Printing is a scam. Well, okay, maybe that’s a bit dramatic, but it definitely feels that way when your Deskjet starts flashing that annoying low-ink light just weeks after you bought it. If you own an HP printer from the mid-2010s, you’re likely tethered to the HP 61 combo pack. It’s the bread and butter of home offices, yet most people are buying it all wrong. They walk into a big-box store, grab the first green-and-blue box they see, and trudge to the register.
Stop doing that.
The HP 61 series is one of the most widely used ink platforms HP ever built. It covers everything from the ENVY 4500 to the tiny Deskjet 1000. But here’s the kicker: not all "combo packs" are created equal, and if you aren't looking at the page yield or the firmware updates, you're basically throwing ten-dollar bills into a paper shredder.
The Anatomy of the HP 61 Combo Pack
Basically, when you buy the standard combo, you get two cartridges. One is the 61 Black (CH561WN) and the other is the 61 Tri-color (CH562WN). HP markets these as a convenience play. It’s one box, one price, and supposedly one solution for your printing needs.
But have you ever actually looked at how much ink is in there?
The standard black cartridge holds roughly 3 to 4 milliliters of ink. That’s about a teaspoon. For a price tag that often hovers around $35 to $45 for the set, you are paying more per ounce for this liquid than you would for a vintage Chanel No. 5 or a high-end single-malt scotch. Honestly, it’s wild. The black cartridge is rated for about 190 pages, while the color one hits around 165. But those numbers are based on 5% page coverage—which is basically a short business letter. If you’re printing photos or school projects with heavy borders, cut those numbers in half.
The "combo" part is mostly a psychological trick. It feels like a deal. In reality, you're usually saving maybe a dollar or two over buying them separately. Sometimes, depending on the retailer’s inventory, the combo is actually more expensive than two individual packs on sale.
🔗 Read more: Why Your Wireless Mouse Is Probably Lagging (And How to Fix It)
Why Your Printer "Rejects" the Cartridge
We’ve all been there. You tear open the foil, click the cartridge into the carriage, and the printer screen screams "Cartridge Error" or "Incompatible Ink." It’s infuriating.
Most of the time, this isn't a hardware failure. It's software. HP uses something called "Cartridge Protection." This is a setting often enabled by default that "locks" a cartridge to the first printer it's installed in. If you bought a "remanufactured" HP 61 combo pack—which is a used cartridge that a third party refilled—and the previous owner had Cartridge Protection turned on, that ink is now a plastic brick.
You can actually turn this off in your printer settings via the IP address of the printer on your local network, but once a cartridge is locked, it’s locked.
Then there’s the regional coding. HP 61 cartridges are for the North American and Asia-Pacific markets. If you accidentally buy an HP 301 (the European equivalent) or an HP 122 (Middle East/Africa), it won't work. They look identical. The pins are the same. The plastic mold is the same. But the chip tells the printer to say "No." It’s a regional lockout that helps HP control pricing across different global economies, but for the average user on Amazon, it's a minefield of "Does this actually fit?"
The XL Myth: Is It Actually Better?
People ask if the 61XL is worth it.
Short answer? Yes. Almost always.
Long answer? It depends on your "evaporation rate."
An HP 61XL black cartridge yields about 480 pages. That’s more than double the standard. The physical size of the plastic shell is exactly the same as the standard version, which leads people to believe they're being scammed. They aren't. Inside the standard 61, there’s a massive plastic divider and a tiny sponge. In the 61XL, the sponge fills the whole chamber.
If you print every day, the XL is a no-brainer. The cost per page drops significantly. However, if you only print once every three months, the XL is a trap. Inkjet ink is mostly water and pigment. It dries out. The print head on an HP 61 is actually built into the cartridge itself—which is why they are so expensive compared to Epson or Brother tanks. If that ink dries in the microscopic nozzles because it sat for half a year, it doesn't matter if you have 400 pages of ink left. The cartridge is dead.
The Remanufactured Rabbit Hole
Can you use off-brand ink? You can. Should you? Maybe.
The HP 61 is one of the easiest cartridges to refill, which is why the market is flooded with "compatible" versions. Companies like LD Products or Planet Ink take empty OEM (Original Equipment Manufacturer) shells, scrub them, replace the sponge, and squirt in new ink.
The risk is the chip. HP frequently pushes firmware updates to their printers via Wi-Fi. These updates often do nothing for "performance" and everything for "security"—which is code for "blocking third-party cartridges." If you use remanufactured ink, you might wake up one day and find your printer refuses to work because it downloaded an update overnight that blacklisted the serial numbers on your "cheap" cartridges.
