You’ve got a massive bowl of Rainier or Bing cherries sitting on the counter. They look incredible. But then you realize you have to pit every single one of them for that pie or just so your kid doesn't choke on a stone. Honestly, it’s the kind of task that makes people just buy frozen fruit instead. But don't do that. Fresh is better.
The thing about learning how to use a cherry pitter is that it seems self-explanatory until you're covered in crimson spray and the pit is still stuck inside the fruit. It’s messy. It’s tedious. But if you do it right, it’s actually weirdly satisfying. I've spent years in kitchens dealing with stone fruits, and there is a massive difference between hacking your way through a pound of cherries and actually using the tool the way it was engineered.
The Different Types of Pitters (And Why It Matters)
Not all pitters are created equal. You might have that cheap plastic one from the grocery store checkout aisle, or maybe you splurged on a heavy-duty multi-cherry plunger.
The single-hand plunger is the most common. You’ve probably seen the OXO Good Grips version. It looks like a stapler. You put the cherry in the little cradle, squeeze, and a metal rod pushes the pit through the bottom. It’s great for a snack, but if you’re making a gallon of jam, your hand will cramp by the tenth minute. Then there are the multi-cherry tools. These are beasts. You can do six or even twelve at a time. Brands like Prepworks make these tray-style pitters that are life-changers for canning season.
There’s also the crank style. You feed them in, turn a handle, and the pits go one way while the fruit goes the other. They feel a bit like 1950s tech, but they work. Sorta. Sometimes they mangel the fruit if it’s too soft.
How to Use a Cherry Pitter the Right Way
First, prep your space. This is where everyone fails. Cherry juice is basically permanent ink. If you’re working on a white marble countertop, stop. Cover it. Use a large cutting board or even lay down some parchment paper.
💡 You might also like: Finding the most affordable way to live when everything feels too expensive
Take your cherry and pull the stem off. This is a vital step. If you leave the stem on, the rod can get deflected or just push the stem into the fruit, which is gross. Place the cherry in the "cup" of the pitter. Now, here is the secret: look at the cherry. You want to align it so the stem end is facing up toward the rod. The pit is naturally closer to that top indentation.
Squeeze firmly. Don't wimp out. You need a quick, decisive motion to punch that pit through the skin on the bottom. If you go too slow, the skin stretches, the juice sprays everywhere, and you end up with a ragged hole. A fast "pop" is what you’re aiming for.
Dealing With Stubborn Pits
Sometimes the pit stays in. It happens. This usually happens with cherries that are either underripe (the flesh is holding onto the stone for dear life) or overripe (the fruit is too mushy to provide resistance). If the pit doesn't drop into your bowl, don't just keep squeezing. Take the cherry out and check it. Sometimes the rod just pushed right past the pit.
If you're using a multi-cherry pitter, the process is slightly different. You line them all up in their little divots. Close the lid. Press down with the palm of your hand. It’s much more efficient, but you have to be careful that every single cherry is seated properly. If one is tilted, you'll end up with a "miss," and biting into a pit in a cherry cobbler is a great way to earn a very expensive trip to the dentist.
Why Handheld Isn't Always Better
I used to swear by the single-hand pitter because it felt more precise. I was wrong. When you're processing five pounds of fruit, the repetitive motion of your thumb and fingers causes actual strain.
📖 Related: Executive desk with drawers: Why your home office setup is probably failing you
If you’re doing high-volume work, get the counter-top versions. The Leifheit Cherrymat is a classic example. It uses a spring-loaded plunger and a gravity-feed system. It's faster. Much faster. But it's also a pain to clean. You have to weigh the time spent pitting against the time spent scrubbing cherry bits out of plastic crevices.
The Splatter Factor
Let's talk about the mess. Cherry juice contains anthocyanins. That’s the stuff that makes them healthy, but it’s also what makes them a nightmare for your clothes.
- Wear an apron. A dark one.
- Pit inside a deep bowl or even a plastic bag.
- If you use a handheld pitter, hold it deep inside the sink. The walls of the sink will catch the spray.
- Keep a damp cloth nearby to wipe up drips immediately.
What if You Don't Have a Pitter?
Look, maybe you don't want another unitasker in your kitchen drawer. I get it. You can use a glass bottle and a chopstick. You put the cherry on top of the bottle opening (stem side up) and push the chopstick through. The pit falls into the bottle. It works, but it's slow. It's the "I'm in a vacation rental and they have nothing" method.
Another option is the paperclip method. You unfold a paperclip into a little hook, shove it into the stem end, twist, and pull the pit out. It keeps the cherry whole, which is nice for garnishes, but it’s incredibly fiddly. Honestly, if you're doing more than ten cherries, just buy the tool. Your sanity is worth the ten bucks.
Choosing the Right Cherries
You can't talk about how to use a cherry pitter without talking about the fruit itself. If your cherries are warm, they will turn to mush. Always pit cherries while they are cold, straight from the fridge. The flesh is firmer, which means the rod makes a cleaner exit hole.
👉 See also: Monroe Central High School Ohio: What Local Families Actually Need to Know
Varieties matter too. Bings are sturdy and pit beautifully. Rainiers are more delicate and can bruise if you're too aggressive with the plunger. Sour cherries (Montmorency) are the hardest because they are smaller and softer, often requiring a specialized pitter with a smaller rod so you don't lose half the fruit in the process.
Cleaning and Maintenance
When you're done, don't let the juice dry. It turns into a sticky glue that can seize up the springs in your pitter. Most modern pitters are dishwasher safe, but honestly, just a quick rinse under hot water usually does the trick if you do it immediately. If you have a model with a lock (to keep it closed in the drawer), make sure it’s fully dry before you lock it, or you might find mold in the hinges next time you pull it out.
Actionable Steps for Your Next Batch
To get the best results when you start pitting, follow this workflow:
- Chill the fruit: Ensure your cherries have been in the fridge for at least two hours.
- Set up a "splash zone": Use a deep bowl or work inside the sink to contain the juice.
- De-stem first: Remove all stems before you even touch the pitter.
- Alignment check: Always place the stem-side up to ensure the rod hits the pit centrally.
- The Quick Punch: Use a fast, firm motion rather than a slow squeeze to keep the fruit intact.
- Verify: Periodically check your "pitted" bowl to make sure a stone hasn't snuck through.
Once you've mastered the rhythm, you can fly through a bag of cherries in minutes. Whether you're prepping for a black forest cake or just want a bowl of fruit that won't break a tooth, using the right technique turns a chore into a simple prep task. Keep the tool clean, keep the fruit cold, and watch your fingers.