How to Sharpen a Knife with a Sharpening Steel: What Most People Get Wrong

You’re standing in your kitchen, mid-onion, and the blade just... slides. It doesn't bite. It skates over the waxy skin like a hockey puck. Most people reach for that long, ridged metal rod in the knife block and start hacking away at it like they’re starring in a period piece about a medieval blacksmith.

Stop. You’re probably not even sharpening it.

First off, let's get the terminology straight because the industry is kinda lying to you. That rod? It’s usually a honing steel, not a sharpening steel. Actual sharpening involves removing metal to create a new edge. Honing is just pushing the microscopic "teeth" of the blade back into a straight line. If your knife is truly dull—like, "can’t cut a ripe tomato" dull—a standard steel won't save you. But if you know how to sharpen a knife with a sharpening steel correctly, you can maintain a screaming-sharp edge for months without ever touching a whetstone.

The Science of the "Rolled" Edge

Every time your knife hits a wooden or plastic cutting board, the very tip of the edge—which is thinner than a human hair—bends. It doesn't break off; it just folds over. Under a microscope, it looks like a wave. When you try to cut, that folded metal acts like a blunt wall.

A honing steel realigns that fold.

There are different types of rods, though. You’ve got your classic stainless steel ones with longitudinal ridges. Then there are ceramic "steels" and diamond-coated rods. These actually do remove metal, which means they are technically sharpening. If you’re using a high-carbon Japanese blade like a Shun or a Global, stay away from the cheap ribbed steel rods. They’re too aggressive and can actually chip the harder, more brittle steel of those fancy knives. Stick to ceramic for those.

Why Your Technique Probably Sucks

Most people do the "theatrical" move. You know the one. They hold the steel out in front of them and swipe the knife toward their hand at high speeds. It looks cool. It makes a great sound. It’s also the fastest way to ruin a $200 Chef’s knife or end up in the ER.

📖 Related: Popeyes Louisiana Kitchen Menu: Why You’re Probably Ordering Wrong

The problem is consistency. To effectively learn how to sharpen a knife with a sharpening steel, you need a perfect angle. If you’re swinging your arms around like a conductor, your angle is changing by 5 or 10 degrees with every stroke. You’re basically rounding off the edge you’re trying to fix.

The Vertical Method: A Better Way to Work

Forget the movies. Put the tip of the sharpening steel down on a damp kitchen towel on your countertop. Hold it vertically, straight up and down. This gives you a stable, non-moving target. Now, hold your knife horizontally. That’s 90 degrees. Tilt it to 45. Tilt it half again. That’s roughly 22.5 degrees.

Most Western knives (Wüsthof, Henckels) want about a 20-degree angle. Japanese knives are steeper, usually around 15 degrees.

Once you’ve got that angle, pull the knife down the steel. Start with the "heel" of the blade (the part near the handle) at the top of the steel and pull it toward your body as you swipe down, so the tip of the knife finishes at the bottom of the steel. Light pressure. Seriously. You aren't trying to saw the rod in half. Think of it like wiping a crumb off a silk sheet.

Do this five times on one side. Then five on the other. Then four. Then three. You’re tapering the pressure and the frequency to "center" the edge.

The Paper Test Doesn't Lie

How do you know if you actually did anything? Take a piece of standard printer paper. Hold it at the corner. Try to slice through the edge of the paper with the knife. If it snags or tears, you’ve either got a nick in the blade or you didn't hone it enough. If it whispers through with a clean, silent zip, you’re golden.

👉 See also: 100 Biggest Cities in the US: Why the Map You Know is Wrong

I’ve seen professional chefs who have used the same French carbon steel knife for thirty years. The blade is half its original width because they’ve honed it every single day. That's the secret. Honing is a maintenance task, not a repair task.

Common Mistakes That Ruin Blades

1. Going too fast. Speed is the enemy of precision. If you’re moving fast, you’re vibrating. If you’re vibrating, your angle is toast. Slow down.
2. Using too much pressure. If you press hard, you’re just bending the edge the other way. You want the steel to do the work.
3. Wrong material. Using a diamond steel on a cheap, soft stainless steel knife is overkill. You’ll eat the blade away in a year.
4. Ignoring the tip. People often stop the stroke before the tip of the knife touches the steel. That’s why you see so many old kitchen knives with a "beak" at the end—the tip never gets maintained.

Diamond vs. Ceramic vs. Steel

Not all rods are created equal.

Stainless Steel Rods are basically just for "rolling" the edge back. They don't sharpen; they straighten. They are best for soft-ish German steel.

Ceramic Rods are my personal favorite. They are harder than steel, so they actually shave off a microscopic amount of metal. They leave a very smooth, polished edge. If you can only own one, get a ceramic rod. Brands like Idahone make ceramic steels that are legendary in the industry for a reason.

Diamond Rods are the heavy hitters. They are coated in industrial diamond dust. They are very abrasive. If your knife is truly dull, this is the only "steel" that will actually bring it back to life, but use it sparingly. It’s the equivalent of 400-grit sandpaper.

The "Burr" and Why It Matters

When you’re learning how to sharpen a knife with a sharpening steel, you might hear people talk about the "burr." This is the tiny wire of metal that forms on the opposite side of the edge you’re working on. In traditional stone sharpening, you want a burr. In honing? Not so much.

✨ Don't miss: Cooper City FL Zip Codes: What Moving Here Is Actually Like

If you feel a rough edge on one side of your knife after honing, you’ve pushed the metal too far. Do one very light, very steep swipe on the other side to "break" that burr off.

Does the Brand of the Steel Matter?

Honestly? Sorta. Don't buy the $5 one at the grocery store. The ridges on those cheap steels are often too coarse and can actually act like a file, leaving your edge jagged. Look for a "smooth" or "fine" cut steel.

If you look at the work of experts like Bob Kramer—arguably the most famous bladesmith in America—he emphasizes that the tool is only as good as the hand holding it. You can have a $300 custom-forged honing rod, but if your angle is 35 degrees, you’re just making a very expensive spoon.

When the Steel Isn't Enough

Eventually, honing won't work anymore. The edge becomes "thick" because you’ve worked your way back into the wider part of the blade's "V" shape. This is when you need a whetstone or a professional sharpener.

A good rule of thumb: Hone your knife every time you take it out to cook. It takes ten seconds. If you do that, you’ll only need to professionally sharpen the knife once a year. If you ignore the steel, you’ll be struggling with a dull blade within two weeks.

Practical Steps for Tomorrow's Dinner

Don't wait until you're frustrated with a dull knife.

1. Grab a towel. Set your steel up vertically on your counter right now.
2. Check your angle. Use the 90-45-22 trick to find that sweet spot.
3. Execute 10 slow strokes per side. Don't worry about the "zing" sound. Focus on the feel of the metal sliding.
4. Clean the blade. Always wipe the knife after using a sharpening steel. Tiny metal shavings (swarf) can stay on the blade and end up in your food.
5. Store it right. If you throw your newly honed knife into a junk drawer with loose spoons, you’ve wasted your time. Use a magnetic strip or a blade guard.

Keeping a knife sharp isn't about strength; it's about discipline. Consistency beats intensity every single time in the kitchen.