In 1994, the world basically stopped. You probably remember the white Bronco, the gloves that didn't fit, and the media circus that turned a double murder trial into a prototype for modern reality TV. But right in the middle of that chaos, a book appeared that changed how we look at celebrity legal battles forever. It was titled I Want to Tell You.
People forget how massive this was.
O.J. Simpson didn't wait for the verdict to start talking to the public; he did it from a 6-by-9-foot cell in the Men’s Central Jail in Los Angeles. He was responding to more than 300,000 letters he’d received since his arrest. Think about that volume for a second. In an era before social media DMs or viral threads, that’s a staggering amount of physical mail. He teamed up with a writer named Lawrence Schiller to produce a response that was part diary, part legal defense, and part plea for sympathy.
What I Want to Tell You Was Really About
Honestly, if you pick up the book today, it feels like a time capsule of a very specific, very polarized moment in American history. It wasn't a traditional autobiography. It was a calculated move. Simpson used the pages to address his children, his late ex-wife Nicole Brown Simpson, and the public's perception of him as a "Jekyll and Hyde" personality.
He was fighting for his life. Literally.
The book is structured around his responses to those fan letters. Some people sent him prayers. Others sent him bile. He addressed the accusations of domestic violence by essentially downplaying them, a move that backfired with many readers but resonated with his core supporters at the time. He talked about his faith, his innocence, and his frustration with the media.
It sold like crazy.
When it hit the shelves in early 1995, it rocketed to the top of the New York Times Best Seller list. People were hungry for anything from the "Trial of the Century," and getting words directly from the man in the cell felt like a forbidden peek behind the curtain. But even then, critics were skeptical. Was this a genuine attempt to connect with fans, or a clever way to fund a defense team that was costing him millions?
✨ Don't miss: Who was the voice of Yoda? The real story behind the Jedi Master
The Financial Reality of a "Dream Team"
Let’s be real: legal fees for a case of that magnitude are astronomical.
We’re talking about Robert Shapiro, Johnnie Cochran, F. Lee Bailey, and Alan Dershowitz. You don't get that kind of talent for free. Reports from that era suggest Simpson received a massive advance for I Want to Tell You—somewhere in the neighborhood of $1 million.
That money didn't go to a retirement fund. It went into the engine of his defense.
It’s a weird ethical gray area that we still see today. When a high-profile defendant writes a book while the trial is ongoing, they are essentially monetizing their own prosecution. It’s a loop. The more the media talks about the crime, the more the book sells, and the more money the defendant has to fight the charges.
The Backlash and the Ethics of the "I Want to Tell You" Era
Not everyone was happy about the book's success. Far from it.
Families of the victims, Nicole Brown Simpson and Ron Goldman, were understandably horrified. To them, the book was a slap in the face—a way for a man they believed to be a killer to profit from the deaths of their loved ones.
This eventually led to a major legal shift.
You’ve probably heard of "Son of Sam" laws. These are statutes designed to prevent criminals from profiting from their crimes through book deals or movie rights. While Simpson was eventually acquitted in the criminal trial, the civil trial was a different story entirely. When he was found liable for the deaths in 1997, the Goldman family went after every cent he had, including future earnings.
- The Civil Judgment: $33.5 million.
- The Result: Simpson lost the rights to much of his memorabilia and future media profits.
- The Irony: Years later, when he tried to publish If I Did It, the Goldman family actually won the rights to the book itself, changing the cover to make the "If" tiny and the "I Did It" huge.
Why We Are Still Obsessed With This Narrative
Why does I Want to Tell You still matter in 2026?
Because it was the first time we saw a celebrity try to bypass the news and "speak his truth" directly to the audience during an active criminal case. Today, we see this every hour on Instagram or X (formerly Twitter). A celebrity gets cancelled or arrested, and they immediately post a Notes app apology or a long-form video.
🔗 Read more: Not the Nine O'Clock News: Why the Satirical Giant Still Matters
Simpson did it with a 200-page hardcover book.
The book also highlights the massive racial and social divide of the 90s. In the text, Simpson leans heavily into the idea that he is a victim of a system that wants to see a successful Black man fail. Whether you believe he was guilty or innocent, you can't deny that he tapped into a very real vein of public distrust toward the LAPD—distrust that had been boiling over since the Rodney King beating just a few years prior.
The Lawrence Schiller Connection
Lawrence Schiller, the guy who helped Simpson write the book, is a fascinating figure in his own right. He wasn't just a ghostwriter; he was a master of "checkbook journalism." He had a knack for getting close to people in the middle of national tragedies. He did it with Gary Gilmore (the subject of The Executioner's Song) and he did it again here.
Schiller’s involvement added a layer of professional polish to Simpson’s jailhouse musings. It made the book readable, even if it was deeply uncomfortable. He spent hours behind glass at the jail, taking notes and recording Simpson’s thoughts. The result was a narrative that felt intimate, even though it was highly curated by a team of lawyers and PR experts.
The Legacy of the "Jailhouse Memoir"
If you look at the true crime genre today, you can see the fingerprints of I Want to Tell You everywhere.
We love the "inside look." We want to hear from the person in the orange jumpsuit.
But there’s a cost.
When we consume these stories, we often forget the victims. In the case of this book, the focus was entirely on O.J.—his feelings, his struggles, his "hell" in a jail cell. The actual lives lost became footnotes to his personal drama. It’s a reminder that true crime isn't just entertainment; it’s a reflection of real-world trauma.
💡 You might also like: New Movies in Theatre: What Most People Get Wrong About This Month's Picks
What Most People Get Wrong About the Book
Most people think the book was a confession. It wasn't. Not even close.
It was a PR campaign.
If you go back and read it now, it's actually quite dry in parts. He talks about missing his kids. He talks about his golf game. He talks about how much he loves his friends. It was designed to make him look like a regular guy who was caught in a nightmare, not a man who had allegedly committed a violent crime.
It worked on some people. It didn't work on others.
But it definitely sold books.
How to Approach This Content Today
If you’re a true crime fan or a student of media history, looking back at I Want to Tell You is essential. It’s the "Patient Zero" of celebrity crisis management. To understand how we got to the current state of media—where every legal battle is a "docuseries" and every defendant is an "influencer"—you have to look at what Simpson did in 1995.
Actionable Insights for the Modern Reader
If you're digging into this era of history or dealing with high-profile narratives, keep these points in mind:
- Question the Source: Always ask why a book is being released during a trial. Is it for "the truth," or is it for the legal defense fund?
- Look for the Gaps: In any memoir, what the author doesn't say is often more important than what they do say. In Simpson's book, the lack of specific detail about the night of the murders is glaring.
- Context is Everything: You can't understand this book without understanding the 1992 L.A. Riots. The racial tension of the city was the oxygen the trial breathed.
- Media Literacy: Recognize that "direct access" to a celebrity is almost always filtered through a team of professionals. Even a "raw" letter from jail has been vetted by a lawyer.
The story of I Want to Tell You is ultimately a story about power. The power to control a narrative, the power of celebrity to influence public opinion, and the power of the dollar to buy the best defense possible. It remains a chilling reminder of how easily the line between justice and entertainment can be blurred.
If you want to understand the modern media landscape, stop looking at TikTok for a second and look back at the 1990s. Everything we’re seeing now started right there, in a jail cell, with a man who had something he wanted to tell us.