It’s a Tuesday night and you’re staring at a text message that makes your blood boil, yet your heart do a weird little flip at the same time. You’re annoyed. Actually, you’re furious. But if they asked you to come over right now, you’d probably put on your shoes. This isn't just some rom-com trope or a catchy song lyric by Gnash or Olivia Rodrigo. It’s a physiological state. I hate you but i love you is arguably the most exhausting sentence in the human language because it forces two competing neural pathways to fire at the exact same time. It feels like a glitch in the matrix of your own brain.
Most people think love and hate are opposites. They aren't.
Indifference is the opposite of love. Hate is just love that has lost its way, or rather, it's a form of high-stakes emotional investment. When you "hate" someone you love, you are acknowledging that they have the power to hurt you. If you didn't care, you wouldn't bother with the anger. You'd just be bored.
The Neuroscience of Ambivalence
Brains are messy. Dr. Helen Fisher, a biological anthropologist who has spent decades scanning brains in love, found something fascinating about the nature of rejection and attachment. When we are in that "i hate you but i love you" phase, the brain's reward system—the ventral tegmental area—is still chugging along. It’s still craving that person like a hit of dopamine. But simultaneously, the amygdala is screaming "danger" because that person has become a threat to your emotional stability.
You’re basically an addict who is mad at the drug.
- Dopamine keeps you hooked on the "love" part.
- Cortisol floods your system during the "hate" part.
- Oxytocin makes you want to cuddle even after a screaming match.
This creates a state called cognitive dissonance. Your brain hates holding two contradictory beliefs at once. It wants to pick a side. "Is he a monster or is he my soulmate?" Usually, the answer is neither, but try telling your prefrontal cortex that when it’s 2:00 AM and you’re doom-scrolling through their Instagram.
Why High-Conflict Relationships Feel Addictive
There is a reason why "make-up sex" is a thing. It’s not just about the physical act; it’s about the massive hormonal crash that follows a spike in stress. When you argue, your body goes into fight-or-flight mode. When you reconcile, the relief is so intense it feels like euphoria. This cycle—the intermittent reinforcement—is the same mechanism that makes gambling or slot machines so hard to quit.
💡 You might also like: Why the Long Head of the Tricep is the Secret to Huge Arms
Honestly, it’s a trap.
You start to associate the "hate" (the conflict) with the inevitable high of the "love" (the resolution). Over time, a calm, stable relationship might even start to feel boring. You’ve conditioned yourself to need the fire to feel the warmth. This is often where toxic patterns take root. If you grew up in a household where love was conditional or explosive, your "picker" might be calibrated to find this chaos normal. It’s familiar. And the brain loves what is familiar, even if it’s miserable.
The Role of Relational Ambivalence
Psychologists call this relational ambivalence. It’s the simultaneous existence of positive and negative feelings toward a target. It’s not that you feel 50% love and 50% hate. It’s that you feel 100% of both, depending on the minute. Research published in the Journal of Personality and Social Psychology suggests that ambivalent relationships are actually more taxing on our cardiovascular systems than purely negative ones.
Why? Because you never know which version of the person you’re going to get.
In a purely "bad" relationship, you can build a wall. You can protect yourself. But when it’s "i hate you but i love you," you keep the door cracked open. You’re constantly scanning for signs of hope, which keeps your nervous system in a state of hyper-vigilance. It’s exhausting. It ages you.
Culture, Music, and the Romancing of Pain
We have to talk about how media sells this to us. From Wuthering Heights to Euphoria, we are told that "real" love is painful. We see characters screaming "I hate you!" before a dramatic kiss. It’s cinematic. It’s great for ratings.
📖 Related: Why the Dead Bug Exercise Ball Routine is the Best Core Workout You Aren't Doing Right
In the real world? It’s usually just a sign of poor boundary-setting.
Take the song "i hate u, i love u" by Gnash and Olivia O'Brien. It went viral because it tapped into that specific post-breakup purgatory where you want the person to be happy, but also kind of want them to stub their toe every single day. It’s a very human, very petty, very real feeling. But we have to distinguish between the feeling and the lifestyle.
Feeling "i hate you but i love you" during a rough patch in a 10-year marriage is normal. Living in that state for three years with a casual partner you met on an app is a choice. A painful one.
When It Becomes Toxic
How do you know if you're just having a "human moment" or if you're in a trauma bond?
- The Ratio: If the "hate" moments outnumber the "love" moments four to one, the math isn't mathing.
- The Cost: Are you losing friends? Is your work suffering? Is your self-esteem in the basement?
- The Change: Do you actually believe things will get better, or are you just waiting for the next "high"?
Trauma bonds are built on the back of "i hate you but i love you." They occur when an abuser or a highly inconsistent person provides sporadic reinforcement. You become tethered to the person who is hurting you because they are also the only one who can provide the comfort to stop the hurt. It’s a circular nightmare.
Moving Toward Emotional Clarity
You can't just flip a switch and stop loving someone. That’s a myth. Love doesn't die; it usually just gets buried under a mountain of resentment. To move forward, you have to stop trying to resolve the contradiction.
👉 See also: Why Raw Milk Is Bad: What Enthusiasts Often Ignore About The Science
Accept that you feel both.
"I love this person, AND they are bad for my mental health."
"I hate how they treated me, AND I miss their laugh."
Both are true. Once you stop fighting the "hate" side of the coin, it loses some of its power. You stop feeling guilty for the anger and stop feeling stupid for the love.
Actionable Steps to Break the Cycle
If you’re stuck in this loop, you need a circuit breaker. Your brain is currently running a program it can’t exit.
- The 72-Hour Rule: When you’re in the "hate" phase and want to send a scathing text or make a massive life decision, wait 72 hours. Let the cortisol levels drop. See if you still feel the same way when your heart rate is below 90 bpm.
- Audit the Evidence: Write down the last five major interactions. Not the ones you imagined, but the ones that actually happened. Look at the cold, hard data of your relationship.
- Externalize the Feeling: Talk to a therapist or a very honest friend. Sometimes hearing yourself say "I hate them but I love them" out loud makes you realize how much energy you’re wasting on someone who hasn't earned that level of emotional complexity.
- Focus on Self-Regulation: When the "i hate you" part flares up, it’s usually because a boundary was crossed. Instead of focusing on them, focus on the boundary. What do you need to do to feel safe right now?
The goal isn't necessarily to stop loving the person. It’s to start loving yourself more. You have to reach a point where your need for peace outweighs your desire for the "hit" of their affection. It’s a slow process. It’s messy. You will probably relapse and send a "miss you" text after a week of "hating" them. That’s okay. Just don't let the grey zone become your permanent residence.
Real love shouldn't feel like a war zone. It should feel like a safe harbor. If you’re constantly fighting for your life emotionally, it might be time to admit that while the love is real, the cost is simply too high. Determine what your "non-negotiables" are and stick to them, even when the dopamine is telling you to stay. Change happens when the pain of staying becomes greater than the fear of leaving. Observe your patterns, acknowledge the duality of your feelings, and prioritize your own nervous system over a chaotic connection.