You walk out to the patio, ready to smash some burgers, and pull back the cover only to see it. That dreaded, flaky, orange-brown crust. It looks like a relic pulled from the bottom of the Atlantic, not a high-end cooking appliance. Your heart sinks. You think you need to buy a new one. Honestly? You don't. Knowing how to restore a blackstone griddle is basically a rite of passage for outdoor cooks, and it’s way easier than it looks.
Rust is just a surface issue. Unless your griddle has literally rusted through—which takes years of extreme neglect—that heavy cold-rolled steel plate is nearly indestructible. It’s just metal. Metal can be cleaned. Metal can be seasoned. Most people panic and throw these things away or sell them for twenty bucks on Marketplace, but with about an hour of elbow grease and some heat, you can get that factory-black shine back.
The Brutal Truth About Why Your Blackstone Rusted
Before we get into the "how," we have to talk about the "why." Blackstone griddles aren't like your kitchen stove. They are carbon steel. If you leave a carbon steel pan in a damp sink overnight, it’ll have orange spots by breakfast. Now imagine leaving a massive 36-inch slab of it outside in the humidity.
Moisture is the enemy. But more specifically, a weak seasoning layer is the culprit. If your oil layer was thin or if you used an oil with a low smoke point that flaked off, the steel was left "naked." Naked steel plus oxygen plus water equals iron oxide. Rust.
I’ve seen griddles that were left uncovered in the Pacific Northwest for an entire winter come back to life. It’s not about magic; it’s about abrasion and polymerization. You have to get the bad stuff off before you can put the good stuff back on.
The Gear You Actually Need (And What to Ignore)
Don't go buying those expensive "restoration kits" first thing. You might have half this stuff in your garage.
First, you need a heavy-duty metal scraper. Not the flimsy one you use for pancakes—a stiff, wide-blade paint scraper or the official Blackstone heavy-duty scraper works best. You also need some heat-resistant gloves because this process is a lot easier when the metal is screaming hot.
Grab a pack of grill stones or high-grit sandpaper. If the rust is really thick and flaky, start with a 40-grit or 80-grit sandpaper. If it's just surface staining, a pumice grill stone is plenty. You'll also need a massive pile of paper towels or old cotton rags you don't mind ruining. Seriously, you will go through a whole roll.
💡 You might also like: The Real Way to Remove Piercing Bumps Without Making Them Worse
Lastly, the oil. Stick to something with a high smoke point. Avocado oil, grapeseed oil, or the Blackstone Seasoning Paste. Don't use olive oil or butter—they burn too low and create a sticky mess that will just peel off later.
Step 1: The Great Scrape
Turn those burners on high. Let the griddle get hot for about 10 to 15 minutes. Heat expands the metal and helps loosen the bond between the rust and the steel.
Once it’s hot, start scraping.
Do not be gentle. You aren't going to hurt the steel. Push that scraper hard against the surface and peel up as much of the dry rust and old, flaking seasoning as possible. It’s going to be loud. It’s going to be dusty. You’ll see big chunks of black and orange debris piling up. Push it all into the grease trap.
Keep going until you aren't getting any more big flakes. If you see silver metal peeking through, you're on the right track.
Step 2: Grinding Down to Raw Steel
Now, turn the heat off or keep it very low. Squirt a generous amount of cooking oil over the entire surface. While the oil is sitting there, take your grill stone or sandpaper and start scrubbing.
Why the oil matters here
The oil acts as a lubricant and carries the rust particles away so they don't just get ground deeper into the pores of the metal. You’re essentially creating a "rust slurry." It looks disgusting. It’ll be a thick, chocolate-milk-colored goop.
- Focus on the corners. Rust loves to hide in the corners and along the side walls.
- Check the texture. Run your (gloved!) finger over the surface. It should feel smooth, not gritty.
- Wipe and repeat. Use your paper towels to wipe away the dirty oil. If the paper towel comes back bright orange, you need more oil and more scrubbing.
Repeat this until the metal looks relatively uniform. It might not look like a mirror, but it should be smooth to the touch and devoid of any "crunchy" spots.
