Honestly, it’s rare for a song to stay this relevant. Most hits from the early 2000s are relegated to "throwback" playlists, but MercyMe’s "I Can Only Imagine" is different. You hear it at weddings. You hear it at funerals. You hear it in the grocery store when you’re just trying to buy milk and suddenly find yourself blinking back tears.
What is it about these specific lyrics that gets under everyone's skin?
Basically, the song asks a question we’ve all had: what happens next? Not just the "afterlife" in a clinical sense, but the actual, physical experience of standing in front of something—or Someone—greater than ourselves. It’s a song about the ultimate "what if."
The Story You Didn't See in the Lyrics
Most people know the chorus by heart, but the backstory is where things get heavy. Bart Millard, the lead singer of MercyMe, didn't just sit down and write a pretty poem. He wrote it about his dad, Arthur Millard.
And Arthur wasn't exactly a saint for most of Bart's life.
In fact, he was a "monster." That’s Bart’s own word for him. Growing up, Bart dealt with intense physical and emotional abuse. His father had a massive temper, partly attributed to a brain injury from a car accident before Bart was even born. Life at home was a minefield.
👉 See also: When Was Kai Cenat Born? What You Didn't Know About His Early Life
Then, everything shifted.
Arthur was diagnosed with pancreatic cancer when Bart was a freshman in high school. During those final years, the man who used to be a terror became a devout Christian. He changed completely. By the time Arthur died in 1991, he and Bart were best friends.
Bart's grandmother was the one who actually planted the seed for the song. At the funeral, she said she could "only imagine" what Arthur was seeing in heaven. Bart became obsessed with that phrase. He started scrawling it on notebooks, scraps of paper, anything he could find.
Ten years later, it finally became a song.
Breaking Down the I Can Only Imagine Lyrics
The song is surprisingly simple. There aren't many metaphors. No complex wordplay. It’s just a series of questions.
✨ Don't miss: Anjelica Huston in The Addams Family: What You Didn't Know About Morticia
"Surrounded by Your glory, what will my heart feel?"
The opening sets the stage. It’s not about the gold streets or the pearly gates. It’s about the internal reaction. Will you be terrified? Joyful? Overwhelmed?
"Will I dance for You, Jesus, or in awe of You be still?"
This is the part that usually hits the hardest. It acknowledges two very different, very human reactions to greatness. Some people are "movers"—they want to celebrate. Others are paralyzed by the weight of the moment. Bart captures that indecision perfectly.
"Will I sing hallelujah? Will I be able to speak at all?"
There’s a real vulnerability here. It’s the admission that even the most devout person doesn't actually know how they’ll handle the "big moment."
How it Became the Biggest Christian Song Ever
It's hard to overstate how massive this track was. It didn't just stay on Christian radio. It crossed over to mainstream pop, adult contemporary, and even country stations.
- 10 Minutes: That's how long it took Bart to write the lyrics. He says it was the easiest song he ever wrote, almost like it was already finished and he just had to write it down.
- The Platinum Milestone: It was the first Christian single to ever go Platinum. Then Double Platinum. Then Triple and Quadruple.
- The 9/11 Factor: The song was released on the album Almost There in August 2001. Just weeks later, the world changed. In the aftermath of the September 11 attacks, people were desperate for hope. "I Can Only Imagine" became an unofficial anthem for a grieving nation.
Why People Get the "Sun vs. Son" Part Wrong
There’s a line in the second verse: "When that day comes and I find myself standing in the sun." Actually, if you look at the official lyric sheets, it's often stylized as "standing in the Son." It’s a play on words. On the radio, it sounds like a beautiful day. To the believer, it’s a direct reference to Jesus. It’s one of the few "hidden" layers in a song that is otherwise very literal.
🔗 Read more: Isaiah Washington Movies and Shows: Why the Star Still Matters
The Movie Effect
In 2018, a movie of the same name was released starring Dennis Quaid as Arthur Millard. It was a massive box office hit, mostly because people wanted to see the "why" behind the song.
The film didn't shy away from the abuse. It showed the brokenness. Seeing the redemption of a "monster" gave the lyrics a whole new weight for a new generation. It reminded everyone that the song isn't just about heaven; it’s about the fact that nobody is too far gone to change.
What Most People Miss
The song isn't actually about death.
That sounds weird, right? But if you listen closely, it’s about anticipation. It’s about the hope that sustains you while you're still alive. Bart wrote it to cope with his father's absence, but it turned into a way for millions of people to process their own losses.
It’s a "grief hack." By focusing on the supposed joy of the person who passed away, it makes the pain of those left behind a little more bearable.
Actionable Insights for the Listener
If you’re diving back into this song, or maybe hearing it for the first time, here is how to get the most out of the experience:
- Listen to the "Movie Session" Version: MercyMe re-recorded the song for the film’s release. It’s got a more mature, stripped-back feel that highlights the lyrics better than the original 2001 pop-rock production.
- Read the Memoir: Bart Millard wrote a book called I Can Only Imagine: A Memoir. It fills in all the gaps the movie left out, especially regarding his relationship with his mother and his early days in the band.
- Watch the Music Video: The original video features people holding empty picture frames. They were told to bring photos of loved ones they had lost. The raw emotion on their faces isn't acting—it's real.
- Use it for Reflection: Many people use this song as a "reset" button during stressful times. The simplicity of the lyrics makes it a great tool for meditation or just a quiet moment of perspective.
The legacy of "I Can Only Imagine" isn't just in the record sales or the awards. It's in the way it provides a vocabulary for the stuff we usually can't put into words. Whether you're religious or not, the idea of finally being at peace—and finally being "okay"—is something we can all get behind.