Honestly, if you grew up watching Hiccup and Toothless, you probably think you know the How to Train Your Dragon characters inside and out. You've seen the movies. Maybe you even binged the Netflix shows. But there is a massive gap between the DreamWorks version and the original world created by Cressida Cowell in her book series. It’s kinda wild how much changed. In the films, Hiccup is this awkward but capable inventor. In the books? He’s basically a geeky underdog who can literally speak Dragonese—a skill that doesn't even exist in the movies because the dragons don't talk.
Most people don't realize that the "char" or character archetypes in this franchise were specifically designed to subvert Viking tropes. You’ve got Stoick the Vast, who isn't just a "tough dad" but a representation of a dying era of warfare. Then you have Astrid, a character who wasn't even in the original books. She was created because the filmmakers realized they needed a strong female foil for Hiccup’s frantic energy.
The Evolution of Hiccup Horrendous Haddock III
Hiccup is the heart of the story. Obviously. But his character arc is actually a masterclass in "soft power." In a world that prizes physical dominance—think Snotlout’s muscles or Stoick’s sheer bulk—Hiccup wins through empathy and engineering. This was a deliberate choice by director Dean DeBlois and his team. They wanted a protagonist who changed his environment rather than being changed by it.
The How to Train Your Dragon characters all orbit around Hiccup’s gravitational pull. If you look at the first film, his growth isn't about becoming a warrior. It’s about intellectual honesty. He tries to kill a dragon, realizes he can't, and instead of pretending he did, he investigates why he couldn't. That’s a very modern psychological trait placed in a medieval setting.
Cressida Cowell’s version of Hiccup is even more nuanced. He’s smaller. He’s often overlooked by everyone, not just his dad. The movies made him a bit more of a "hero," whereas the books keep him as a "thinker" until the very end. It's a subtle distinction, but it changes how you view his leadership.
Toothless and the Anatomy of a Non-Human Protagonist
Toothless isn't just a pet. He’s a mirror. In the books, Toothless is a tiny, green, common dragon who is incredibly stubborn and kind of a brat. He’s about the size of a pug. When DreamWorks stepped in, they realized a tiny dragon wouldn't carry the emotional weight of a cinematic epic. So, they turned him into the Night Fury.
✨ Don't miss: Chase From Paw Patrol: Why This German Shepherd Is Actually a Big Deal
This change redefined the How to Train Your Dragon characters dynamic entirely. By making Toothless a "forbidden" and rare species, the writers turned the relationship into one of equals. They are both "broken." Hiccup loses a leg; Toothless loses a tail fin. This symmetry is why the bond feels so authentic to audiences. It’s not a master-servant thing. It’s a mutual dependency.
Specific design choices made Toothless feel human. His eyes are positioned more toward the front of his head than a typical reptile, which allows for better "acting" on screen. The animators actually pulled inspiration from black panthers, dogs, and even horses to get that specific mix of lethal and lovable.
Why Astrid Hofferson Changed Everything
Astrid didn't exist in the source material. In the books, the primary female lead is Camicazi, a tiny, blonde, fierce girl from the Bog-Burglars tribe. Astrid was a composite character. She takes the ferocity of the book characters but adds a layer of competitive pressure that Hiccup needs to overcome.
She represents the "ideal Viking." By having the ideal Viking fall for the "unconventional Viking," the story validates Hiccup’s worldview. If Astrid hadn't been convinced by Hiccup’s methods, the rest of Berk never would have followed. She is the bridge.
The Supporting Cast: More Than Comic Relief?
The "Teen Dragon Riders" are often dismissed as just the funny guys. But if you look at the series Race to the Edge, you see more depth.
🔗 Read more: Charlize Theron Sweet November: Why This Panned Rom-Com Became a Cult Favorite
- Fishlegs Ingerman: He’s the academic. While Hiccup is the engineer, Fishlegs is the historian. He’s the one who tracks the "Dragon Manual" and understands the biological limits of the species.
