Look, if you’re scouring the web for a 2026 mock draft with Hunter Reynolds sitting in the first round, you’re probably looking at a different Hunter. Or maybe a different Reynolds.
The reality of the Hunter Reynolds NFL draft conversation is a bit of a tangled web of "which one are we talking about?" and "wait, didn't he already graduate?" It’s one of those classic internet rabbit holes where a few similarly named athletes and a weird quirk in eligibility years make the search results look like a jigsaw puzzle with half the pieces missing.
Let’s set the record straight: the most prominent Hunter Reynolds we’ve seen recently—the safety who ballled out at Utah State after a stint at Michigan—actually finished his college run a bit ago. He was a 2023 draft prospect. But because of the "COVID year" and the way transfer portal news lingers forever, his name keeps popping up in 2026 searches like a ghost in the machine.
The Original Hunter Reynolds: A Path of Pure Grit
You’ve got to respect the journey this guy took. He wasn't some five-star recruit with a clear shot at the pros. He started as a walk-on at Michigan. Think about that for a second. You’re at one of the biggest programs in the country, paying your own way, just hoping for a sniff of the field.
He didn't just sniff it; he earned a scholarship.
By 2020, he was actually leading the Wolverines' secondary in tackles during a game against Penn State, racking up 11 stops. Most guys would be satisfied with that. Not him. He hit the transfer portal and landed at Utah State, where things really clicked.
- 2021 Season: 83 tackles, an interception in the LA Bowl.
- 2022 Season: 93 tackles, three picks, and a 55-yard fumble return for a TD.
- The IQ Factor: Coaches loved him because he played like a coach on the field. He was the guy alignment-checking everyone else.
He was the definition of a "glue guy" for the Aggies. Despite the production, he went undrafted in 2023. Since then, he's been the ultimate "keep grinding" story, looking for that professional stickiness that eludes so many talented DBs.
Why Is He Still Trending in 2026?
This is where the confusion kicks in. If you see "Hunter Reynolds" and "2026" in the same sentence, you’re usually looking at one of three things:
- The "Other" Hunter Reynolds: There is a younger Hunter Reynolds who plays linebacker and running back for Huntingdon College (Class of 2025/2026). He’s a different build—5'10", 230 lbs—basically a human bowling ball compared to the 6'0" safety from Utah State.
- The Travis Hunter Effect: Honestly, with Travis Hunter (the Colorado superstar) dominating every 2025 and 2026 draft board, Google's algorithms sometimes get a little "fuzzy." People type "Hunter draft" and "Reynolds" (maybe thinking of Daejon Reynolds from Pitt) and suddenly the search results are a mess.
- The Dynasty Fantasy Football Lag: Devy (developmental) leagues often track players for years. If a name was on a watch list in 2022, it sometimes stays there in old databases, leading fans to believe a player still has eligibility when they’re actually long gone.
The Scouting Truth: Small School Safety Hurdles
If we look at the Hunter Reynolds NFL draft profile from a technical standpoint, the "knock" was never the heart or the head. It was the measurables.
NFL scouts are obsessed with "traits." Usually, that means 4.4 speed or a 6'2" frame. Reynolds was more of a 6'0", 200-pound player who won with positioning rather than raw twitch. In a league that’s getting faster every year, being "smart" isn't always enough to get you drafted, even if it's enough to make you a star in the Mountain West.
But don't get it twisted. His 2022 tape is a masterclass in safety play. He was consistently the highest-graded defender on his team according to PFF (Pro Football Focus) because he rarely blew a coverage. That kind of reliability is exactly why he’s stayed on the radar of professional scouts in various leagues.
What Actually Matters Now
If you’re a fan or a scout looking for the next "Hunter Reynolds" type, you’re looking for a specific archetype. You want the kid who can play the deep half but isn't afraid to stick his nose in the fan at the line of scrimmage.
The Hunter Reynolds NFL draft story isn't about a high-round selection. It's a reminder that the path to the pros isn't a straight line. Sometimes it’s a walk-on at Michigan, a star in Logan, Utah, and a long road through training camps and mini-camps.
For the younger Hunter Reynolds at Huntingdon or other namesakes in the high school ranks, the path is wide open. But for the guy most of us remember from the Aggies, the chapter of "draft prospect" has transitioned into the chapter of "pro athlete."
✨ Don't miss: The LA Dodgers Score Yesterday and Why the Bullpen is Already Giving Fans Heartburn
Actionable Next Steps for Draft Junkies
If you're trying to track the actual 2026 draft class without getting bogged down in name-confusion:
- Verify the College: If the player isn't on a current D1 roster by late 2025, they aren't a 2026 draft prospect.
- Cross-Reference Stats: Check current season logs on sites like CFBStats or ESPN. If the last entry is from 2022, that player is out of the collegiate loop.
- Watch the "Riserrs": Keep an eye on the Mountain West and MAC. The next "Reynolds-style" safety is likely a transfer portal veteran who found a home in a mid-major conference.
The draft is a chaotic business. Names get recycled, stats get mixed, and the "experts" aren't always looking at the same guy you are. Just make sure you know which Hunter you're rooting for before you put money on a mock.