You’re sitting on the couch, scrolling through Instagram, and there it is. A golden retriever puppy with paws too big for its body, tripping over a tennis ball. Your brain immediately short-circuits. You think, i should get a dog. It feels like a biological imperative, a sudden, crushing need for a tail-wagging shadow to follow you from the kitchen to the bathroom. Honestly, we’ve all been there. It’s a primal urge. But before you head to the local shelter or start messaging breeders on AKC Marketplace, we need to talk about the stuff that isn’t in the cute 15-second clips.
Owning a dog is basically like adopting a perpetual toddler that never learns how to use a microwave or put on its own shoes. It’s a massive life pivot.
The "I Should Get a Dog" Internal Debate
Most people start this journey by weighing the pros and cons in a really lopsided way. They think about hiking trips. They imagine crisp autumn walks where the dog perfectly heels by their side. They don't think about the 3:00 AM "I just ate a sock" emergency vet visits or the way a house smells when a wet Labrador decides to dry itself on the velvet sofa.
There's real science behind why you feel this way, though. According to a study published in AERA Open, brief interactions with dogs can significantly reduce cortisol levels. It's not just in your head; they actually make you feel better. But "feeling better" comes at a price that isn't just financial. It’s a time tax. If you work sixty hours a week and your idea of a hobby is sleeping, a high-energy Belgian Malinois is going to turn your life into a living nightmare. You have to match the dog to the reality of your Tuesday afternoons, not your Saturday morning fantasies.
The Financial Reality Nobody Likes Talking About
Let's get tactile with the numbers. According to Rover and the ASPCA, the first year of dog ownership can easily swing between $1,000 and $4,000. That’s not a typo. You’ve got the adoption fee or purchase price, sure. But then there’s the "startup costs." Crate. Leash. High-quality kibble—because cheap corn-filler food just leads to more expensive vet visits later. Heartworm prevention is non-negotiable. Flea and tick meds are a monthly tax.
✨ Don't miss: Williams Sonoma Deer Park IL: What Most People Get Wrong About This Kitchen Icon
And then there's the "oops" fund.
If your dog develops a penchant for swallowing rocks or gets a hot spot that turns into a systemic infection, you're looking at a $500 bill just to walk through the door of an emergency clinic. I once knew a guy who spent $3,000 because his Beagle decided a box of dark chocolate truffles looked like a snack. He still says i should get a dog was the best thought he ever had, but his bank account might disagree. You need to be financially solvent enough to handle a sudden catastrophe without it ruining your life.
Lifestyle Alignment or Lifestyle Enslavement?
You have to be honest. Are you an active person, or do you want to be an active person? These are two very different things. Buying a Border Collie because you want to start running is a recipe for a destroyed linoleum floor. If you aren't already hitting the trails three times a week, a high-drive working dog won't change your DNA; it’ll just get frustrated and start herding your cats or chewing the drywall.
Consider your living situation.
🔗 Read more: Finding the most affordable way to live when everything feels too expensive
- Apartment Dwellers: You're looking at four elevator trips a day, rain or shine.
- The Homebody: A Greyhound is actually a "45-mph couch potato" and might fit you perfectly.
- The Social Butterfly: If you’re never home, who is the dog hanging out with?
Dogs are pack animals. They don't handle isolation well. Separation anxiety is one of the leading reasons dogs are returned to shelters. It manifests as howling, scratching through doors, and self-mutilation. If your career requires you to be in an office from 8:00 AM to 6:00 PM, you’re going to need to budget for doggy daycare or a professional walker. That's another $20 to $40 a day. Do the math. It adds up faster than a car payment.
The Shelter vs. Breeder Minefield
This is where things get heated in the dog world. There’s a lot of "Adopt, Don't Shop" rhetoric, which is noble but sometimes lacks nuance. Shelters are overflowing, especially with bully breed mixes and hounds. If you go the shelter route, you are saving a life. That’s a fact. But you are also taking on a bit of a genetic mystery box. You might get the world’s sweetest soul, or you might get a dog with deep-seated trauma that requires thousands of dollars in professional behavior modification.
On the flip side, a responsible breeder—and I mean someone who does OFA heart and hip clearances, not a backyard breeder on Craigslist—offers predictability. You know the temperament. You know the health history. But you’ll pay $2,000+ upfront for that peace of mind.
If you’re sitting there thinking i should get a dog, ask yourself if you have the patience for a project. A rescue dog is often a project. A puppy from a breeder is a blank slate, but that slate needs to be written on every single hour for the first six months. Puppies are basically land sharks. They bite. They pee on your favorite rug. They wake you up at dawn.
💡 You might also like: Executive desk with drawers: Why your home office setup is probably failing you
Why Breed Specificity Actually Matters
Don't buy a dog because of how it looks. Just don't.
Huskies are beautiful, but they are loud, independent, and will escape a fenced yard just for the sport of it. Great Danes are majestic, but they have short lifespans and their "bloat" surgery can cost as much as a used Honda. You need to research the "purpose" of the breed. Goldens were meant to retrieve. Pointers were meant to point. Terriers were meant to kill vermin. If you don't give them a job, they will invent one. Usually, that job involves deconstructing your pillows.
The Impact on Your Mental Health (The Good and Bad)
We talk a lot about how dogs fix depression. It’s a common trope. And yeah, having a creature that thinks you are the center of the universe is a powerful antidepressant. But "Puppy Blues" are a very real phenomenon. The sleep deprivation and the sudden loss of freedom can trigger a massive spike in anxiety.
You can't just go to happy hour on a whim anymore. You can't take a weekend trip to Vegas without planning two weeks in advance for boarding. Your life becomes tethered to a biological clock that needs to go outside every few hours. For some, this structure is a godsend. It forces them to get out of bed. For others, it feels like a cage.
Practical Steps Before Pulling the Trigger
If you’re still convinced that i should get a dog, don't go to a pet store tomorrow. Start slow.
- Foster first. This is the ultimate "try before you buy" move. Shelters are desperate for fosters. You’ll see what it’s like to have a dog in your space without the 15-year commitment.
- Volunteer at a local rescue. Spend a Saturday morning cleaning kennels and walking high-energy dogs. If you still want one after being jumped on and covered in dog hair, you might be ready.
- Audit your calendar. Look at the last three months. How many nights were you away from home for more than 8 hours? If the answer is "most of them," a dog isn't fair to the dog.
- Talk to a trainer. Not a salesperson, a trainer. Ask them which breeds they see the most for "aggression" or "anxiety." Their answers might surprise you.
- Set up a "Dog Fund." Put $200 a month into a separate savings account for six months. If you miss that money or can't afford to set it aside, you can't afford the dog.
The reality of saying i should get a dog is that you are choosing to break your own heart eventually. You are signing up for a decade of joy followed by a very specific, crushing kind of grief. But most of us who have done it—who have dealt with the ruined carpets and the 6:00 AM walks in the freezing rain—would tell you it's the only way to live. Just make sure you’re choosing the dog for who they are, not just for how they look in a photo.
Begin by reaching out to a breed-specific rescue for a conversation. They know their dogs better than anyone and will be brutally honest about whether your lifestyle matches the needs of the animal. If you can handle the honesty, you're halfway there.