When you think of high-profile murder investigations, your mind probably goes straight to some gritty HBO drama or maybe the sprawling streets of Chicago. But if you actually look at the data and the raw reality of American policing, the spotlight often lands on a mid-sized city in Oklahoma. Tulsa. Specifically, the Tulsa OK homicide detectives who operate out of the Detective Division. They’ve gained a weird sort of national fame—not because the city is a hotbed of crime, but because they are freakishly good at catching people.
The numbers tell a story that feels almost impossible in modern law enforcement. While the national average for "clearing" or solving homicides often hovers around 50% or 60% in many major metros, Tulsa routinely clears north of 80% or 90%. Some years, they hit 100%. That isn't a typo. It’s a statistic that has made the unit a subject of fascination for true crime fans and federal researchers alike.
Why the Tulsa OK homicide detectives are different
It isn’t magic. Honestly, it’s mostly just a combination of a very specific culture and the "First 48" effect. If you’ve ever flipped on A&E, you’ve seen them. Detectives like Jason White, Ronnie Leatherman, and the now-retired Dave Walker became household names because they allowed cameras to document the grueling, unglamorous reality of the job.
Most departments hate cameras. They worry about liability or looking bad. Tulsa took the opposite approach. They figured that if the community saw how hard they worked—and saw that they actually cared about the victims—people might start talking. It worked. In a lot of neighborhoods where "no snitching" is a survival rule, Tulsa detectives often find witnesses who are willing to step up because they’ve seen the face of the investigator on their TV screen.
The workload is heavy. These guys aren't sitting in air-conditioned offices theorizing about motives. They are on the pavement. When a call comes in at 3:00 AM in North Tulsa or near the 61st and Peoria corridor, the entire team usually moves. This "all-hands" approach during the first few hours is basically the secret sauce. You don't just have one primary investigator; you have a room full of veterans poking holes in stories and chasing down doorbell camera footage before it gets overwritten.
📖 Related: What Really Happened With Trump Revoking Mayorkas Secret Service Protection
The Gritty Reality of the "Clearance Rate"
We need to talk about what a "solve" actually means. In the world of Tulsa OK homicide detectives, a cleared case usually means an arrest has been made and the case has been turned over to the District Attorney. It doesn't always mean a conviction—though their conviction rates are also high—but it means the mystery is over.
But here’s the thing people get wrong: they think a high solve rate means the city is safe.
That’s not necessarily true.
Solving a murder is reactive. It happens after the tragedy. Tulsa has struggled with a high violent crime rate relative to its size for years. The detectives are the cleanup crew. They are brilliant at what they do, but they are working within a system that is often overwhelmed by domestic violence, gang friction, and the ubiquitous presence of firearms.
Take a look at the 2023 stats. Tulsa ended the year with 48 homicides. That was a significant drop from the 68 seen in 2022. For the detectives, a "slow" year is a blessing, but it also means they have more time to dig into the cold cases that haunt the filing cabinets at the police headquarters downtown.
The Dave Walker Era and the Culture of "The Unit"
You can't talk about this group without mentioning retired Lieutenant Dave Walker. He led the unit for years and basically shaped the persona of the Tulsa OK homicide detectives. He was old-school. He wore the fedora. He talked to suspects like they were neighbors who had just made a really bad mistake.
👉 See also: Franklin D Roosevelt Civil Rights Record: Why It Is Way More Complicated Than You Think
This psychological approach is a hallmark of the TPD style. They don't do the "Bad Cop" screaming routine much. Instead, they use rapport. They sit in the interview room for six, eight, ten hours. They wait. They listen. They let the suspect talk themselves into a corner. It's a game of patience that requires a specific kind of mental stamina.
Current leadership, like Lieutenant Brandon Watkins, has kept that momentum going. They’ve had to adapt to a world where digital evidence is everything. Ten years ago, a detective wanted a witness. Today, a detective wants your cell phone pings and your Instagram DMs. The unit has leaned heavily into tech, using NIBIN (National Integrated Ballistic Information Network) to link shell cells from different crime scenes in a matter of hours. If a gun was used in a robbery on Monday and a murder on Tuesday, these detectives know about it by Wednesday morning.
The Toll Nobody Talks About
Being a Tulsa OK homicide detective isn't a 9-to-5. It’s a 24/7/365 lifestyle that eats people alive. You see the worst of humanity—the stuff that doesn't make it onto the A&E edits. You see the grieving mothers and the kids who were in the next room when the shots fired.
The burnout rate in homicide units across the US is massive. Yet, in Tulsa, you see detectives staying in the unit for a decade or more. There’s a weird sense of "tribe" there. They eat together, they vent to each other, and they carry the weight of the "victim's family" as their primary motivator.
✨ Don't miss: 39 Carl St and Kevin Lau: What Actually Happened at the Cole Valley Property
There's also the friction with the community. Tulsa has a complicated history—the 1921 Race Massacre is the massive, dark shadow that hangs over all law enforcement relations in the city. The detectives have to navigate that. They have to build trust in neighborhoods where the police haven't always been the "good guys." It’s a delicate, ongoing process of showing up and proving that this time, the investigation will be fair.
What Happens When the Cameras Turn Off?
While "The First 48" made them famous, the real work is the paperwork. It's the thousands of pages of discovery. It's the depositions. It's standing in front of a jury and explaining why a grainy piece of surveillance footage proves the defendant was the shooter.
The Tulsa OK homicide detectives are currently facing new challenges. The "McGirt" Supreme Court decision fundamentally changed how jurisdiction works in much of Eastern Oklahoma, including parts of Tulsa. This means that if a victim or a suspect is a member of a federally recognized tribe, the case might end up in federal court rather than state court. It added a massive layer of bureaucratic complexity to an already difficult job. Detectives now have to be legal scholars as much as they are investigators, ensuring they follow the right protocols so a murderer doesn't walk on a jurisdictional technicality.
Actionable Insights: What You Should Know
If you live in Tulsa or are just interested in how justice works in the "Real World," there are a few things to keep in mind regarding how these investigations function:
- Communication is the Key Variable: The reason Tulsa solves cases is that people eventually talk. If you have information about a crime, using anonymous tips through Crime Stoppers (918-596-COPS) is actually effective. You don't have to be a "snitch" on the record to help a family get closure.
- Digital Footprints are Permanent: Almost every homicide solved in Tulsa lately involves some form of digital breadcrumb. From Ring cameras to Snapchat location data, the "perfect crime" basically doesn't exist anymore.
- Support for Victims: If you are a family member of a victim, the TPD Homicide Unit works closely with the Victim Services Unit. There are resources for counseling and navigating the court system that many people don't realize are available for free.
- Advocacy and Cold Cases: Just because a case isn't solved in the "First 48" doesn't mean it's dead. The unit still actively reviews files from the 70s, 80s, and 90s. If you have new info on an old case, contacting the Homicide Unit directly is the best path to reopening that door.
The Tulsa OK homicide detectives aren't superheroes. They are just people who are incredibly disciplined about a very grim task. They’ve proven that even in a city with deep-seated social issues and a high crime rate, you can still achieve justice if you're willing to put in the miles and treat the victims like they actually matter. It’s a high bar, and frankly, more cities should probably be looking at the Tulsa playbook.