You probably remember the bandana. Maybe the 24-inch pythons. But do you actually remember the pasta? If you’re scouring the streets of Manhattan today looking for the Hulk Hogan bar NYC fans used to whisper about, you’re going to find a lot of high-end boutiques or maybe a Starbucks, but you won't find the Hulkster.
It’s one of those weird fever dreams of the early 2000s.
Back in 1995, Terry Bollea—better known as Hulk Hogan—decided he needed to conquer the culinary world. He opened Pastamania! in the Mall of America. It flopped. Hard. But for some reason, the itch to own a brick-and-mortar spot in the biggest city in the world never really went away. People often get confused when they search for a Hogan-themed establishment in New York because, frankly, the history is a bit of a mess of short-lived branding deals and missed opportunities.
The Reality of Hogan’s Presence in the New York Bar Scene
Let’s get the facts straight right away. There is no current "Hulk Hogan Bar" in New York City. If you see a TikTok claiming there’s a secret wrestling bar owned by him in Midtown, they’re pulling your leg.
However, the search for the Hulk Hogan bar NYC experience usually leads back to a very specific era: the late 90s and very early 2000s. This was the peak of themed restaurants. We had Planet Hollywood. We had the Official All Star Cafe. Hogan was a massive part of that latter venture. The All Star Cafe, located right in the heart of Times Square at 1540 Broadway, was essentially the closest thing New York ever had to a Hogan headquarters.
He wasn't just a face on the wall. He was an investor alongside guys like Tiger Woods, Ken Griffey Jr., and Joe Montana.
It was loud. It was garish. The monitors played nonstop highlights of the 1990s wrestling boom. Honestly, it was kind of a vibe if you were ten years old and obsessed with the nWo. But as a sustainable business model? Not so much. The All Star Cafe eventually filed for bankruptcy, and the Times Square location shuttered in 2001. That essentially ended the era of Hogan having a "home base" for fans in the city.
✨ Don't miss: Who was the voice of Yoda? The real story behind the Jedi Master
Why Do People Still Search for This?
Nostalgia is a powerful drug.
The reason the "Hulk Hogan bar NYC" query still pops up on Google is largely due to the mandela effect of celebrity branding. People remember Hogan being everywhere in New York during the "Hulkamania" peaks. He was a regular at Madison Square Garden. He did the talk show circuits. He was the face of the city’s entertainment scene for decades.
There's also the confusion with his actual current businesses. If you want the real Hogan experience, you have to go to Florida. He owns Hogan’s Hangout in Clearwater Beach. That’s the place you see on social media with the wrestling memorabilia, the massive drinks, and the occasional appearance by the man himself. New York tourists often see clips of the Clearwater spot and assume—given Hogan's ties to the Big Apple—that there must be a local franchise.
There isn't.
What You’ll Find Instead
If you are a wrestling fan in NYC looking for that "Hulk Hogan bar" energy, you’ve basically got two options that aren't actually owned by him but cater to the same crowd.
- Jack Demsey's: This is often cited as a hub for wrestling fans during major pay-per-views. It’s got that old-school Manhattan pub feel.
- Dmitri's (and various Brooklyn spots): There are specific dive bars in Bushwick and Williamsburg that lean into the "ironic" appreciation of 80s wrestling, but it’s a far cry from a branded Hogan establishment.
The Business Failure of Celebrity Themed Bars
Why didn't a permanent Hulk Hogan bar NYC location ever take off?
🔗 Read more: Not the Nine O'Clock News: Why the Satirical Giant Still Matters
Commercial real estate in Manhattan is a monster. Even for a guy with Hogan's net worth, the overhead of maintaining a massive themed space in Times Square or Chelsea is astronomical. When the All Star Cafe went under, it signaled the end of the "super-athlete" restaurant craze. Fans stopped wanting to eat mediocre burgers just because a famous guy’s name was on the door.
