It’s a specific kind of cold. You’re standing in the kitchen, or maybe sitting on the edge of the bed, and the person who is supposed to be your "safe place" says something—or does something—that rips the floor out from under you. Your brain starts screaming i cant believe youre hurting me on a loop. It’s not just drama. It's physiological.
Science actually backs this up. When we experience social rejection or betrayal by a loved one, the brain processes that pain using the same neural pathways it uses for physical injury. Specifically, the dorsal anterior cingulate cortex and the anterior insula light up. These are the same spots that fire off when you break an arm or burn your hand on a stove.
Pain is pain.
The Science Behind Why It Hurts So Much
Betrayal isn't just a "bummer." It’s a biological crisis. Evolutionarily, humans survived by staying in the pack. If the person closest to you—your mate, your primary attachment figure—turns on you, your DNA interprets that as a literal death threat.
The phrase i cant believe youre hurting me is often the first thing someone says during a discovery of infidelity or a sudden, cruel breakup because the prefrontal cortex is struggling to reconcile two conflicting "facts." Fact A: I love this person. Fact B: This person is causing me agony. The brain essentially glitches.
Dr. Edward Smith at Columbia University famously did a study involving fMRI scans of people who had recently been through unwanted breakups. He showed them photos of their exes. The results were staggering. The brain's response wasn't just "sadness"; it was a full-blown "ouch" response.
🔗 Read more: Ingestion of hydrogen peroxide: Why a common household hack is actually dangerous
When Trust Becomes a Weapon
We give people a map of our insecurities. That’s what intimacy is. You tell your partner where the bruises are so they don’t step on them. But when things go south, that map becomes a tactical guide for how to destroy you.
When you find yourself whispering i cant believe youre hurting me, you’re often reacting to the violation of an unspoken contract. Most of us operate under the "Assumption of Benevolence." We assume our partners want the best for us. When they choose their own ego, a secret life, or a sharp tongue over your wellbeing, that assumption shatters.
It's messy.
Sometimes the hurt isn't a massive explosion. It’s the "slow bleed." It’s the passive-aggressive comments about your weight, the way they roll their eyes when you talk about your dreams, or the tiny, daily dismissals that add up until you're a shell of yourself.
The Physical Fallout of Emotional Betrayal
Stress isn't just in your head. It’s in your gut. It’s in your heartbeat.
💡 You might also like: Why the EMS 20/20 Podcast is the Best Training You’re Not Getting in School
- Takotsubo Cardiomyopathy: This is the medical term for "Broken Heart Syndrome." It’s a temporary heart condition that’s often brought on by stressful situations, like the death of a loved one or a massive betrayal. The heart muscle actually changes shape.
- Cortisol Spikes: When you’re thinking i cant believe youre hurting me, your body is flooded with cortisol. Prolonged exposure ruins your sleep, messes with your digestion, and can even lead to skin breakouts or hair loss.
- The Vagus Nerve: This nerve connects your brain to your heart and digestive tract. When you feel that "pit in your stomach" after an argument, that’s your vagus nerve reacting to the emotional trauma.
Honestly, we don't talk enough about how "heartbreak" is a literal systemic inflammation of the body. You aren't being "sensitive." You're being human.
Navigating the "I Cant Believe Youre Hurting Me" Cycle
If you’re stuck in this cycle, you’ve probably noticed that the person hurting you often uses "DARVO." This is a term coined by Dr. Jennifer Freyd. It stands for Deny, Attack, and Reverse Victim and Offender.
You say: "You’re hurting me."
They say: "I wouldn't have to act this way if you weren't so needy."
Suddenly, you’re apologizing for being hurt. It’s gaslighting 101. It’s a way to deflect accountability and keep you off balance. When you can’t believe they are hurting you, your brain is actually looking for an excuse for them. You want to believe they’re "just stressed" or "had a bad childhood."
While those things might be true, they don't change the fact that your nervous system is in a state of alarm.
📖 Related: High Protein in a Blood Test: What Most People Get Wrong
Rebuilding After the Break
Recovery isn't a straight line. It’s a jagged, ugly scribble.
The first step is radical acceptance. You have to stop trying to "solve" why they are hurting you. Sometimes people hurt us because they are incapable of managing their own shadows. It has nothing to do with your worth.
Second, you need to regulate your nervous system. Deep breathing, cold plunges, or even just humming can stimulate the vagus nerve and tell your body, "We are safe right now."
Third, set boundaries that feel like armor. If someone keeps hurting you after you’ve told them—clearly—that their behavior is painful, then their "hurt" is no longer an accident. It’s a choice. You can't control their choice, but you can control your proximity to it.
Actionable Steps for Moving Forward
- Document the Reality: When you’re in the middle of a i cant believe youre hurting me moment, write down exactly what happened. Our brains tend to "fuzz out" bad memories to protect us, which leads us back into toxic cycles. Read your notes when you feel like going back.
- Seek "Bottom-Up" Therapy: Traditional talk therapy is great, but for deep emotional betrayal, "bottom-up" approaches like EMDR (Eye Movement Desensitization and Reprocessing) or Somatic Experiencing work directly with the body's stored trauma.
- Audit Your Inner Circle: Who else is in your life? Surround yourself with people who provide "co-regulation." These are the friends who make your heart rate slow down just by being in the room.
- Practice Self-Compassion: Stop telling yourself you should be "over it." If you had a broken leg, you wouldn't expect to run a marathon the next week. Treat your heart with the same medical respect.
- Establish a "No-Contact" or "Low-Contact" Rule: If the person continues to cause harm, physical distance is often the only way to allow the chemical soup of stress hormones in your brain to dissipate. It takes about 21 to 60 days for the "addiction" to the person to start fading.
Healing isn't about forgetting that they hurt you. It's about getting to a place where their ability to hurt you is gone. You deserve a life where you don't have to wonder when the next blow is coming.