He was the guy every man wanted to grab a beer with and every woman wanted to be with. At least, that’s the image. In reality, the man behind the mustache was a massive ball of contradictions. If you’ve ever watched the documentary I Am Burt Reynolds, you know exactly what I’m talking about. It’s not just some glossy tribute. Honestly, it’s a bit of a gut-punch that strips away the "Bandit" persona to show a guy who was frequently his own worst enemy.
Burt was the biggest movie star on the planet for five straight years. Think about that. From 1978 to 1982, nobody touched him. Not Eastwood. Not Redford.
But fame is a fickle beast.
👉 See also: Harry Mack Net Worth: Why People Keep Getting the Numbers Wrong
The Football Hero Who Stumbled Into Fame
Most people forget that Burt Reynolds didn't actually want to be an actor. He wanted to be a pro football player. He was a star running back at Florida State University, and he was good. Like, Baltimore Colts contract good. But a nasty knee injury followed by a horrific car accident basically ended that dream before it even started.
Imagine being twenty years old, your entire identity wrapped up in being an athlete, and suddenly you’re told it’s over. That’s a lot of trauma to carry.
He ended up in an acting class at Palm Beach Junior College because, well, he didn't know what else to do. His teacher, Watson B. Duncan III, saw something in him. He gave Burt the lead in a play called Outward Bound. That single role led to a drama award, which led to a scholarship in New York, which led to... everything else.
It wasn’t an overnight success story, though. Burt spent years doing "Spaghetti Westerns" in Italy and playing "half-Indian" characters on shows like Gunsmoke. He famously said he played every Indian except Pocahontas. He was a working actor long before he was a star, and that blue-collar work ethic stayed with him, even when he was flying around in private jets.
Why I Am Burt Reynolds Hits Different
What makes the I Am Burt Reynolds documentary so compelling is how it tackles the "Cosmopolitan" incident. In 1972, right as his breakout film Deliverance was hitting theaters, Burt posed naked on a bearskin rug for Cosmopolitan magazine.
It was meant to be a joke. A lark.
👉 See also: 2000s Nick Jr Shows: Why That Era of Kids TV Still Hits Different
Instead, it defined him for decades. While it made him a global sex symbol, it arguably killed his chances of an Oscar for Deliverance. The Academy didn't take "centerfolds" seriously. You can see the regret in his eyes in old interviews. He spent the rest of his life trying to prove he was a "real" actor, even though the audience just wanted him to wink at the camera and drive a Trans Am.
The film features some really heavy hitters:
- Loni Anderson: His ex-wife, who provides a perspective that isn't always sunshine and roses.
- Jon Voight: His co-star from Deliverance and a long-time friend.
- Sally Field: The "one who got away," though their relationship was famously tumultuous.
The Money, The Ego, and The Decline
Burt made a lot of money. Like, "buy a 144-acre ranch in Jupiter, Florida" money. But he spent it even faster. He bought a helicopter. He bought a professional football team (the Tampa Bay Bandits). He gave money to anyone who asked.
By the 1990s, he was filing for bankruptcy.
It’s painful to watch. You see this guy who was the king of the world suddenly selling off his memorabilia just to keep the lights on. But even in the lean years, he never lost that charm. He moved back to Florida, opened the Burt Reynolds Institute for Film and Theatre, and spent his final years teaching. He actually cared about the craft, even if his filmography was littered with duds like Cannonball Run II.
There’s a specific moment in the documentary that talks about Boogie Nights. Burt hated the movie. He hated the director, Paul Thomas Anderson. He allegedly even tried to punch him. He thought the movie was "seedy" and would ruin him.
Then he won a Golden Globe for it.
🔗 Read more: Why Mariah Carey Last Christmas Rumors Just Won’t Die
He was nominated for an Oscar, and for a second, it looked like he was finally going to get that validation he’d been chasing since 1972. But then he lost to Robin Williams. You can see the disappointment on his face in the archival footage. It’s human. It’s raw. And it’s why we still talk about him.
What Most People Get Wrong
People think Burt was just a "good ol' boy" who liked cars and girls. But he was actually incredibly progressive for his time. He was one of the few male stars who openly praised women and talked about how much he genuinely liked them—not just as conquests, but as people. He was a feminist before it was a buzzword, often saying that men who didn't like women were "missing the point of life."
He was also deeply insecure.
He wore a hairpiece for years and was obsessed with his image. He had a temper. He struggled with an addiction to painkillers after a stunt went wrong on the set of City Heat, which shattered his jaw. He wasn't a porcelain statue; he was a broken, talented, generous, and often frustrated man.
Actionable Insights for the Burt Reynolds Fan
If you want to truly understand the legacy of the man behind the mustache, don't just stop at the documentary. Here is how you should "consume" Burt Reynolds to get the full picture:
- Watch Deliverance (1972): This is the peak of his "serious" acting. It's a brutal film, but his performance as Lewis is masterclass-level intensity.
- Stream The Longest Yard (1974): This is where his football past and acting present collided perfectly. It’s arguably his best "all-around" movie.
- Read "But Enough About Me": His 2015 memoir is surprisingly honest. He doesn't hold back on his regrets, especially regarding Sally Field.
- Find the Johnny Carson Clips: Burt was the best talk show guest in history. His chemistry with Carson was legendary and shows the "wit" that the movies often failed to capture.
Burt Reynolds died in 2018, just as he was preparing to film his scenes for Quentin Tarantino’s Once Upon a Time in Hollywood. He never got that final "prestige" moment. But as the documentary proves, he didn't need it. He was already a legend, flaws and all.