If you go the remanufactured route, look for vendors that offer a "latest chip version" guarantee. Otherwise, you’re gambling with a paperweight.
Troubleshooting the "Low Ink" Liar
The HP 61 is notorious for reporting low ink when it’s still one-third full. The printer doesn't actually "see" the ink level. It estimates it based on the number of dots the print head has fired. It’s a literal guess.
If your printer says it's empty but you suspect there's more life in it, there are two tricks.
- The "Tape Trick": This is old-school and a bit messy, but covering certain copper contacts on the back of the cartridge with Scotch tape can sometimes trick the printer into thinking a "new" cartridge has been inserted, resetting the internal counter.
- The Power Cycle: Unplugging the printer from the wall (not just the power button) for 60 seconds can sometimes clear the temporary memory that's flagging the cartridge as "expired."
Also, if your colors look streaky, don't just run the "Clean Printhead" utility five times. That utility uses a massive amount of ink to flush the nozzles. Instead, take a lint-free cloth, dampen it with a tiny bit of distilled water, and gently dab the copper-colored plate on the bottom of the cartridge. If you see three solid stripes of color (cyan, magenta, yellow), the cartridge is fine; the printer’s internal maintenance just isn't cutting it.
Environmental Impact of the Combo Pack
We need to talk about the plastic. Every time you finish an HP 61 combo pack, you are throwing away two integrated circuit boards and two high-grade plastic housings. Because the print head is on the cartridge, it's much more wasteful than "tank" printers where you just add liquid.
HP has a recycling program (HP Planet Partners), but honestly, very few people use it. Most of these end up in landfills where the residual ink—which contains heavy metals and chemicals—can leach into the soil. If you're using 61s, at least take them to a Best Buy or Staples for recycling. They often give you store credit or rewards points for doing it. It’s a small win for the planet and your wallet.
The Future of the 61 Series
HP is moving away from this model. They want you on "Instant Ink." This is their subscription service where the printer monitors your usage and mails you cartridges before you run out.
For the HP 61 user, Instant Ink is a weird deal. If you sign up, they send you special "Subscription" cartridges. They are physically larger and hold more ink than even the XL. But here is the catch: if you cancel your subscription, those cartridges instantly stop working, even if they are full of ink. You don't own the ink; you're renting the ability to print.
If you print a consistent 50 pages a month, Instant Ink is actually cheaper than buying a 61 combo pack every few months. But if your printing is sporadic, stay away. The "pay-per-page" model will eat you alive during months you don't print anything.
Practical Steps for Better Printing
If you're stuck with an HP 61 printer, don't despair. You just have to be smarter than the software.
- Check the Date: Every HP 61 box has an "Install By" date. Ink has a shelf life. If you buy a "deal" on eBay that's three years past its date, the ink is likely viscous and will clog your printer immediately.
- Store it Right: If you buy a backup combo pack, store it upright. If it lays on its side, the ink can migrate away from the print head, causing air bubbles that lead to streaky "ghost" printing.
- Default to Draft: Go into your computer's printer properties and set the default quality to "Draft." The HP 61 uses about 30% less ink in this mode, and for text documents, you honestly won't notice the difference.
- Keep it Plugged In: Don't plug your printer into a power strip that you turn off at night. HP printers do a "mini-prime" when they power on. If you're constantly cutting the power, the printer thinks it's a cold start every time and wastes ink cleaning the heads. Leave it in "Sleep" mode instead.
Ultimately, the HP 61 combo pack is a legacy product. It's reliable, it's ubiquitous, but it's a "razor and blade" business model at its peak. Treat the cartridges with care, avoid the standard-size packs unless you're in a total pinch, and always—always—disable those "mandatory" firmware updates if you ever want to use cheaper ink alternatives.
The next time you're at the store, do the math on the back of a receipt. Check the price of the 61XL black plus a 61XL color versus the combo pack. You might find that the "convenience" of the pre-made box is costing you a premium you didn't need to pay.
Stop buying the standard capacity. Switch to XL if you print more than once a week. Disable "HP Cartridge Protection" in your printer's web interface immediately to keep your options open for third-party ink. If your printer is more than five years old and the 61 cartridges are getting harder to find at a fair price, it might be time to look into an "EcoTank" or "MegaTank" system where you pour ink from a bottle—it’ll save you hundreds of dollars over the next three years.