You know that pile of shirts? The ones sitting in the back of your drawer because the sleeves feel restrictive or they’ve got those annoying yellow pit stains? Yeah, those. Honestly, most people just toss them or donate them to thrift stores where they’ll probably end up in a landfill. But there is a better way to handle it. Making a shirt a tank top is basically the ultimate DIY move for summer, the gym, or just lounging around without feeling like you're being strangled by cotton.
It’s surprisingly easy. Seriously.
But here is the thing: most people mess it up because they think they can just eyeball it with a pair of kitchen scissors. They end up with one armhole reaching down to their hip and the other barely clearing their shoulder. It looks messy. Not the "cool vintage" messy, but the "I gave a toddler safety scissors" messy. If you want to do this right, you need to understand how fabric actually behaves once it’s been cut.
Why Your First Cut Usually Fails
Most t-shirts are made of jersey knit. This is important. Jersey doesn't fray like a button-down shirt would, but it does curl. When you learn how to make a shirt a tank top, you have to account for that "roll." The moment you snip those sleeves off, the raw edge is going to start rolling toward the outside or inside, depending on the tension of the knit.
If you cut exactly where you want the line to be, the roll will actually make the armhole look bigger and the shoulder strap look thinner than you intended. I've seen so many people ruin perfectly good concert tees because they didn't leave a "buffer zone" for the fabric to do its thing.
👉 See also: North Highlands Antelope Library: Why This Sacramento Hub is Actually Worth Your Time
Also, can we talk about the neckline? People focus so much on the arms that they forget the collar. A thick, ribbed crew neck looks weird with massive gaping armholes. You usually have to trim the neck too if you want that cohesive, relaxed look.
The Gear You Actually Need (Don't Skip This)
Stop using your kitchen scissors. Please.
If you try to cut through two layers of heavy cotton with the same blades you use to open packages of chicken, you’re going to get jagged edges. You need fabric shears. They are sharper, longer, and designed to slice through fibers without "chewing" them. If you’re feeling fancy, a rotary cutter and a self-healing mat are even better because they allow for one continuous motion, which eliminates those little "nicks" in the fabric.
You also need:
- Chalk or a washable fabric marker. Do not use a Sharpie. It will bleed.
- A ruler or a flexible measuring tape.
- A "template" shirt. Find a tank top you already love the fit of. This is the secret weapon.
How to Make a Shirt a Tank Top Step-by-Step
First, lay your shirt out on a flat, hard surface. A carpeted floor is your enemy here because the fabric will snag and shift as you try to mark it. Smooth out every single wrinkle. If the shirt is particularly wrinkled, iron it. I know, ironing sucks, but if you cut a wrinkled shirt, your lines will be crooked once the fabric relaxes.
Marking the Lines
Take your template tank top and lay it directly on top of the t-shirt. Align the necklines.
Now, here is the trick. Don't trace the template exactly. Trace about half an inch outside the template. This accounts for that fabric roll I mentioned earlier. Use your chalk to draw a smooth curve from the top of the shoulder down to the armpit.
Some people like a "muscle tee" look where the armhole goes way down the ribs. If that's what you're after, bring your mark down about three or four inches below the original armpit seam. Just remember: you can always cut more later, but you can't put the fabric back on.
The Actual Cutting
When you start cutting, don't pick the shirt up. Keep it flat. Slide the bottom blade of your shears along the table surface. This keeps the two layers of fabric from sliding against each other.
Once you’ve cut one side, stop.
Don't just move to the other side and try to mirror it by eye. Instead, fold the shirt in half vertically. Align the shoulder seams and the side seams. Now, you can use the side you just cut as a guide for the second side. This is the only way to ensure your tank top is actually symmetrical. If you skip this, you’ll end up with a lopsided mess.
Dealing With the "Raw Edge" Look
Once the sleeves are gone, give the edges a good tug. Pull on the fabric in the direction of the cut. This encourages the jersey to roll. It hides any tiny imperfections in your cutting and gives it that finished, "store-bought" look.
If you hate the rolling, you’re going to have to hem it. That requires a sewing machine and a zigzag stitch or a serger. But honestly? Most people making a shirt a tank top are going for a casual vibe where the raw edge is part of the appeal.
What About the Neckline?
If the original collar feels too tight now that the sleeves are gone, you can cut it off entirely. The best way is to cut just below the ribbed binding. Follow the curve carefully. Again, stay about a quarter-inch away from where you think you want the final edge to sit.
A "scoop neck" or a "deep V" can be achieved by marking a new point lower on the chest and drawing a new curve. Just be careful—if you go too wide on the neck and too deep on the armholes, the shoulder straps will become too thin and might snap or stretch out during a wash.
Advanced Tips for Different Fabrics
Not all shirts are created equal. A 100% cotton heavy-weight Gilden tee behaves differently than a tri-blend (cotton/polyester/rayon) shirt.
- 100% Cotton: Very stable, easy to cut, rolls significantly.
- Tri-blends: Very soft, prone to stretching while you cut. You need to be extra careful not to pull the fabric while slicing.
- Synthetics/Dry-Fit: These don't always roll. Sometimes they just stay flat and look a bit "unfinished." They also tend to fray more than cotton, so you might actually need to use a fray-check liquid on the edges.
Common Mistakes to Avoid
Don't cut through the side seams if you can help it. If your shirt has side seams (most modern shirts do), try to stop your armhole cut just before you hit the seam, or make sure you reinforce the seam with a few hand stitches if you do cut through it. Otherwise, the shirt might start unravelling from the bottom up.
Avoid cutting the back of the shirt exactly like the front. Usually, you want the back of the armholes to be a bit shallower than the front to allow for movement. If you cut them the same, the shirt might "ride back" or feel like it's pulling against your throat.
Real-World Use Cases
I've seen this work incredibly well for "pump covers" at the gym. You take an oversized XL shirt, cut the sleeves deep, and suddenly you have a breathable gym top that actually looks intentional.
It’s also great for vintage shirts where the sleeves are weirdly short or "bell-shaped"—a common problem with 70s and 80s blanks. By removing the sleeves, you preserve the graphic but fix the dated silhouette.
Moving Forward With Your DIY Wardrobe
Now that you've got the basics down, don't just stop at one shirt.
The best way to master this is through repetition. Start with a "test" shirt—something from a thrift store or an old pajama top—before you move on to your favorite band tee. Once you get a feel for how the shears move and how the fabric curls, you can start experimenting with different shapes, like racerbacks or "stringer" styles.
- Step 1: Sort your shirts by fabric type. Stick to cotton or cotton blends for your first few tries.
- Step 2: Invest in a pair of $15 fabric shears. It's the best money you'll spend on this project.
- Step 3: Always use a template. Your favorite fitting tank is your best guide.
- Step 4: Wash the shirt after cutting. The dryer cycle actually helps set the "roll" on the edges and hides the cut marks.
Getting the hang of making a shirt a tank top is a legitimate skill that saves money and keeps clothes in rotation longer. It’s about taking something that doesn't fit quite right and turning it into something you actually want to wear. Just take your time, use the right tools, and remember to fold it in half before you cut that second side. Your wardrobe will thank you.