You're standing over your Maytag, looking at a tub that smells like a wet basement, or maybe you’re trying to fish out a stray sock that’s vanished into the abyss. It's frustrating. You know that to really get things clean—or to fix that grinding noise—you need to figure out how to remove the agitator from a Maytag washing machine. Most people assume it's just one giant plastic bolt, but Maytag has been making washers since before your grandmother was born, and they’ve changed the design more times than I can count.
Honestly, it’s usually just one of two things: a hidden bolt or a terrifyingly firm tug.
If you have an older dependable care model, you're looking at a different beast than the modern Bravo series. This isn't just about repairs, though. If you’ve noticed your clothes coming out with grey flakes or "scrud"—that nasty buildup of fabric softener and skin cells—the only way to truly sanitize the machine is to pull that center post and scrub the gunk hiding underneath. It’s gross. You've been warned.
Identifying Your Maytag Agitator Type
Before you go grabbing the heavy-duty wrenches, look at what you’ve got. Maytag basically uses two main styles. There is the single-piece agitator, which is one solid hunk of plastic from top to bottom. Then there’s the two-piece high-vane agitator. The two-piece ones have an upper "corkscrew" part that moves independently to spiral clothes downward, and a bottom part that does the heavy scrubbing.
Why does this matter? Because the way you get them off is totally different.
If your machine has a fabric softener dispenser on top, start there. Pop that cap off. Underneath, you might see a "dust cap" or a clear plastic seal. Some of the newer Maytag commercial-grade residential units have a 1/4-inch or 7/16-inch bolt sitting right in the center of that column. If you don't see a bolt, don't panic. You aren't crazy. It might be a "press-fit" or "spline-mounted" version. These are held in by nothing but friction and a prayer.
🔗 Read more: Devil signs with hands: Why everyone gets the meaning wrong
The Bolt Method: Step-by-Step
Most classic Maytag top-loaders, including many of the Centennial and older Atlantis models, use a long-axis bolt. You’ll need a socket wrench with a long extension. If you don’t have an extension, you’re going to be jamming your hand down a dark, soapy hole, and it’s not fun.
First, unplug the machine. Seriously. Do it.
Remove the dispenser cup by pulling it straight up. Some require a little twist. Once that's out, look down the center. If there’s a plastic cap, pry it off with a flathead screwdriver. Now, you should see the bolt. It’s almost always a 7/16-inch hex head.
Lefty-loosey applies here. However, these bolts spend their lives submerged in water and detergent. They get "frozen." If it won't budge, don't strip the head. Spray a little WD-40 or PB Blaster down there and let it sit for twenty minutes. Once the bolt is out, the agitator should slide up. If it feels stuck, it’s just soap scum acting like glue. Give it a wiggle.
Sometimes, the bolt isn't at the very top. In some older Maytag Performa models, the bolt is actually located on the side of the agitator base. You have to rotate the drum until you see a small hole in the plastic. You’ll need a small socket to reach in there and loosen the set screw. It’s a pain, but it’s how they were built back then.
Dealing With the "Stuck" Agitator
What if there is no bolt? This is common on many modern Maytag machines. They use a tapered spline. The agitator is essentially shoved onto a grooved metal shaft until it wedges tight.
To remove this, you need a bit of leverage. Here is a trick used by actual appliance techs: take a piece of sturdy nylon rope or a thick towel. Loop it under the bottom rim of the agitator. Give it a sharp, vertical yank.
Don't lean your face over it.
I’ve seen people hit themselves in the jaw when the agitator finally lets go. It’s also helpful to run a "clean washer" cycle with very hot water and vinegar right before you try this. The heat can expand the plastic just enough to break the seal of dried detergent and lime scale. If you're struggling with a Maytag Bravos or a newer MVW model, the "wash plate" (that flat disc that replaces the tall agitator) is removed similarly, though it almost always has a center bolt hidden under a decorative chrome cap.
Why Your Agitator Might Be Failing
If you’re doing this because the top half of your agitator isn't moving, you likely have stripped "dogs." Agitator dogs are small plastic directional wedges. They’re designed to wear out so that your motor doesn't burn up if a rug gets caught.
💡 You might also like: I Like Men Now: The Reality of Late-Blooming Sexual Fluidity
If the bottom of the agitator turns but the top corkscrew just spins freely in both directions, those dogs are toast. They cost about five dollars. Replacing them is the easiest DIY fix in the world of appliances. You just pull the top half of the agitator off (usually after removing the center bolt), swap the plastic bits, and slide it back on.
Common Pitfalls to Avoid
- Using a pry bar: Please, don't shove a metal crowbar under the agitator. You will crack the outer porcelain or plastic tub. Once you chip that tub, it’ll start snagging your clothes, and you’ll have to replace the whole machine.
- Forgetting the O-ring: Many Maytags have a rubber O-ring under the bolt or the cap. If you lose this, water can seep into the drive shaft splines, causing them to rust. If they rust, you will never get that agitator off again.
- Stripping the splines: When you put the agitator back, make sure it’s lined up perfectly with the grooves on the shaft. Don't force it. If it’s not seated right and you start a cycle, the metal shaft will chew the plastic teeth right out of the agitator.
Cleaning the "Scrud"
Since you’ve gone through the trouble of learning how to remove the agitator from a Maytag washing machine, don't just put it back in dirty. The bottom of an agitator is usually a biohazard. It’s a mix of undissolved powdered soap, hard water minerals, and bacteria.
Scrub the inside of the agitator with a long-handled brush and a 50/50 mix of bleach and water. Check the "drive block" (the metal part the agitator sits on) for any signs of heavy corrosion. If the metal is flaking off, your transmission might be on its way out.
Reassembly Tips
Putting it back is easier, but there’s a trick. Make sure the drive shaft is clean. I like to put a tiny, tiny dab of marine-grade grease on the splines. This prevents the plastic and metal from "cold welding" together over the next five years.
Drop the agitator down, ensure it clicks or seats firmly, and thread the bolt in by hand first. If you cross-thread this bolt, you are looking at a very expensive transmission replacement. Tighten it until it's snug, but don't go Incredible Hulk on it. The plastic just needs to be held firm against the shaft.
Actionable Next Steps
Now that you know the mechanics, here is your checklist to get this done today:
- Check your model number: It's usually on a sticker behind the lid or on the back of the control panel. Look it up to see if you need a 7/16-inch socket or if it's a "boltless" design.
- Gather your tools: You’ll definitely need a flathead screwdriver to pry the cap and likely a socket set with a 10-inch extension.
- The "Tug" Test: If you don't see a bolt, try the rope trick. Loop a belt or rope under the base and pull straight up with a quick snap.
- Inspect the Dogs: If you have a two-piece agitator, check the four plastic "dogs" inside the cam assembly. If they are rounded off, buy replacements online before you put everything back together.
- Deep Clean: Use this opportunity to scrub the outer tub. You'll never have better access to that grime than right now.
If you follow these steps, you’ll save yourself a $150 service call and probably extend the life of your washer by a few years. It’s a messy job, but someone’s gotta do it. Just keep your face away from the splash zone when you're prying things loose.