Let’s be honest for a second. Dealing with internet service providers is usually a nightmare, and trying to figure out how to return an AT&T modem is basically the final boss of that headache. You’ve cancelled your service, you're ready to move on with your life, and then you realize there's a dusty black box sitting in the corner that effectively belongs to a multibillion-dollar corporation. If you don't give it back, they will charge you. A lot. We’re talking anywhere from $150 to $500 depending on the specific gateway model and how many "non-returned equipment" fees they decide to stack on your final bill. It’s stressful.
I’ve seen people just toss these things in a random box, mail them to the wrong warehouse, and then spend six months arguing with collections. Don't do that. AT&T actually has a very specific rhythm to their returns, and if you step out of sync, the automated billing system will flag you before a human ever looks at your account.
The 21-Day Countdown Is Real
You have exactly 21 days. Not a month. Not "whenever you get around to it." From the moment your service is officially disconnected or your new equipment arrives, the clock starts ticking. If AT&T doesn't have that hardware scanned into their system by day 22, you’ll likely see a "Non-Return Equipment Fee" on your statement. It’s automated. It’s cold.
If you're switching to a different provider—maybe you're jumping to Google Fiber or a local Co-Op—make sure you keep your AT&T account login active for a few weeks. You'll need it to track the return status. Most people think once the internet is off, they’re done. Wrong. You’re in a grace period where you’re still "tethered" to them via that hardware.
What actually needs to go back?
Don't send them your old Ethernet cables from 2012. They don't want your HDMI cords or those little yellow-tipped cables you found in the junk drawer. You need to return the Wi-Fi Gateway (that’s the modem/router combo) and the power cord. That’s it. If you had U-verse TV, you also need to pack up the receivers and their respective remotes. Honestly, keep the remotes if you want, but AT&T technically asks for them. If you have an ONT (Optical Network Terminal)—the little box that stays mounted to the wall for fiber—leave it alone. If you rip that off the wall, you're looking at a property damage or equipment replacement fee that makes the modem fee look like pocket change.
👉 See also: iPad Air M3 11: What Most People Get Wrong
The FedEx and UPS Strategy (The Only Way to Fly)
The most common way to handle this is through a partnership AT&T has with FedEx Office and The UPS Store. This is the "Bring It In" method. It sounds simple because it is, but there is a massive trap you have to avoid.
First, find a corporate FedEx Office or The UPS Store. Not a "drop-off point" like a pharmacy or a grocery store locker. It has to be a full-service retail location. You walk in with your equipment. You don't even need a box. Seriously, don't waste your time taping up a cardboard box you found in the garage. They have a system where they scan your AT&T account number (usually found on your bill) or the serial number on the bottom of the modem.
They scan it. They hand you a receipt. Do not lose this receipt. This piece of thermal paper is your only shield against a $150 charge. Take a photo of it. Email it to yourself. Put it in a safe. I've heard countless stories where the equipment gets lost in the bowels of a distribution center in Texas, and the only thing that saved the customer was that tracking number on the receipt. Once the clerk scans it, the equipment is technically "in transit" in AT&T's system, which usually pauses the 21-day clock.
🔗 Read more: How to Ping Apple Watch from Phone (and Why It Sometimes Fails)
Using the Pre-Paid Label (The "Old School" Way)
Sometimes, AT&T sends you a return kit in the mail. This usually happens if you’re doing an equipment swap because your old modem died. If they sent you a box with a label, use it.
- Use the box the new modem came in.
- Peel off the old shipping label.
- Slap the new pre-paid Return Label on there.
- Drop it off at the designated carrier (usually USPS or FedEx, check the label!).
If you go this route, you must write down the tracking number. The "SmartLabel" system they use can be notoriously slow. It might sit in a hub for five days before it even moves.
Why Your Account Status Matters
I once talked to a guy who returned his modem three days after cancelling, but because his account was "In Collection" for a disputed $10 late fee, the system didn't register the return correctly. It was a mess. Before you hand over that hardware, log into the myAT&T app. Check your balance. If you owe money, pay it. It makes the return process significantly smoother because the system won't have any reason to "hold" your equipment status in limbo.
Also, if you're moving, don't leave the modem for the next tenant. They won't return it for you. They’ll probably throw it away or try to use it, and you'll be the one getting the bill. I know it seems obvious, but in the chaos of moving day, that black box often gets left behind on a shelf.
Dealing With the "Equipment Not Received" Email
It happens. You returned the modem ten days ago, you have the receipt, and then—ping—you get an email saying "We haven't received your equipment yet."
Don't panic.
✨ Don't miss: Camera Home Security System: What Most People Get Wrong About True Safety
There is often a lag between the physical delivery at the warehouse and the digital update on your account. However, if you get this email, you need to call the AT&T Loyalty Department (sometimes called the Retentions department). Give them the tracking number from your FedEx/UPS receipt. Usually, once a human sees a valid tracking number that shows "Delivered" or "In Transit," they can manually override the pending charge.
A Note on Fiber Installations
Fiber is different. As I mentioned earlier, the ONT is the "jack" in the wall. If you have the newer BGW320 model (the sleek white one), that is both the ONT and the modem. That whole unit goes back. If you have the older setup where a red cable runs from a small wall box into a black modem, only the black modem goes back. If you’re unsure, look for the AT&T logo. If it has a power cord and it's not screwed into the baseboard, it's likely a returnable item.
Summary of the Practical Path Forward
To make sure you aren't fighting with a customer service rep for three hours next month, follow this specific flow. It’s the most "bulletproof" way to handle the situation.
- Locate your account number. It’s at the top of your bill. You'll need it if the serial number on the modem is scratched or unreadable.
- Disconnect the power and the gateway. Bundle the power cord with the unit. You don't need the boxes or the manuals.
- Drive to a UPS Store or FedEx Office. Ask them specifically, "Do you handle AT&T equipment returns?" Most do.
- Watch them scan it. Don't just leave it on the counter. Stay there until they hand you a printed receipt with a tracking number.
- Save the proof. Take a photo of that receipt immediately.
- Monitor your email. You should get a confirmation from AT&T within 48-72 hours stating they've processed the return. If you don't hear anything after a week, call them.
Once that’s done, you’re free. No surprise charges, no credit score hits, and no more AT&T equipment cluttering up your house. Just make sure you do it within that 21-day window or the automation will win. It’s a simple process, but it requires you to be more organized than the company you're returning it to.
Check your final statement one last time about 30 days after the return. Sometimes a "prorated credit" will appear if you returned the gear early, and you might actually find they owe you a few bucks. It’s rare, but it happens. Mostly, you just want to see that $0.00 balance and the "Account Closed" status. Don't let them keep a ghost of a balance on your name because you forgot a power brick.