So, you’ve been wearing your polygel set for three weeks and that gap at the cuticle is starting to look like a canyon. We’ve all been there. You want them off. Now. But if you start picking at those edges, you are going to peel away layers of your actual nail plate, and honestly, that takes months to grow back. Polygel is a hybrid—it’s got the strength of acrylic but the flexibility of a gel. Because it’s cured under a UV or LED light, it doesn't just "pop" off like a press-on.
Learning how to remove polygel nails properly is basically the difference between having healthy, long natural nails and having thin, painful "paper" nails that bend when you try to open a soda can. It takes patience.
The Absolute First Step: Shorten the Length
You need to grab your heavy-duty clippers. If you try to soak or file the whole nail while it’s still at a long coffin or stiletto length, you’re just wasting your own time. Clip the extension down as close to your natural free edge as you can without actually cutting your real nail. Use a 100/180 grit file to thin out the bulk of the product on top. Polygel is thick. If you don't file off that top seal and at least 50% of the product height, the acetone won't be able to penetrate the material. It'll just sit there.
I’ve seen people try to soak for an hour without filing first. It doesn't work. The chemical structure of polygel (often a mix of oligomers and polymers) is designed to be non-porous once cured. You have to physically break that barrier.
Why Some Pros Say No to Soaking
Here is a bit of a controversy in the nail world. Some brands, like Gelish PolyGel, are technically "soak-off" if you use enough acetone and time. However, many nail techs, including famous educators like Suzie from Nail Career Education, often prefer filing them down to a thin base layer and letting that grow out or just e-filling them off.
🔗 Read more: Dr Dennis Gross C+ Collagen Brighten Firm Vitamin C Serum Explained (Simply)
Why? Because acetone is incredibly drying. It leaches the oils out of your skin and can make your natural nail brittle. If you have a steady hand and a good hand file, you can actually file away the polygel until there is only a paper-thin layer left. Then, you just buff it smooth. This avoids the chemical bath entirely. But, if you aren't confident with a file, the soak-off method is your safest bet to avoid over-filing your own nail.
The Soak-Off Method That Actually Works
Don't just stick your hands in a bowl of acetone. It's messy and inefficient.
Instead, get some cotton balls, high-quality 100% pure acetone (don't use the "strengthening" polish remover from the grocery store, it’s too weak), and small squares of aluminum foil. Saturate the cotton. Place it directly on the filed-down nail. Wrap it tight with the foil.
The heat from your fingers gets trapped in the foil, which actually speeds up the chemical reaction. Wait 15 to 20 minutes. No peeking. If you open it too early, the acetone evaporates and the polygel starts to re-harden. When you pull the foil off, the product should look crumbly or "gummy." Use an orange wood stick or a plastic cuticle pusher to gently—and I mean gently—scrape the softened goo away. If it doesn't move easily? Wrap it back up for another five minutes.
💡 You might also like: Double Sided Ribbon Satin: Why the Pro Crafters Always Reach for the Good Stuff
A Quick Warning on E-Files
If you bought one of those cheap electric drills off an ad, be careful. E-files are amazing tools, but in the hands of a beginner, they are dangerous. It only takes a split second to hit the "red line"—that's the friction burn you feel when you've filed through the product and hit the living nail tissue. If you're learning how to remove polygel nails at home for the first time, stick to the manual hand file for the last 20% of the product.
Dealing With "The Ghost" Layer
Sometimes, even after soaking, you'll see these little white patches that look like the polygel is still stuck there. It's tempting to scrape harder. Don't.
This is often just extreme dehydration. Take a buffing block (220 grit or higher) and lightly smooth the surface. Once you apply a bit of cuticle oil—and you should be drenching your hands in it after using acetone—those white patches usually disappear. If they don't, it’s a tiny bit of leftover base coat. Leave it alone. It’s better to have a microscopic bit of base coat left on the nail than to have a divot in your nail plate from over-scraping.
Post-Removal Recovery
Your nails are going to feel weirdly light and maybe a little flexible after the polygel is gone. This is partly because they’ve been protected by a hard shell for weeks and partly because they are dehydrated.
📖 Related: Dining room layout ideas that actually work for real life
- Wash your hands with mild soap to get the acetone residue off.
- Apply a high-quality nail oil. Look for brands that use Jojoba oil, like CND SolarOil. Jojoba has a molecular structure small enough to actually penetrate the nail plate.
- Give it a rest. If you can, wait 24 hours before applying a new set. This gives the nail plate time to rehydrate and "reset."
Common Mistakes to Avoid
- The "Teeth" Method: Never, ever bite your polygel off. You are literally ripping the top layer of your nail cells off.
- Cold Acetone: If your room is cold, the soak will take forever. Some people safely place their foiled hands inside a warm towel to speed things up.
- Using the Wrong File: A 180 grit is standard. A 100 grit is very coarse and meant for the bulk. Never use a 100 grit on your natural nail.
Essential Supplies for Success
- 100/180 Grit Hand File
- 100% Pure Acetone (Check the label, it must be 100%)
- Cotton balls or lint-free wipes
- Aluminum foil squares or silicone soak-off caps
- Orange wood sticks (metal ones can be too harsh for beginners)
- High-quality cuticle oil (Jojoba-based)
- Buffer block
The Reality of Polygel Chemistry
Polygel is essentially an "oligomer" based system. Unlike acrylic, which cures through a liquid-and-powder monomer reaction, polygel stays workable until it hits the UV light. This means the bond it creates with your nail is incredibly strong. It’s why you can’t just soak it off in five minutes like a standard soak-off gel polish. The molecular chains are denser.
Understanding this helps you realize why the filing step is so vital. You are manually breaking down those chains so the solvent can do its job. If you’re using a brand like Makartt or Modelones, they tend to be a bit more stubborn than the professional-grade Gelish, so you might need an extra five minutes of soaking time.
Once you’ve successfully cleared the product away, look at your nails. If they look shiny and smooth, you did it right. If they look "shredded" or have white peeling bits, you likely scraped too hard or didn't soak long enough. Take a mental note for next time. Nail health is a long game.
Now that the product is off, the best thing you can do is massage that Jojoba oil into your cuticles and the underside of your free edge. Do this twice a day for the next week. Your natural nails will thank you by staying strong and ready for your next manicure.
Clean your tools with alcohol and store them in a dry place. If you used wooden sticks, toss them—they're single-use only. Your files can be used again as long as they aren't clogged with dust; just give them a quick tap and a spray of disinfectant.