Let’s be honest. Nobody actually likes writing these. You get an email from a former intern or a colleague you haven't spoken to in three years, and suddenly you’re staring at a blinking cursor, wondering how to summarize a human being's entire professional worth in four hundred words. It’s a lot of pressure. If you mess it up, they might miss out on a dream job. If you make it too glowing, you look like you’re lying.
Writing a recommendation is basically a balancing act between being a cheerleader and being a cold-blooded pragmatist. Most people think they can just download a template, swap out the names, and call it a day. That’s a mistake. Recruiters can smell a generic form letter from a mile away. They see them every single day. If you really want to help someone, you need to know how to write a recommendation letter sample that feels alive, specific, and—most importantly—honest.
The Anatomy of a Letter That Doesn't Suck
Most people start with "To Whom It May Concern." Don't do that. It’s 2026; if you can’t find a name on LinkedIn or the company website, at least address it to the "Hiring Committee" or the "Department Lead." It shows you actually put in thirty seconds of effort.
The first paragraph needs to be punchy. You have to establish your "standing" immediately. Why should the reader care what you think? If you were their direct supervisor for four years at a high-growth startup, say that. If you only worked together on one project, be transparent about it. Clarity beats fluff every single time.
Why Specificity Is Your Only Friend
I once saw a letter that said a candidate was "hardworking and a team player." Guess what? Everyone says that. It’s white noise. It means nothing.
Instead of saying they’re a leader, tell the story of the time the server went down at 3:00 AM on a Sunday and they were the only one who hopped on the Zoom call to coordinate the fix. That’s a "show, don't tell" situation. Use the "Situation, Action, Result" (STAR) method, but keep it conversational. Real people talk about results. "Sarah didn't just manage the social media; she tripled our engagement in six months without spending a dime on ads." That’s a sentence that gets someone an interview.
👉 See also: Parker's Ace Hardware Sault Ste Marie: Why Local Pros Still Swear by It
How to Write a Recommendation Letter Sample Without Looking Like a Robot
The biggest giveaway that a letter was generated by a machine or a lazy human is the lack of "texture." Texture comes from mentioning the small things. Maybe it’s the way the person handles feedback or how they’re always the one to suggest the most efficient way to run a meeting.
The Mid-Section Deep Dive
The middle of the letter is where you prove the "fit." If the candidate is applying for a senior management role, your letter shouldn't focus on how good they are at Excel. It should focus on their emotional intelligence.
- Talk about their ability to navigate conflict.
- Mention how they mentor junior staff.
- Focus on their long-term strategic thinking.
- Highlight a specific project where they saved the company money or time.
Contrast this with a letter for a junior-level role. There, you want to emphasize coachability and grit. You’re trying to convince the hiring manager that this person won't quit when things get boring or difficult.
The "Weakness" Trap
A lot of people think a recommendation letter should be 100% positive. I actually disagree. A letter that is too perfect feels fake. Now, don't go listing their worst traits, obviously. But adding a tiny bit of "constructive" nuance can actually make the praise feel more earned.
For instance, you might say, "Early on, Marcus struggled with delegating tasks because he’s such a perfectionist, but over the last year, I’ve watched him master the art of empowering his team." See? You’ve turned a potential negative into a growth story. It makes you look like a credible witness, not just a friend doing a favor.
Structuring the Closing
The end is where you stick the landing. Avoid the "Please feel free to contact me" cliché if you can. Try something more assertive. "I would hire them again in a heartbeat if I had an open headcount" is one of the strongest sentences you can write. It puts your own professional reputation on the line, which carries massive weight with recruiters.
Avoid These Common SEO Pitfalls
When you're looking for how to write a recommendation letter sample, you'll find a lot of sites giving you "copy-paste" blocks. Avoid those like the plague. Google’s algorithms, especially with the recent E-E-A-T (Experience, Expertise, Authoritativeness, and Trustworthiness) updates, are getting better at identifying unoriginal content. If your letter looks exactly like ten thousand others on the web, it doesn’t just hurt your candidate; it makes you look uninspired.
- Don't over-format. Human beings don't usually write in perfectly symmetrical bulleted lists when they're recommending a friend.
- Watch your tone. Keep it professional but let your personality through. If you're a casual person, it's okay to sound like one.
- Check the facts. Double-check dates of employment. Nothing kills credibility faster than a factual error about when someone worked for you.
What Research Says About Professional Endorsements
According to various studies in organizational psychology, "narrative" letters are consistently rated higher than "check-the-box" evaluations. A study published in the Journal of Applied Psychology highlighted that specific behavioral examples are more predictive of future performance than general trait ratings. Basically, stories win.
Dealing with the "No"
Sometimes, you shouldn't write the letter. If you can't genuinely recommend someone, it’s better to say no. A lukewarm recommendation is often worse than no recommendation at all. It’s awkward, sure, but "I don't think I'm the best person to speak to your specific skills for this role" is a valid and professional boundary to set.
Actionable Steps for Your Next Draft
Start by asking the person for their current resume and the job description they’re eyeing. You need to know what "keywords" the hiring manager is looking for. If the job description emphasizes "cross-functional collaboration," make sure that phrase (or a variation of it) appears in your letter.
Next, jot down three specific "wins" you witnessed. Don't worry about grammar yet. Just get the stories down.
Once you have the stories, wrap them in a professional shell.
- Header: Your contact info.
- Salutation: Specific name if possible.
- Introduction: Who you are and how you know them.
- The Core: 2-3 paragraphs of specific examples and "texture."
- The "Why": Why they fit this specific new role.
- The Closer: Your personal stamp of approval.
Keep the whole thing under one page. Recruiters are busy. If it's longer than a page, they're going to skim it, and they might miss the best parts. Aim for 300 to 500 words. That's the "Goldilocks" zone—not too short to be dismissive, not too long to be a chore.
Finally, save it as a PDF. Word docs can get messy with formatting depending on what version of Office the recipient is using. A PDF stays exactly how you intended it to look.
👉 See also: Is There Actually a Walmart New York Times Square? What You Need to Know
Writing a great recommendation isn't about being a brilliant prose stylist. It's about being a witness. If you can prove, with evidence, that someone is a capable, reliable, and pleasant human being to work with, you've done your job.
Next Steps:
- Audit your anecdotes: Review your draft and replace every "very" or "highly" with a specific number or a specific story.
- Verify the recipient: Spend three minutes on the company's "About Us" page to find the actual name of the hiring manager or department head.
- Cross-reference the job post: Ensure at least two key skills mentioned in the job description are explicitly addressed in your letter's body paragraphs.