Most people assume there is a "Vice President-in-waiting" just sitting in a hallway somewhere. They think the line of succession works like a set of falling dominoes. If the President goes, the VP steps up. So, logically, if the VP goes, the Speaker of the House just slides into that second chair, right?
Wrong.
That is not how it works. At all.
Actually, for a huge chunk of American history, if the Vice President died, the office just stayed empty. Period. No one replaced them until the next election. If the Vice President dies who becomes vice president today is a question answered by a relatively modern fix called the 25th Amendment, but the process is way more political—and potentially messy—than a simple list of names on a piece of paper.
The Empty Chair Problem
Before 1967, the United States was surprisingly casual about having a vacant Vice Presidency. It happened sixteen times. Sixteen! Sometimes the VP died in office, like George Clinton (who served under two different presidents and died in 1812) or Garret Hobart in 1899. Other times, the VP moved up to the Oval Office because the President died, leaving their old seat cold and empty.
When Harry Truman became President after FDR died in 1945, the Vice Presidency sat vacant for nearly four years. Think about that. For almost an entire presidential term, if something had happened to Truman, the country would have skipped straight to the Secretary of State (under the law at the time) because there simply was no Vice President.
It took the assassination of John F. Kennedy to finally scare Congress into action. When LBJ took the oath on Air Force One, he had a history of heart issues. The next two people in line were the Speaker of the House and the President pro tempore of the Senate, both of whom were in their 70s and 80s. The realization hit: we need a formal way to fill the "Number Two" spot. Fast.
How the 25th Amendment Actually Works
Section 2 of the 25th Amendment changed the game. It’s pretty short. Basically, it says that whenever there is a vacancy in the office of the Vice President, the President shall nominate a successor.
👉 See also: The Station Nightclub Fire and Great White: Why It’s Still the Hardest Lesson in Rock History
But it isn't a "done deal" just because the President picks someone.
The nominee has to be confirmed by a majority vote in both the House of Representatives and the Senate. This is the only time the House of Representatives has a say in who becomes the Vice President. Usually, the VP is elected by the Electoral College, but in this specific scenario, your local Congressman gets a vote on who is a heartbeat away from the presidency.
The Gerald Ford Precedent
We’ve actually seen this play out in real life. It’s not just a "what if" scenario for political geeks. In 1973, Spiro Agnew resigned because of a bribery scandal. Suddenly, Richard Nixon needed a new VP. He chose Gerald Ford, who was the House Minority Leader at the time. Ford was well-liked and cruised through the confirmation.
Then, less than a year later, Nixon resigned. Ford became President. Now the VP spot was empty again. Ford then nominated Nelson Rockefeller. Within a span of roughly 14 months, the U.S. had a President and a Vice President who were both appointed under the 25th Amendment. Neither of them had been elected to those offices by the American people. It was wild.
The Succession Act vs. The 25th Amendment
This is where people get confused. You’ve probably seen the "Line of Succession" list that starts with the Speaker of the House, then the President pro tempore of the Senate, then the Secretary of State, and so on.
That list only matters if the President and Vice President are both gone at the same time. Or, if the President dies and there is no Vice President currently in office.
If the Vice President dies, the Speaker of the House does not automatically become Vice President. They stay Speaker. They only move up if the President also dies or is removed before a new VP can be confirmed. It is a race against time. The President wants to get their nominee through Congress as fast as possible to ensure the line of succession is stable.
✨ Don't miss: The Night the Mountain Fell: What Really Happened During the Big Thompson Flood 1976
Imagine a divided government. If a Democratic President loses their VP, and the House is controlled by Republicans, that confirmation hearing is going to be a circus. The House could, theoretically, refuse to confirm anyone the President picks, hoping to keep the Speaker (their guy or gal) next in line for the presidency. It’s a constitutional loophole that hasn't been tested in a hostile, modern political climate, but it keeps constitutional scholars up at night.
Why Does It Take So Long?
You might think it would happen overnight. It doesn't. When Nelson Rockefeller was nominated, it took four months for him to be confirmed.
The FBI does a deep dive. They check taxes. They check past statements. They check everything. Congress holds televised hearings. In a world of 24-hour news cycles and social media, a modern-day VP appointment would likely be the most scrutinized event in history. Every "like" on a post from ten years ago would be brought up in the Senate Judiciary Committee.
What Happens to the "Duties" in the Meantime?
While the seat is empty, the Vice President's official duties basically go into limbo.
- The Tie-Breaker: The VP’s most famous job is breaking ties in the Senate. If the VP dies, that power is gone. A 50-50 tie in the Senate becomes a failed vote. The President pro tempore (usually the longest-serving member of the majority party) presides over the Senate, but they don't get an extra tie-breaking vote. They already have a vote as a Senator.
- The Cabinet Presence: The President loses their top advisor and "attack dog" for the administration’s policies.
- The 25th Amendment Trigger: If the President becomes incapacitated (like going under anesthesia for surgery) while the VP spot is vacant, things get weird. The Cabinet would have to work with the Speaker of the House to manage the temporary transfer of power.
Real-World Nuance: The "Heartbeat" Factor
The Vice Presidency is often mocked. John Adams called it "the most insignificant office that ever the invention of man contrived." But its importance is entirely based on the health of the person in the Oval Office.
If the Vice President dies who becomes vice president is a question that carries massive weight if the President is elderly or in poor health. The person chosen to fill that vacancy isn't just a backup; they are the immediate future of the party. Usually, the President will pick someone "safe"—a person who can get through Congress easily—rather than a firebrand who might get blocked by the opposition party.
When Ford picked Rockefeller, he was looking for someone with massive experience and "gravitas" to stabilize a country reeling from Watergate. Today, a President might look for someone who balances the ticket for the next election, even though they aren't being elected in the moment.
🔗 Read more: The Natascha Kampusch Case: What Really Happened in the Girl in the Cellar True Story
Is There a Secret List?
No. There is no secret envelope in the National Archives with a name on it. The President can pick literally anyone who meets the constitutional requirements (35 years old, natural-born citizen, 14 years a resident). They could pick their cousin. They could pick a sitting Governor. They could even pick the Speaker of the House, though the Speaker would have to resign their seat in Congress to take the job.
Honestly, the most likely candidates are usually sitting Senators or Governors. People with a "paper trail" of public service that makes the background check move faster.
Practical Realities for the Future
If we ever face this situation again, expect a total media blackout followed by an absolute firestorm of political maneuvering.
The moment a Vice President is declared deceased, the White House legal counsel immediately pulls the "25th Amendment Section 2" file. They have to. The stability of the government depends on that second slot being filled.
What should you watch for? Watch the Speaker of the House. Until a new VP is sworn in, that Speaker is the "Acting Vice President" in all but name, because they are the one who would take over if the President fell ill. That creates a massive shift in the power dynamic in Washington D.C.
Actionable Takeaways to Remember:
- The Speaker doesn't slide up: They stay in the House unless the President also dies.
- The President chooses: It is an appointment, not an election.
- Congress has the final say: Both the House and Senate must vote "Yes" by a simple majority.
- The seat stays empty: Until the vote happens, there is no Vice President.
- The 25th Amendment is the "How-To": Specifically Section 2, ratified in 1967.
If you want to see this in the raw text, go read the Constitution. It’s surprisingly straightforward for something that carries so much weight. The gap between a VP dying and a new one being sworn in is one of the most vulnerable periods for the American executive branch. Understanding that the process is a political appointment—not an automatic promotion—changes how you view every "Succession" chart you see in a textbook.