You’ve got a new kitten. Or maybe a stray just wandered onto your porch looking for a handout and a warm bed. You’re looking at it, squinting, trying to figure out if you should name it Oliver or Olive. Honestly, it’s harder than it looks, especially when they’re young. Most people think it’s obvious. It isn't. Determining how to tell male cat from female is a bit of a biological guessing game if you don't know exactly what "punctuation marks" you're looking for under that tail.
Getting it wrong is a rite of passage for many pet parents. I've known people who raised "Luna" for three years only to realize Luna was actually a Lou when he started spraying the curtains. It happens. But if you want to avoid the surprise of an unexpected litter or a very confused vet visit, you need to look closer.
The Punctuation Trick That Actually Works
Vets usually explain the difference using grammar. It sounds weird, but it’s the most reliable visual aid we have. When you lift the tail of a female cat, the genital opening and the anus are very close together. The genital opening is a vertical slit. Together, they look like a lowercase "i" or perhaps a semicolon.
Males are different.
On a boy, there is a much larger gap between the anus and the penile opening. We’re talking about an inch of space in an adult cat, or about a finger’s width in a kitten. The opening itself is small and round. This configuration looks like a colon (:). If you see a lot of space, you’re likely looking at a male. This space is where the testicles eventually reside, though in young kittens or neutered adults, those "pom-poms" might be missing or barely visible.
📖 Related: Bridal Hairstyles Long Hair: What Most People Get Wrong About Your Wedding Day Look
Why Kittens Make You Question Everything
Identifying gender in newborns is a nightmare. Even experienced breeders get it wrong. In the first few weeks, everything is swollen and tiny. If you’re trying to figure out how to tell male cat kittens apart from their sisters, wait until they are at least three or four weeks old.
At birth, the physical distance is the only real clue. If you have a whole litter, compare them. Side-by-side comparison is your best friend. You'll notice some have openings that are practically touching, while others have a distinct bridge of skin. That bridge is the future home of the scrotum.
The "Pom-Pom" Factor
By six to ten weeks, a male kitten's testicles usually descend. They look like two little furry marbles. However, don't bet the farm on it. Sometimes one or both testicles are "retained" (cryptorchidism), meaning they’re still tucked up inside the body. If you don't see them, it doesn't 100% mean it's a girl. It might just mean he's a late bloomer or needs a quick surgery to prevent health issues later.
Does Coat Color Give It Away?
Sometimes you don't even need to look under the tail. Genetics are wild.
👉 See also: Boynton Beach Boat Parade: What You Actually Need to Know Before You Go
If you are looking at a calico (white, orange, and black) or a tortoiseshell (mottled black and orange), there is a 99.9% chance it’s a girl. This is because the gene for the orange color is linked to the X chromosome. To get both orange and black, a cat usually needs two X chromosomes. Nature is rarely absolute, though. About 1 in 3,000 calico cats is male, usually due to a genetic condition called Klinefelter syndrome (XXY). They are almost always sterile.
On the flip side, orange tabby cats are much more likely to be male. About 80% of orange cats are boys. It’s not a guarantee like the calico rule, but if you’re betting on an orange stray, "he" is the safer pronoun.
Behavioral Clues That Aren't Always Helpful
People love to project personality onto gender. "Boys are cuddlier," or "Girls are more independent." In my experience, that’s mostly nonsense. Personality is a roll of the dice.
However, hormones do drive specific behaviors in unneutered cats. An intact male will eventually start "spraying." This isn't just peeing; it’s a high-velocity, foul-smelling territorial statement. They also tend to wander. If your cat is constantly trying to bolt out the door and has a face that seems to be getting wider—those are "jowls"—you've got a tomcat. These jowls are thickened skin pads protected by testosterone, meant to shield their necks during fights with other males.
✨ Don't miss: Bootcut Pants for Men: Why the 70s Silhouette is Making a Massive Comeback
Unspayed females have their own "tell." They go into heat. If your cat is suddenly face-down, tail-up, and yowling like she’s in pain, she’s not hurt. She’s just looking for a boyfriend. This behavior is called lordosis, and it’s a dead giveaway.
What About Neutered Males?
This is where it gets tricky for people adopting older cats. Once a male is neutered, the scrotum shrinks and becomes much less obvious. It can look quite flat. If you're looking at a fixed adult, you have to go back to the "colon vs. semicolon" rule. Check the distance. A neutered male will still have that significant gap between the anus and the tiny, circular opening where the penis is retracted.
Medical Realities and Vet Checks
If you've found a stray and can't tell, a vet is your only certain bet. They aren't just looking at the plumbing; they're feeling for things you might miss. Dr. Marty Becker often notes that physical exams are crucial because "hidden" males (cryptorchids) can develop tumors if those internal testicles aren't removed.
Also, don't assume a lack of "parts" means the cat is female. A "tipped" ear—where the tip of one ear is surgically removed—is the universal sign that a stray has been part of a Trap-Neuter-Return (TNR) program. It means the work is already done, regardless of what's happening under the tail.
Actionable Steps for New Cat Owners
Identifying the sex of your cat is the first step in responsible ownership. If you're still staring at your cat's backside with a look of confusion, follow these steps:
- Wait for Relaxation: Don't grab the cat and flip it over. That’s a great way to get scratched. Wait until the cat is happy and perhaps standing with its tail up while eating.
- The "i" vs "Colon" Test: Look at the distance. If the openings are close (less than half an inch in an adult), it’s a girl. If there’s a wide gap (an inch or more), it’s a boy.
- Check the Color: Is it a calico? It’s a girl. Is it orange? Probably a boy.
- Feel (Gently): For kittens older than 8 weeks, you can very gently feel the area in the gap. If you feel two small, firm lumps, those are testicles.
- Look for the Tattoo: Many shelters now put a small green line (tattoo) on a cat’s belly near the surgical site when they are spayed or neutered. If you see that green line, the cat is fixed, which can sometimes make gender ID harder for a layperson but easier for a vet.
- Schedule the Appointment: Regardless of your DIY diagnosis, get to a vet by 4 months of age. Kittens can get pregnant much earlier than people realize, and "he" might turn into a mother of five before you've even finished the first bag of kitten food.