You’re leaning into it. Your knuckles are white, your jaw is clenched, and you’re giving that old, rusted fastener everything you’ve got. Then, it happens. A sickening snap or a dull grind. You look down and the head of the screw is either sheared clean off or stripped into a smooth, useless crater. It’s a gut-punch moment. You've probably already muttered a few choice words. Honestly, figuring out how to remove a screw with a broken head is less about raw strength and more about outsmarting the physics of friction.
Most people just keep digging with their screwdriver, hoping for a miracle. They end up making it worse. If you’ve already turned a Phillips head into a circular pit of despair, stop. Just stop. You’re fighting a losing battle against metal fatigue. There are actually about half a dozen ways to fix this, and none of them involve throwing your drill across the garage.
The Rubber Band Trick and Other "Soft" Saves
Before you go buying heavy machinery, start small. Sometimes you just need a little more "bite." This is the oldest trick in the book. Grab a wide, flat rubber band from your junk drawer. Lay it flat across the mangled screw head. Push your screwdriver tip into the rubber band and then into the screw. The rubber fills the gaps where the metal used to be. It provides just enough grip to get things moving.
👉 See also: The Stories Lesbian First Time Realities: What Movies Get Wrong and How It Actually Feels
It doesn't always work. If the screw is rusted deep into a 4x4, a rubber band isn't doing squat. But for a slightly stripped hinge screw? It’s a lifesaver.
Then there’s valve grinding compound. You can find this at any auto parts store like O'Reilly or AutoZone. It’s a gritty paste. Put a dab on the screw head. The grit acts like tiny teeth for your screwdriver. It’s a subtle difference, but that extra friction is often the gap between "stuck forever" and "finally moving."
When the Head is Completely Gone
What if the head snapped off entirely? Now you’re looking at a headless shank buried flush with the wood or metal. This is the "broken head" nightmare. You can’t grab it with pliers because there’s nothing to grab.
Actually, if there’s even a millimeter of the shank sticking out, reach for the Vise-Grip brand locking pliers. Don't use standard pliers. You need something that locks with enough force to deform the metal slightly. Clamp them on perpendicular to the screw. Turn slowly. If you rush it, you’ll just shear off the remaining nub.
If it's flush, you have to create a new slot. Use a Dremel tool with a thin reinforced cutoff wheel. Carefully cut a single straight groove across the top of the broken shank. You’re essentially turning a broken mess into a flat-head screw. Grab your widest flat-head screwdriver, press down with your entire body weight, and twist.
Why Screws Break in the First Place
It’s rarely just "bad luck." Most of the time, it’s a combination of over-torquing and "hydrogen embrittlement," a phenomenon where high-strength steel becomes brittle and cracks. This happens often in cheap, imported fasteners found in flat-pack furniture. According to materials experts at organizations like ASTM International, the grade of the steel dictates how much "twist" it can take before the head gives up. If you're working with old deck screws, they've likely undergone years of thermal expansion and contraction, making them prime candidates for snapping.
The Nuclear Option: Screw Extractors
When the DIY hacks fail, you need an EZ-Out or a dedicated screw extractor set. Brands like Irwin or Ontel make these. They look like weird, reverse-threaded drill bits.
- Center punch it. Take a nail or a center punch and tap a small divot into the exact center of the broken screw. If you don't do this, your drill bit will "walk" across the metal and ruin the surrounding surface.
- Drill a pilot hole. Use a high-quality cobalt drill bit. Wood bits won't work here. You need something that can eat through hardened steel.
- Insert the extractor. Tap the extractor into the hole. Because it has reverse threads, as you turn it counter-clockwise, it bites deeper into the screw.
- The moment of truth. Eventually, the extractor’s grip exceeds the screw’s resistance. The whole thing should start to back out.
Using Heat to Break the Bond
If you’re working with metal-on-metal—like a broken bolt in an engine block or a bicycle frame—the problem is often "galvonic corrosion." Basically, the two metals have chemically bonded over time.
Heat is your friend. Use a propane torch (carefully) to heat the surrounding area. Metal expands when hot. This expansion can crack the microscopic rust seals holding the screw captive. Drop a bit of penetrating oil like WD-40 Specialist or PB Blaster onto the joint while it's hot. The oil will "wick" into the threads via capillary action. Wait ten minutes. Try again.
A Warning on Heat
Don't use a torch on finished wood. You'll have a fire or a ruined piece of furniture. For wood, stick to the mechanical methods.
The Last Resort: Drilling it Out Completely
Sometimes, you just have to give up on the screw and save the hole. If you’ve tried extractors and they’ve snapped (which is a whole different nightmare because extractors are made of hardened steel that is almost impossible to drill), you might have to drill out the entire screw.
Use a bit slightly larger than the screw's diameter. Drill straight down. Once the screw is gone, the hole will be too big for a new screw. You'll need to plug it with a wooden dowel and wood glue, then redrill a fresh pilot hole once it's dry. In metal, you’d use a "Helicoil" to replace the threads you just destroyed. It’s tedious. It’s messy. But it works.
Actionable Steps for Success
Success in removing a broken screw depends on your patience. The second you get frustrated is the second you strip the metal beyond repair.
📖 Related: Carlos Castaneda and The Teachings of Don Juan: Why the Mystery Still Haunts Us
- Switch to a Manual Screwdriver: Drills move too fast. They strip heads in milliseconds. Once the head is compromised, use a manual driver for better "feel."
- Apply Downward Pressure: 80% of your effort should be pushing into the screw, and only 20% should be turning it.
- Check Your Bits: If your screwdriver bit is rounded at the edges, throw it away. Using a worn bit on a stubborn screw is a guarantee of failure.
- Use Penetrating Oil Early: Don't wait until you're desperate. If a screw feels "crunchy" or stuck, soak it in PB Blaster and walk away for an hour.
- Identify the Metal: If it's a brass screw, be extremely gentle. Brass is soft and the heads pop off if you even look at them wrong. Stainless steel is tougher but can "gall" (cold weld) to other stainless parts.
Dealing with a broken screw head is a rite of passage for anyone doing home repairs or mechanical work. It’s frustrating, sure. But if you have a Dremel, some locking pliers, and a decent extractor set, there isn't a screw in the world that can stay stuck forever. Just remember to take it slow. If the metal starts to feel "spongy," stop turning and re-evaluate your grip. Your future self will thank you for not turning a five-minute fix into a three-hour ordeal.