Most post-apocalyptic movies start with a bang, a scream, or a frantic montage of news anchors looking terrified. Not this one. I Think We’re Alone Now film, directed by Reed Morano, chooses a radically different path. It opens with silence. Actually, it opens with the sound of a man cleaning.
Peter Dinklage plays Del. He’s a librarian. He lives in a world where everyone else is dead. He doesn’t seem particularly upset about it. In fact, he’s thriving in the quiet, meticulously cataloging the abandoned houses of his small town and burying the bodies with a methodical, almost liturgical precision. It’s weirdly soothing. Then Elle Fanning’s character, Grace, shows up and ruins his perfect, lonely ecosystem.
People usually expect zombies or radioactive mutants when they hear "end of the world." You won’t find those here. Instead, Morano gives us a character study wrapped in a beautiful, somber aesthetic that feels more like a painting than a blockbuster. If you’re looking for The Walking Dead, you’re going to be frustrated. But if you want to explore the psychology of isolation, it’s a masterclass.
The Quiet Brilliance of Del’s Routine
Del is a fascinating protagonist because he is essentially a misanthrope who got his wish. He spends his days going house to house. He removes the dead. He cleans the floors. He takes one "memento" from each home—usually a photograph—and files it away in the local library. It’s a bizarrely bureaucratic way to handle the extinction of the human race.
Dinklage is incredible here. He uses his face more than his voice. You can see the relief in his eyes when he’s alone and the visceral irritation when Grace appears in a cloud of fireworks and noise. She is everything he hates: loud, messy, and desperate for connection.
The film makes a bold choice by not explaining how everyone died. We see the aftermath—the bodies slumped over dinner tables or tucked into beds—but there's no mention of a virus, a war, or an alien invasion. This lack of exposition drives some viewers crazy. Honestly, it makes total sense for the story. If you’re the last person on earth, does the "why" even matter anymore? You just have to deal with the "now."
📖 Related: How Danny DeVito Saved It's Always Sunny Season 2 and Changed TV Forever
Why the Second Act Shift Is So Polarizing
About two-thirds of the way through, the I Think We’re Alone Now film takes a massive left turn. It shifts from a quiet, Two-Hander drama into something that feels like a sci-fi conspiracy thriller. This is where most of the critical debate happens.
We meet characters played by Charlotte Gainsbourg and Paul Giamatti. Suddenly, the isolated town isn't so isolated. We learn about a "colony" that has found a way to "cure" grief. It’s a jarring transition. Some critics, like those at The Hollywood Reporter during its Sundance premiere, noted that this shift feels like it belongs in a different movie entirely.
I sort of get why Morano and writer Mike Makowsky went this way. The film is investigating whether true connection is possible without pain. The colony represents a forced, artificial happiness—a lobotomized version of society. Del, despite his grumpiness, eventually realizes that Grace’s chaotic presence is more "real" than a sterilized utopia. But man, it’s a weird pivot. It changes the pacing from a slow simmer to a frantic escape.
The Cinematography of Reed Morano
You can’t talk about this movie without talking about how it looks. Reed Morano is a cinematographer by trade (she worked on The Handmaid’s Tale), and she served as her own DP on this project. It shows.
📖 Related: Jennifer Chiaverini Order of Books: How to Navigate the Elm Creek Universe Without Getting Lost
The lighting is almost entirely naturalistic.
Dark.
Mood-driven.
The way she uses the 1.85:1 aspect ratio makes the empty houses feel both cavernous and claustrophobic at the same time.
There’s a specific shot of Del standing in the library stacks that looks like a Rembrandt. It’s gorgeous. She uses shallow depth of field to keep the focus tight on the emotional friction between Del and Grace, making the empty world outside feel like a blurry afterthought.
Common Misconceptions About the Movie
- It’s an action movie. It definitely isn't. There are no chase scenes until the very end, and even those are low-energy compared to Hollywood standards.
- It’s a romance. Not really. While Del and Grace form a bond, it’s more about the necessity of companionship than "falling in love." It’s a platonic, survival-based intimacy.
- The ending is a cliffhanger. While it leaves some things open, the emotional arc of Del choosing to be "with" someone rather than just "existing" is a complete resolution.
Comparing It to Other "Last Man" Stories
Think about I Am Legend. In that film, Will Smith is a hero trying to save the world. In the I Think We’re Alone Now film, Del isn't trying to save anything. He’s just a guy who finally found a job he’s good at: being the world’s janitor.
It shares more DNA with movies like Z for Zachariah or even the quiet moments of The Road. It’s about the mundane reality of the apocalypse. What do you eat? How do you get batteries? What do you do with all the trash? Morano obsesses over these details, which gives the film a grounded, tactile feel that many sci-fi movies lack.
Actionable Insights for Viewers
If you haven't seen the film yet, or if you watched it and felt confused, here is how to actually digest what Morano is putting down:
1. Watch the background details.
The film doesn't use dialogue to explain the world. Look at the photos Del collects. Look at the way the houses are staged. The story of the town is told through the set design, not the script.
2. Focus on the theme of "Curation."
Del is a librarian. He wants to organize the world. Grace is an agent of chaos. The movie is essentially an argument between order and life. Order is dead; life is messy. To choose life, Del has to accept the mess.
3. Adjust your expectations for the ending.
Don't expect a scientific explanation for the "procedure" introduced in the third act. View it as a metaphor for how people try to bypass the hard work of mourning. It’s social commentary, not hard science fiction.
4. Listen to the sound design.
The absence of sound is a character in itself. Use a good pair of headphones or a decent soundbar. The subtle creaks of the houses and the wind are intentional. They emphasize the "alone" part of the title.
The I Think We’re Alone Now film is a moody, difficult, and visually arresting piece of cinema. It’s not for everyone. If you hate slow-burns, you’ll probably turn it off in twenty minutes. But if you’ve ever felt like the world was too loud and just wanted everyone to go away so you could finally hear yourself think, this movie will speak to you in a way few others do. It’s a quiet film about a quiet man that makes a surprisingly loud statement about why we need each other, even when we wish we didn't.
To get the most out of your viewing, pair it with Morano’s other work to see her stylistic evolution. It's a specific vibe. Lean into the stillness. Stop looking for the monsters and start looking at the man holding the shovel. That’s where the real story lives.