The thought usually hits at 2:00 AM. Or maybe it’s while you’re watching a stranger’s toddler have a total meltdown in the middle of a Target aisle. You see the chaos, the sticky fingers, and the sheer exhaustion on the parent’s face, and instead of running for the hills, a weirdly calm voice in your head whispers: I could be a good mother. It’s not always a biological ticking clock. Sometimes it’s just a realization that you have enough love, patience, or maybe just enough snacks in your bag to handle it.
But then the doubt creeps in. How do you actually know? We live in an era where parenting is performative. Instagram makes it look like a beige-toned dream, while Reddit threads make it sound like a literal descent into madness.
The truth is way more boring and way more complicated than that.
The myth of the maternal instinct
Let’s get one thing straight. This idea that women are born with a "maternal instinct" that turns on like a light switch is mostly nonsense. Scientists have looked into this. It’s a mix of hormones—mostly oxytocin—and social conditioning. You don’t just wake up knowing how to swaddle a human burrito. You learn it.
People who say "I could be a good mother" often worry because they don't feel that "glow" yet. Honestly? That’s normal. Dr. Sarah Johns, an evolutionary anthropology expert, has noted that the bond often develops through caretaking, not just through some magical cosmic connection at birth. If you're worried about whether you have the "right" instincts, you're probably already ahead of the game. It shows you're thinking about the child's needs rather than just your own ego.
Why the phrase "I could be a good mother" feels so heavy
There’s a specific type of grief in the "could." It’s a conditional statement. It implies a choice, a delay, or maybe a barrier. Maybe you haven't found the right partner. Maybe your bank account looks like a crime scene. Or maybe you're just not sure if you want to trade your Saturday morning lie-ins for 6:00 AM screenings of Bluey.
Choice is a luxury our grandmothers didn't really have. They just... did it.
Now, we analyze. We look at the statistics. We see that the average cost of raising a child to 18 in the U.S. is now well over $300,000, according to Brookings Institution estimates. That’s a lot of pressure. It’s enough to make anyone second-guess that quiet inner voice. You start wondering if being "good" at it is enough when the world feels like it’s on fire half the time.
The "Good Enough" Mother
Ever heard of D.W. Winnicott? He was a British pediatrician and psychoanalyst who coined the term "the good-enough mother." He basically argued that children actually benefit from their parents being imperfect. If you’re perfect, your kid never learns how to deal with disappointment or reality.
🔗 Read more: Finding the Right Word That Starts With AJ for Games and Everyday Writing
So, if you’re sitting there thinking you could be a good mother because you’re patient and kind, cool. But if you’re thinking you’d be a bad one because you lose your temper when you’re hungry or you hate playing with blocks, take a breath. Being "good" isn't about being a saint. It’s about being present. It’s about being a solid "B+" parent.
What actually makes someone "good" at this?
It isn't the organic kale or the wooden toys. It’s emotional regulation.
Can you handle being screamed at by a person who doesn't understand how gravity works? Can you apologize when you mess up? Dr. Dan Siegel, a clinical professor of psychiatry at UCLA, talks a lot about "mindsight" and the importance of repair in relationships. If you can mess up, realize it, and fix the connection with the kid, you’re doing it right.
That’s the secret.
People who are terrified of being bad mothers are usually the ones with the most potential. The ones who think they’ll be perfect? They’re the ones in for a very rude awakening.
The lifestyle shift nobody tells you about
Let’s talk about the loss of self. This is where the "I could be a good mother" sentiment hits a wall of reality. You will lose yourself. For a while, anyway. Your identity gets subsumed by this tiny, loud creature.
- You'll find yourself Googling "color of baby poop meaning" at 3:00 AM.
- Your hobbies will become "sleeping" and "showering alone."
- You will develop a weirdly intense relationship with your coffee maker.
It’s a transition. Sociologists call it "matrescence." Like adolescence, it’s a massive hormonal and identity shift. It’s awkward. It’s uncomfortable. It doesn't mean you're failing; it means you're growing into a new version of yourself.
Breaking the generational cycle
A lot of people feel like they could be a good mother because they want to "do it differently." They saw what their own parents did—the yelling, the emotional distance, the "because I said so" attitude—and they want to break that chain.
💡 You might also like: Is there actually a legal age to stay home alone? What parents need to know
This is called "breaking the cycle." It’s hard work. It requires therapy, self-awareness, and a lot of deep breathing. But it’s also one of the most powerful reasons to want to be a parent. You’re not just raising a kid; you’re healing a family line.
But don't put too much pressure on yourself to be the "healer." Sometimes being a good mother is just making sure the kid feels safe enough to tell you when they've messed up. That’s it. That’s the whole job.
The external noise
Social media is a liar.
I’ll say it again. It’s a liar.
When you see those "Get Ready With Me: Mom Edition" videos where the house is white and the kids are wearing linen, remember that there is likely a pile of dirty laundry just out of frame. Probably some dried spaghetti on the floor, too. Comparing your internal "could be" to someone else’s curated "is" will drive you crazy.
Real parenting is gross. It’s loud. It involves a lot of fluids you’d rather not think about. If you can look at that reality and still think "Yeah, I could do that," then you’re probably right.
When the "could" becomes a "should" or "won't"
It’s also okay if "I could be a good mother" is just a realization and not a career path. You can have the skills and the heart for it and still choose not to do it. Our culture treats motherhood as the ultimate destination for women, but it’s just one path.
You can be a "good mother" to your friends, your pets, your community, or your creative projects. The nurturing energy is the same.
📖 Related: The Long Haired Russian Cat Explained: Why the Siberian is Basically a Living Legend
If you’re struggling with the decision, stop looking at the "shoulds." Look at the "wants." Do you want the life that comes with the child, or do you just want the validation of being "good" at something? There’s no wrong answer, but you have to be honest with yourself.
Actionable steps for the "maybe" phase
If you’re stuck in the "I could be a good mother" loop, stop theorizing and start testing the waters in low-stakes ways.
1. Borrow a kid. Seriously. Offer to babysit for a weekend for a friend who is drowning. Don't just do the "fun" stuff. Do the bedtime routine. Do the "I don't want to eat my peas" negotiation. See how you feel when you're tired and covered in crumbs.
2. Audit your patience. For the next week, track how you react when things go wrong. If you get cut off in traffic or your laptop freezes, what’s your baseline? Motherhood is a marathon of minor inconveniences. Developing your "patience muscle" now is the best prep you can do.
3. Talk to the "regretful" parents. We always talk to the people who say "it’s the best thing I ever did." Seek out the honest ones. Read the stories of people who love their kids but hate the job of parenting. It gives you a balanced view of the "could."
4. Check your "why." Grab a notebook. Write down why you think you’d be a good mother. If the reasons are all about how the child will make you feel (loved, needed, successful), dig deeper. If the reasons are about what you want to give or the human you want to help shape, you’re on the right track.
5. Financial reality check. Don't let it scare you, but let it inform you. Look at childcare costs in your specific zip code. Knowing the numbers takes the "phantom" fear out of the equation and replaces it with a plan.
The feeling that you could be a good mother isn't a mandate from the universe. It’s just an invitation to look at your capacity for love and resilience. Whether you choose to act on it or keep it as a quiet, comforting truth about yourself, it’s a testament to who you are as a person right now. You don't need a child to prove you’re nurturing, and you don't need to be perfect to be a parent.
Basically, trust your gut, but keep your eyes wide open. Motherhood isn't a test you pass or fail; it’s a relationship you build, one messy day at a time.