They wanted better food. They wanted craft cocktails. Hogan's brand—bless his heart—is many things, but "refined" isn't one of them. His brand is 1980s neon, loud music, and high-energy showmanship. That works incredibly well in a tourist haven like Clearwater, Florida, where people are on vacation and want to let loose. In the cutthroat NYC hospitality world of the 2020s? It's a tough sell.
Also, we have to talk about the controversies. Over the last decade, Hogan’s public image took some massive hits. From the Gawker lawsuit to the leaked transcripts that briefly got him scrubbed from WWE history, his "brand equity" isn't what it was in 1987. Modern bar owners in New York are generally looking for brands that are "safe" or "edgy-cool." Hogan is "legacy-complex," which is a harder sell for a corporate landlord on 5th Avenue.
Tracking the Hogan Footprint
It’s interesting to look at where he did spend his time. Back in the day, if you wanted to catch Hogan after a show at the Garden, you weren't going to a themed bar. You were going to high-end spots like Smith & Wollensky or old-school haunts that valued privacy over branding.
Hogan was always a businessman first. He knew that his fans would pay for a ticket to see him drop a leg, but would they pay $25 for a "Hulkster Martini" on a Tuesday night in February in Manhattan? The data suggests no.
Misconceptions About the "Hogan Bar"
- Fact: Hogan’s Beach (in Tampa) was a real thing, but it was rebranded after several controversies and a break with the hotel that hosted it.
- Fact: Pastamania! lasted less than a year.
- Fact: Any "Hulk Hogan Bar" you see listed on old Yelp pages for NYC is likely a defunct reference to a specific event or a long-closed pop-up.
Honestly, the closest thing to a Hogan bar in New York today is probably a vintage shop in the East Village selling 1991 Wrestlemania shirts for $200. The culture has shifted from physical spaces to digital nostalgia.
💡 You might also like: New Movies in Theatre: What Most People Get Wrong About This Month's Picks
The Future of Wrestling-Themed Venues in NYC
While Hogan might not have a permanent shingle out in the city, the appetite for wrestling-themed hospitality hasn't totally died. It’s just changed.
We see "watch parties" at various bars across the five boroughs. These are temporary takeovers. They’re lean. They don't require the massive capital of a celebrity-owned flagship. If Hogan were to ever return to the NYC market, it would likely be through a partnership with a hospitality group rather than a solo venture.
Think about it: a "Hogan-themed" popup during SummerSlam week? That would print money. A permanent bar in the West Village? It would be closed by the next rent cycle.
Actionable Steps for the Hulkamania Fan in New York
Since you can't walk into a dedicated Hogan bar in NYC right now, here is how you actually scratch that itch:
- Check the WWE Schedule: When WWE runs Brooklyn or MSG, certain bars in the immediate vicinity (like those on 7th Avenue) become de facto wrestling bars for 48 hours. Follow accounts like "Wrestling Party" on social media to see where the fans are congregating.
- Visit Jimmy’s Seafood (if you're traveling): Okay, it’s in Baltimore, not NYC, but it’s the unofficial home of wrestling legends on the East Coast.
- Go South: If you absolutely must drink at a bar owned by Hulk Hogan, book a flight to TPA. Hogan’s Hangout in Clearwater is the only place where the brand is fully realized, complete with the "Wall of Fame" and the heavy-handed wrestling aesthetic you're looking for.
- Verify Listings: If you see a Google Maps listing for a "Hulk Hogan Bar" in NYC, check the "Last Updated" date. Most of these are ghost listings or errors in the database from old events held at venues like the Hard Rock Cafe.
The dream of the Hulk Hogan bar NYC remains just that—a dream. It’s a remnant of an era where celebrities thought they could just slap their face on a building and the world would beat a path to their door. Nowadays, the Hulkster stays where the sun is hot and the taxes are lower.
If you're in the city, grab a drink at a classic Irish pub, put on a 1980s playlist on the jukebox, and toast to the 24-inch pythons. That’s about as close as you’re going to get.