You might also like: Wire brush for cleaning: What most people get wrong about choosing the right bristles
If you look at the 1858 tintype taken in Lawrence, Kansas, you see a younger, cleaner-shaven James. He looks... normal. Kinda soft, even. Once he grew that mustache to hide the "duck" look and the "Wild Bill" legend took off, he never looked back. The mustache became his armor.
Spotting the Real Deal vs. the Fakes
The market for images of Wild Bill Hickok is absolute chaos. Collectors pay millions for authenticated tintypes of Old West figures (like that $2.3 million Billy the Kid photo), so the "discoveries" never stop coming.
But authenticity is a high bar.
- The 1873 Gurney Portrait: This is the gold standard. Taken by Jeremiah Gurney in New York, it shows Hickok in his full buckskin glory while he was touring with Buffalo Bill’s Wild West show. This is the "Iconic Bill."
- The Deadwood Legend: People often look for a photo of him at the poker table where he died. Spoilers: it doesn't exist. There are plenty of recreations, but no one was snapping candids in Saloon No. 10 that day.
- The "Texas Jack" Tintype: A few years ago, a photo surfaced claiming to show Hickok with Texas Jack Omohundro. Historians basically shredded it. The facial structure didn't match the known skeletal measurements of Hickok’s face.
The eyes are usually the giveaway. Hickok had what people described as "riveting gray eyes." In old black-and-white photography, gray or light blue eyes often look piercingly white or ghostly. If the guy in the photo has dark, soulful eyes, it’s probably not Bill.
Why These Photos Look So Stiff
If you think he looks grumpy in every shot, you’re not wrong. Sitting for a portrait in the 1860s involved a head rest (a metal claw, basically) to keep you from moving during the long exposure.
📖 Related: Images of Thanksgiving Holiday: What Most People Get Wrong
Plus, Hickok was literally going blind.
In his final years, he suffered from glaucoma or trachoma (historians argue about which). By the time he reached Deadwood in 1876, his vision was failing. This adds a layer of sadness to those final images. The "Dead Shot" was losing his most valuable asset.
The Gun Problem in Pictures
Check the waist. In many images of Wild Bill Hickok, he’s wearing his famous ivory-handled Colt 1851 Navy revolvers.
But look closer.
Sometimes, for promotional shots, he’d borrow props. There’s one famous image where he’s wearing leggings and has pistols tucked into a belt outside his coat. For years, people thought those were his Navies. Then, firearms experts looked at the grips in a high-res scan and realized they were actually 1860 Army Colts. Even a legend sometimes had to "fake it 'til you make it" for the camera.
👉 See also: Why Everyone Is Still Obsessing Over Maybelline SuperStay Skin Tint
How to Find Authentic Images Today
If you want to see the real stuff without the digital filters or AI enhancements, you’ve got to go to the sources.
- The Library of Congress: They hold several of the most famous Gurney prints.
- The Kansas Historical Society: Since he was a marshal in Hays and Abilene, they have the "lawman" era records and photos.
- The Adams Museum in Deadwood: They have the most intimate connection to his final days, including photos of his original grave site before it was moved.
Don't trust every "rare find" you see on social media. Most of them are just 1870s guys with big mustaches.
The real Hickok was a mix of vanity and violence. He was a guy who cared about his "red shirt with scarlet set in front" as much as he cared about his aim. When you look at his photos, you aren't just looking at a killer; you're looking at a man who was very carefully crafting the version of himself he wanted history to remember.
Your Next Steps for Research:
To get the full picture of Hickok’s visual history, visit the Digital Collections of the Nebraska State Historical Society. They house the original research materials from Joseph G. Rosa, the world's leading Hickok expert. If a photo isn't in Rosa's catalog, there is a 99% chance it’s a fake. For a hands-on experience, head to Deadwood, South Dakota, to see the bronze bust at Mount Moriah Cemetery—it’s based on the most accurate facial measurements available from his contemporary portraits.