Step 3: The Neutralization Phase
Once the rust is gone, you have to get the residue off. If you leave tiny microscopic bits of rust or old soap (if you used any), your new seasoning won't stick.
Some people swear by a quick splash of water on a hot griddle to "steam" the pores clean. Be careful with this—too much water on a scorching plate can cause warping, though it's rare on a thick Blackstone. A safer bet is a light wipe with a damp rag, followed immediately by a dry one. The goal is a bone-dry, clean-looking greyish-silver plate.
How to Restore a Blackstone Griddle with the Perfect Seasoning
This is where the magic happens. This is the part people mess up because they are impatient. Seasoning isn't just "putting oil on a pan." It’s a chemical process called polymerization. You are turning liquid oil into a hard, plastic-like film that bonds to the metal.
The Secret is Thin Layers
Drop about a tablespoon of oil on the surface. Use a paper towel (held by tongs if it's too hot) to spread that oil over every single inch. The bottom, the sides, the outer edges.
Now, wipe it off.
Yes, wipe it off. You want the layer of oil to be so thin it looks like it’s barely there. If the oil is thick enough to bead up or puddle, your seasoning will be sticky and gross.
Turn your burners to the highest setting. Watch the smoke. It will start to billow. This is good. You want the oil to hit its smoke point and stay there. Wait until the smoke stops. This usually takes 10 to 15 minutes. The surface will start to turn dark brown or even black.
Repeat, Repeat, Repeat
One layer isn't enough. Not even close. For a full restoration, you need at least three to five layers.
- Apply a tiny bit of oil.
- Wipe it until it looks dry.
- Let it smoke until the smoke clears.
- Wait 2 minutes.
- Do it again.
By the fifth round, your griddle should look like a black mirror. That deep, dark patina is your non-stick surface and your shield against future rust.
Common Mistakes That Will Ruin Your Progress
Most people get lazy around layer three. They think "good enough" is fine. It’s not. If you stop too early, the seasoning is "soft." The first time you scrape a spatula across it to flip a burger, you’ll tear the seasoning right off the metal, exposing it to air and starting the rust cycle all over again.
Another big one: using too much oil. If your griddle feels tacky or sticky after it cools down, you used too much oil. The only way to fix a sticky seasoning is to heat it back up and try to burn it off, or scrape it back down and start over.
And for the love of all things BBQ, don't use dish soap once you've finished the seasoning process. While modern dish soaps don't contain the lye that used to destroy cast iron, they are still designed to break down oils. You just spent an hour building an oil-based barrier; don't invite a degreaser to the party.
Keeping the Rust Away for Good
Once you’ve done the hard work of knowing how to restore a blackstone griddle, you never want to do it again. Maintenance is 90% of the battle.
After every cook, while the griddle is still warm, scrape off the food bits. Squirt a little water on the hot spots to lift the char. Wipe it dry. Then—and this is the most important part—apply a very thin "maintenance layer" of oil while it's still warm.
Invest in a silicone griddle mat if you live in a high-humidity area. These mats sit directly on the metal surface and create an airtight seal, preventing any moisture in the air from touching the steel. Also, make sure your cover is actually waterproof. Many of the cheap canvas covers let water seep through during heavy rain, which then gets trapped under the cover and creates a humidor effect for your griddle.
Summary of Actionable Steps
- Heat it up: Get the griddle screaming hot to loosen debris.
- Scrape aggressively: Use a stiff metal scraper to remove all surface rust and flaking seasoning.
- Oil and Stone: Use cooking oil and a grill stone/sandpaper to grind down to the raw, smooth steel.
- Clean thoroughly: Wipe away all the grey/orange slurry until the paper towels come back clean.
- The 5-Layer Rule: Apply five incredibly thin layers of high-smoke-point oil, letting each layer smoke off completely before adding the next.
- Protect your work: Always apply a thin coat of oil after cooking and use a heavy-duty, waterproof cover.
If you follow this, your Blackstone will probably outlive you. It’s a hunk of steel, and steel is incredibly forgiving. Just keep it seasoned, keep it dry, and keep cooking. The more you use it, the better that seasoning gets.