Honestly, if you grew up in the early 2000s, you probably have a hazy, fever-dream memory of a movie where a nerdy kid sells his soul to a guy in a suit just to get a girl to notice him. It wasn't a horror movie. It wasn't a gritty indie flick. It was a Showtime original that eventually migrated to the Disney Channel, and it was called I Was a Teenage Faust. Looking back on it now, it’s such a bizarre relic of a specific era of TV filmmaking.
The movie stars Josh Zuckerman as Brendan Willy, a loser—and let's be real, he's a total loser—who moves to a new town and immediately gets targeted by a demon. But this isn't your typical red-skinned, pitchfork-wielding devil. It’s Robert Loggia. Yeah, the guy from Big and Scarface. He plays Mr. Five, a high-level corporate soul-harvester who treats damnation like a mid-level marketing scheme.
The Weird Plot of I Was a Teenage Faust
Most people forget that this movie is actually based on a book by Bill Manhoff. It follows the classic Faustian bargain template but dips it in neon-colored 2002 aesthetics. Brendan is desperate. He wants to be popular. He wants the girl. Mr. Five offers him a deal: "Give me your soul, and I'll make you the coolest kid in school."
It’s a simple premise. But the execution is where it gets weird.
Instead of just becoming "cool" in a normal way, the movie uses these strange, almost surreal sequences to show Brendan's transformation. He gets the clothes, he gets the attitude, but the cost starts showing up in these tiny, localized ways. You see the internal rot of the bargain. It’s a kid’s movie, sure, but the underlying dread of Robert Loggia hovering over a teenager's shoulder is genuinely unsettling if you think about it for more than five seconds.
Why Robert Loggia Made the Movie
Loggia is the soul of this film. Without him, it’s just another forgotten made-for-TV movie. He brings this gravelly, intimidating energy to the role of Mr. Five that feels completely out of place in a movie aimed at pre-teens—and that’s why it works. He doesn't play it like a cartoon. He plays it like a guy who has closed a thousand deals and is bored by the morality of it all.
He’s basically a predatory lender for the afterlife.
📖 Related: Who is Really in the Enola Holmes 2 Cast? A Look at the Faces Behind the Mystery
Contrast that with Josh Zuckerman’s frantic, high-energy performance as Brendan. Zuckerman went on to do things like Sex Drive and Kyle XY, but here, he's the quintessential 2000s "dork." He has that specific frantic energy that actors like Justin Long mastered during the same period.
The Visuals and the "Disney-fication"
When I Was a Teenage Faust started airing on Disney Channel, it felt like the odd one out. It wasn't a "Disney Channel Original Movie" (DCOM) in the traditional sense because it was actually produced for Showtime. This meant it had a slightly darker, more cynical edge than something like The Luck of the Irish or Zenon: Girl of the 21st Century.
The colors are saturated. The fashion is... well, it's 2002. We're talking baggy cargo pants, spiked hair with too much gel, and those weird button-down shirts with flames on them. It captures a very specific moment in time where "cool" was a very loud, very ugly concept.
The special effects are also a trip. We’re talking early-2000s CGI. It’s clunky. It’s distracting. But in a weird way, the low-budget feel adds to the dreamlike quality of the movie. When things start going wrong for Brendan, the visual "glitches" in his life feel appropriately cheap and nasty.
The Moral Lessons (And Whether They Actually Work)
Like every movie aimed at kids, there's a lesson. Don't take shortcuts. Be yourself. Blah, blah, blah.
But I Was a Teenage Faust is a bit more cynical than its peers. It actually acknowledges that being "cool" is a performance. When Brendan gets what he wants, he realizes that the people who like the "new" him are shallow and boring. It’s a common trope, but the stakes—literally his eternal soul—make the teen drama feel much heavier.
👉 See also: Priyanka Chopra Latest Movies: Why Her 2026 Slate Is Riskier Than You Think
There's a scene near the end where things escalate, and we see the "soul collection" process. It’s surprisingly grim for a movie that aired on Sunday afternoons between Even Stevens marathons. It asks a question that most kids' movies avoid: Is the validation of your peers worth the erasure of your identity?
Finding the Movie Today
If you’re trying to find a high-definition 4K stream of this, good luck. It’s a ghost.
Because it was a Showtime/Disney co-production or acquisition, the rights are a mess. It occasionally pops up on obscure streaming services or is available for digital purchase in some territories, but it’s largely a "lost" movie for the general public. You usually have to dig through secondary markets or find old DVD copies on eBay.
It hasn't had the same cult resurgence as Hocus Pocus or The Nightmare Before Christmas. It’s stuck in that middle ground of "I think I saw that once" for millions of Millennials.
What We Get Wrong About the 2000s TV Era
We often look back at this era as being purely wholesome. We think of Lizzie McGuire and Raven Baxter. But there was this sub-genre of TV movies that were genuinely experimental and weird. I Was a Teenage Faust belongs to that group. It was part of a wave of content that wasn't afraid to be slightly grotesque or morally ambiguous.
It wasn't trying to sell a soundtrack. It wasn't trying to launch a pop star. It was just a weird, dark comedy about a kid who made a really bad deal.
✨ Don't miss: Why This Is How We Roll FGL Is Still The Song That Defines Modern Country
Final Thoughts on the Legacy of Brendan Willy
Brendan Willy isn't a hero. He’s a warning.
He represents that universal teenage feeling of being invisible. The movie works because we’ve all felt that. We’ve all wanted a "Mr. Five" to show up and give us the cheat codes to life. The fact that the movie ends the way it does—with a realization that the "deal" was always rigged—is a surprisingly sophisticated take for the genre.
If you happen to stumble across a copy of I Was a Teenage Faust, watch it. Don't expect a masterpiece. Expect a weird, grainy, Robert Loggia-fueled trip down a very specific memory lane. It’s a reminder that even in the world of teen comedies, there’s room for a little bit of darkness and a lot of gravelly-voiced demons.
How to Revisit the Faustian Trope
If this movie left a hole in your heart, you should check out the original source material or other variations of the Faust legend. It’s one of the oldest stories in the book for a reason.
- Read the original: Look for Christopher Marlowe’s Doctor Faustus. It’s way more intense than the movie, obviously, but you’ll see where all the tropes started.
- Check out modern takes: Movies like Bedazzled (the Brendan Fraser one) occupy a similar space of "comedy-horror soul-selling."
- Track down the DVD: If you’re a physical media collector, searching for the original Showtime DVD release is your best bet for seeing the movie in its intended format without the heavy Disney edits.
- Analyze the archetype: Notice how Mr. Five isn't a monster, but a businessman. This "Corporate Devil" trope has become the standard for modern storytelling because it’s much more relatable—and scarier—than a guy with horns.
The real value in revisiting these old TV movies isn't just nostalgia. It's seeing how we used to talk to kids about big ideas like greed, identity, and consequence. They don't really make 'em like this anymore, mostly because the "middle" of the film market—those mid-budget TV movies—has largely evaporated in favor of massive blockbusters or tiny indie projects.
Enjoy the kitsch, but pay attention to the subtext. There’s more going on in Brendan Willy’s suburban nightmare than you probably remembered from 2002.