Every April, we convince ourselves we know exactly what’s going to happen. We refresh Twitter every six seconds, obsess over hand size measurements, and pretend that a twenty-year-old’s 40-yard dash time tells us if he’s the next Justin Jefferson. It doesn't. Not really. If you want to actually predict the NFL draft, you have to stop looking at the highlights and start looking at the math, the history, and the sheer desperation of NFL GMs.
Predicting this thing is a chaotic science. It’s a mix of game theory and high-stakes poker where everyone is lying to everyone else. You’ve got "smoke season," where agents leak fake interest to drive up a player’s value, and coaches who fall in love with "traits" over actual on-field production. Honestly, most mock drafts are busted by pick number four.
Why Your Mock Draft Always Breaks Early
The biggest mistake people make when they try to predict the NFL draft is drafting for what the team needs instead of how the team operates. Fans look at a roster and say, "The Giants need a wide receiver." But Joe Schoen or any other GM might be looking at the draft board and seeing a massive drop-off in offensive tackle talent after the first ten picks.
Teams have tiers. If their top tier is empty, they trade back. If a player they have graded as a "blue-chip" talent falls to them, they take him, even if they already have a starter at that position. Look at when the Eagles took Jalen Hurts while they still had Carson Wentz. Nobody predicted that because everyone was focused on "need."
The Numbers That Actually Matter
Forget the jersey swaps. If you want to be accurate, look at the Relative Athletic Score (RAS). Created by Kent Lee Platte, RAS aggregates a player's combine measurements into a single score from 0 to 10. Certain teams, like the Indianapolis Colts under Chris Ballard, almost exclusively draft players with an RAS above 9.0. If you’re trying to predict who the Colts take in the second round, just filter for the most "freakish" athletes left on the board. You’ll be right more often than not.
Age is another one. It’s called "Breakout Age." Analytical teams—think the Browns or the Ravens—love guys who dominated in college at 18 or 19 years old. If a player stayed in school for five years and finally had a good season at age 23, the Ivy League grads in the front office usually get skeptical. They see a "grown man" beating up on 19-year-olds, which won't happen on Sundays.
The Quarterback Premium
Everything changes when a QB is involved. Desperation is a hell of a drug. When a coach is on the hot seat, they don't draft a boring left tackle; they draft a savior. This is why you see "reaches." You might think a quarterback has a second-round grade, but if three teams need a starter, that guy is going in the top ten. Period.
Trusting the Right Insiders
Stop listening to the "draft gurus" who just watch film. Start listening to the guys who talk to the decision-makers. Adam Schefter and Ian Rapoport are the obvious ones, but the real gold is often found with local beat writers.
A guy who has covered the Packers for 20 years knows their "type." He knows that Green Bay rarely takes a wide receiver in the first round. He knows the Steelers love linebackers from big-ten schools. If you want to predict the NFL draft with any sort of consistency, you have to learn the "organizational DNA" of all 32 teams.
The SEC Bias is Real
It’s not just a meme. NFL teams trust the SEC because it’s the closest thing to a semi-pro league. When a corner locks down an LSU receiver, scouts believe it more than if he did it against a directional school in a mid-major conference. Georgia, Alabama, and Ohio State are basically NFL factories. If you’re torn between two players in your predictions, pick the one who played on Saturday nights in front of 100,000 people.
✨ Don't miss: Who Do Lions Play This Week: Why the Answer Is Complicated Right Now
Positional Value is the Golden Rule
You’ll almost never see a linebacker go before a premium edge rusher unless that linebacker is a generational freak like Micah Parsons. The league values four things above all else:
- Quarterbacks (The engine)
- Left Tackles (The insurance)
- Edge Rushers (The disruptors)
- Cornerbacks (The erasers)
If you’re predicting a team to take a safety or a running back in the top ten, you better have a massive amount of evidence to back it up. In the modern NFL, that’s considered "bad value."
How to Handle the Trades
This is where the wheels fall off. Predicting trades is basically impossible, but you can predict the probability. Teams with a lot of draft capital (like the Bears or Cardinals in recent years) are always candidates to move. Keep an eye on the "Draft Value Chart." Most teams still use a version of the old Jimmy Johnson chart, which assigns a point value to every pick. If the points don't add up, the trade probably won't happen.
Sometimes, a team just gets bored. Or panicked. You’ll see a run on a certain position—say, three wide receivers go in a row—and suddenly the team at pick 15 panics because they think the cupboard is bare. They’ll overpay to move up to 12. You have to account for that human element of fear.
Practical Steps for Your Final Prediction
- Check the Pre-Draft Visits: Teams are allowed 30 "Top 30" visits where they bring prospects to their facility. While some of this is a smokescreen, about 70% of drafted players had some form of official contact with the team that picked them. If a player didn't visit or talk to a team at the Combine, it's a long shot.
- Follow the Money: Look at the betting markets. Professional bettors often have better info than the media. If a player’s odds to go "Under 5.5" suddenly skyrocket, someone knows something.
- Ignore the "Pro Day" Hype: Everyone looks good in shorts with no pass rush. Don't let a viral video of a QB throwing a 70-yard bomb in an empty stadium change your evaluation. It's noise.
- Read the Pressers: When a GM says "we want to get tougher in the trenches," believe them. They are usually telling you exactly what they plan to do, we just assume they're lying.
- Watch the Late Risers: Every year, one guy from a small school or a player with "injury concerns" clears his medicals and shoots up the boards in the final 48 hours. This is usually the NFL's actual opinion finally filtering out to the public.
The NFL draft is the only sporting event where nobody actually plays a game, yet it’s one of the most watched nights of the year. It’s hope. It’s the idea that one guy can change a franchise. To predict the NFL draft successfully, you have to embrace the mess. Look for the patterns in the chaos. Study the GMs who have been in their jobs for more than five years; they are creatures of habit. They will show you their cards if you look close enough.
Don't get married to your first mock. Be ready to pivot when the first trade happens. That’s how you win.