- Snotlout Jorgenson: He’s the manifestation of toxic masculinity being dismantled. He starts as a bully and ends as someone who deeply cares for his Hookfang, even if he’s too embarrassed to admit it.
- The Twins (Ruffnut and Tuffnut): They represent the chaos of the Viking world. They aren't interested in logic or order, which provides a necessary contrast to Hiccup’s constant planning.
These How to Train Your Dragon characters work because they represent different reactions to fear. Fishlegs hides in books. Snotlout lashes out. The twins embrace the madness. Hiccup is the only one who tries to solve the root cause of the fear itself.
Stoick the Vast and the Tragedy of Traditionalism
Stoick is a complex dude. Voice actor Gerard Butler brought a lot of weight to the role, but the writing is what makes him stick. He isn't a villain. He’s a leader trying to keep his people alive in a world where giant flying lizards burn their food supply every Tuesday.
The friction between Stoick and Hiccup is the core conflict of the first movie. It’s not dragon vs. human; it’s tradition vs. innovation. Stoick’s death in the second film is often cited as one of the most emotional moments in modern animation. It wasn't just for shock value. It was a necessary "passing of the torch." For Hiccup to truly lead Berk, the old guard—the physical embodiment of the old way of life—had to move aside.
Valka and the Cost of Isolation
When Valka was introduced in the second movie, it split the fanbase a little bit. Some people felt she was a "deadbeat mom" for staying away for twenty years. Others saw her as a visionary who was doing exactly what Hiccup did, just on a larger scale.
Valka’s character shows us what Hiccup could have become if he didn't have Berk. She became a hermit. She became more dragon than human. This serves as a warning for the protagonist: empathy for "the other" shouldn't mean abandoning your own kind. She is a fascinating addition to the How to Train Your Dragon characters roster because she’s the only one who truly understands the biological majesty of the dragons without the lens of "utility."
💡 You might also like: Charlie Charlie Are You Here: Why the Viral Demon Myth Still Creeps Us Out
Villains: Grimmel, Drago, and the Reflection of Hate
A hero is only as good as their villain. The HTTYD villains are all "dark reflections" of Hiccup.
- Drago Bludvist: He wants to control dragons through fear and brute force. He is the "alpha" by intimidation.
- Grimmel the Grisly: He is the intellectual rival. He’s what Hiccup would be if Hiccup used his brain for genocide instead of harmony. Grimmel doesn't hate dragons because they are dangerous; he hates them because their existence challenges human supremacy.
By comparing these villains to the main How to Train Your Dragon characters, you see that the theme of the whole franchise is choice. Hiccup chooses to be vulnerable. The villains choose to be invincible.
How to Apply These Character Lessons
If you’re a writer or just a fan, there are some pretty clear takeaways from how these characters were built. They aren't static. They evolve based on their trauma and their successes.
- Vulnerability is a Strength: Hiccup’s physical weakness is what led to his greatest discovery. Don't hide the flaws of a character; make the flaw the catalyst for their unique skill.
- Contrasting Dynamics: Put a "Thinker" (Hiccup) with a "Doer" (Astrid) or a "Brute" (Snotlout). The friction creates the plot.
- Environment Matters: The characters act the way they do because Berk is a harsh, cold, unforgiving rock. Their personalities are forged by the weather and the lack of resources.
What to Watch (or Read) Next
If you’ve only seen the movies, you are missing about 60% of the character development. To get the full picture of the How to Train Your Dragon characters, follow this specific path:
- Read the Books: Start with How to Train Your Dragon by Cressida Cowell. It is a completely different experience. It’s funnier, darker, and more whimsical.
- Watch the Shorts: Specifically Gift of the Night Fury. It explores the psychology of the dragons more than the main films do.
- The Series: Race to the Edge (on Netflix) bridges the gap between the first and second movies. It explains how the characters got their new armor, how they discovered new lands, and how the relationships solidified.
The characters in this universe work because they feel like real people caught in an impossible situation. They fail. They argue. They lose limbs. But they keep trying to build a world that’s a little bit kinder than the one they were born into. That is why we still talk about them years after the final movie hit theaters.