If you lived through 2005, you probably remember that grainy footage of a man in a rumpled shirt looking absolutely exhausted. He was screaming at the federal government on the radio. He was crying. He was the face of a city underwater. That man was C. Ray Nagin, the hurricane katrina New Orleans mayor who went from being a local hero to a federal inmate in less than a decade.
It’s a wild story. Honestly, it’s one of the most polarizing political arcs in American history.
Before the storm hit, Nagin was actually seen as a "reformer." He was a former cable executive, a businessman who promised to clean up the notoriously corrupt "Big Easy." People liked him because he didn't act like a typical politician. He was blunt. He was kind of a maverick. But when the levees broke, that "bluntness" turned into a lightning rod for criticism that still sparks heated debates in New Orleans bars and barbershops today.
The Decision That Changed Everything
The biggest "what if" of the whole disaster is the timing of the evacuation.
Katrina was barreling toward the Gulf, and the National Hurricane Center was sounding every alarm they had. But Nagin waited. He didn't issue the mandatory evacuation order until Sunday, August 28—less than 24 hours before landfall. Why the delay? Well, reports later suggested he was worried about the city’s liability if he forced hotels and businesses to close too early.
🔗 Read more: Lake Nyos Cameroon 1986: What Really Happened During the Silent Killer’s Release
By the time the sirens started wailing, it was too late for thousands of people.
Think about that for a second. If you didn't have a car or money for a Greyhound, you were basically stuck. The city had hundreds of school buses sitting in parking lots. They could have been used to ferry people to higher ground. Instead, they were left to flood, their yellow roofs eventually poking out of the toxic water like gravestones.
The Superdome and the "Chocolate City"
When the water rose, the Superdome became a "shelter of last resort." It quickly turned into a living nightmare. No power. No running water. The heat was unbearable. Nagin was stuck in the middle of it, and you could see him cracking under the pressure.
Then came the "Chocolate City" speech in early 2006.
💡 You might also like: Why Fox Has a Problem: The Identity Crisis at the Top of Cable News
During a Martin Luther King Jr. Day celebration, Nagin said, "This city will be a chocolate city at the end of the day. This city will be majority African American. It’s the way God wants it to be." It was a moment that basically split the city in half. To some, it was a defiant promise that the Black community wouldn't be erased by gentrification after the flood. To others, it was divisive "race-baiting" that alienated white residents who were also trying to rebuild their homes.
The Fall of a New Orleans Icon
Most people think the hurricane katrina New Orleans mayor lost his job because of the storm. He didn't. He actually won re-election in 2006.
The real downfall happened later, and it was much more cliché: corruption. While the city was struggling to put itself back together, Nagin was allegedly taking kickbacks. We're talking about money, free vacations, and literal truckloads of free granite for his family's stone business.
In 2014, a federal jury convicted him on 20 counts, including:
📖 Related: The CIA Stars on the Wall: What the Memorial Really Represents
- Wire fraud
- Bribery
- Money laundering
- Tax evasion
He was sentenced to 10 years in federal prison. He served most of it at a facility in Texarkana before being released to a halfway house and then home confinement in 2020.
What We Can Learn from the Nagin Era
It's easy to look back and point fingers, but the Katrina response was a failure at every level—local, state, and federal. Nagin was just the most visible person in the room when the lights went out.
If you're looking for the "actionable" takeaway from this piece of history, it's about the danger of the "businessman-politician" myth. Running a city during a catastrophe isn't like running a cable company. It requires a level of logistics and empathy that can't be found on a balance sheet.
Next Steps for Understanding the Legacy:
- Watch the "When the Levees Broke" documentary by Spike Lee. It gives the rawest look at the atmosphere Nagin was operating in.
- Look up the 2004 "Pam" exercise. It was a simulation done a year before Katrina that predicted almost exactly what would happen. It proves the authorities knew the risks long before Nagin ever had to make a call.
- Visit the Lower Ninth Ward Living Museum if you're ever in New Orleans. It provides the perspective of the residents who feel most betrayed by the leadership during that era.
The story of the hurricane katrina New Orleans mayor is a reminder that in a crisis, the difference between a hero and a villain is often just a few hours and a lot of yellow buses.