You just met a seven-foot-tall tiefling with a literal engine for a heart and a glowing axe. She’s energetic. She’s swearing. She’s also burning hot enough to melt your armor if you get too close. Romancing Karlach in Baldur’s Gate 3 isn't just about picking the right dialogue options; it’s a high-stakes mechanical puzzle mixed with an emotional marathon. If you mess up the timing in Act 1, you're locked out. Period.
Honestly, Karlach is the "golden retriever" of the group, but her romance is surprisingly fragile. Unlike Astarion or Shadowheart, who might tolerate a little indecision, Karlach requires you to be all-in from the moment you find her by the river near the Risen Road. You’ve got to be her champion because everyone else in the Hells—and a good chunk of the people in Faerûn—wants her dead or back in chains.
✨ Don't miss: Stopping the Sanctum: How to Beat the Metaphor ReFantazio Louis Fight on 9/24
The First Hurdle: Finding the Infernal Iron
Before you even think about a kiss, you need to talk to Dammon. He’s the tiefling smith. You’ll find him at the Emerald Grove. If you side with the Goblins and raid the Grove, say goodbye to your chances. Karlach will leave your party immediately, and even if she didn't, Dammon would be dead, and he’s the only person in the first two acts who knows how to work on her Infernal Engine.
You need Infernal Iron. You can find a piece in the Blighted Village (in the basement of the blacksmith's house) or inside the Shattered Sanctum. Bring it to Dammon while he's at the Grove. He’ll perform the first upgrade. This is the "look but don't touch" phase. She still burns too hot for a real physical connection, but the seeds are sown.
Making Your Move in Act 1
The celebration at the camp after saving the refugees is the make-or-break moment. You need high approval. How do you get it? Be direct. Be kind. Smash things that deserve to be smashed. Karlach loves a hero who doesn't overthink the morality of punching a bad guy.
During the party, talk to her. She’ll mention how much she wants to touch you. Tell her you want that too. If your approval is high enough, you’ll get a scene later that night. But wait. You can’t actually sleep with her yet. If you try, you’ll just get burned. You’ve got to get creative. Some players use a splash of water or a frost spell to momentarily cool her down for a quick kiss. It’s a small, desperate moment of intimacy that defines their early relationship.
Act 2: The Second Upgrade and the Last Light Inn
Once you reach the Shadow-Cursed Lands, your priority is finding the Last Light Inn. Dammon is there. If he survived Act 1, he’s set up a forge in the stables. You need another piece of Infernal Iron.
This is where it gets real. After the second upgrade, Karlach is finally "stable" enough for physical contact. She’ll test it out by hugging you, or if you’ve played your cards right, she’ll be ready for more. This is usually when the "official" romance triggers. You’ll get a long rest event where she comes to your bunk. Don't miss this. If you start a romance with someone else, like Wyll or Gale, during this time, you might accidentally ninja-lock yourself out of Karlach’s path.
The scene at the camp after her second upgrade is one of the most emotional in the game. It’s not just about the sex; it’s about the fact that she hasn't been touched in ten years. Ten years of loneliness in Avernus. She’s terrified of the engine failing, and she’s terrified of dying, and she’s pouring all that energy into you. It’s heavy.
Why People Fail the Karlach Romance
Most players fail because they take too long. If you move into Act 3 without having that specific Act 2 night-time scene at the camp, the game assumes you're just friends. Also, watch your "flirting" with other companions. Baldur’s Gate 3 has a hidden "limit" on active romances. If you’re already "dating" two other people, Karlach won't trigger. You might have to break a few hearts to keep the big red engine running.
📖 Related: Why It's Been Ages NYT Crossword Clues Always Trip You Up
Another common pitfall? Gortash.
Karlach hates Gortash with a burning passion. He’s the one who sold her to Zariel. When you get to Wyrm's Crossing in Act 3, she's going to be a wreck. You need to let her take the lead. If you try to make deals with Gortash in front of her without acknowledging her pain, she’ll lose respect for you.
The Act 3 Date: The Best Scene in the Game?
If you’ve made it to the Lower City and you’re still going strong, Karlach will eventually ask you out on a proper date. Not a "slaying monsters" date, but a dinner at a fancy restaurant. This is a rare moment of normalcy in a world ending via Mind Flayers.
Bring her the clothes she likes. Be supportive. The date can go a few different ways depending on your dialogue, but the goal is to let her feel like a person again, not just a weapon of war. It’s a bittersweet moment because the ticking clock of her engine is always in the background.
Facing the Reality of the Engine
Let's talk about the ending. It's the part of the Karlach romance that keeps people up at night. Her heart is failing. The upgrades Dammon provided were only temporary fixes. As you approach the finale of the game, you're faced with a choice.
- Let her die on the docks after the final battle.
- Go with her to Avernus.
- Let her become a Mind Flayer to save her life (though this changes her fundamentally).
If you’re truly romancing her, going to Avernus together is widely considered the "best" path. It’s a "Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid" moment. You’re both charging into the Hells, cigar in hand, ready to fight until you find a permanent fix. It’s the only ending that feels like it honors her spirit. Staying behind and letting her burn up is devastating.
Practical Steps for Your Playthrough
To make sure you don't miss a beat, follow this sequence:
- Act 1: Recruit her early. Don't go to the Goblin Camp until she's in your party. Get the first Infernal Iron from the Blighted Village and give it to Dammon at the Grove.
- Act 1: During the party, choose the "I want to touch you" options. If you missed the water-splash kiss, don't panic, but make sure your approval is at least "Fair" or "Good."
- Act 2: Head straight for Last Light Inn. Do not pass Go. Do not kill the nightsong yet. Talk to Dammon, get the second upgrade, and then take a few Long Rests in a row to force the camp event to trigger.
- Act 3: Take her to see Gortash's coronation, but talk to her immediately afterward to manage her rage. Kill Gortash eventually.
- The Ending: Choose to stay with her. Whatever happens, don't let her face the end alone.
Romancing Karlach isn't just a side quest. It's the emotional core of the game for a lot of players. She’s the character who wants to live the most, which makes her potential fate the hardest to swallow. Just keep her cool, keep Dammon alive, and never side with the cultists. Do that, and you'll have the most loyal partner in all of the Forgotten Realms.