It happens to everyone. You’re deep into a weekend project, maybe fixing a loose cabinet door or swapping out a battery in a kid’s toy, and then you hear it. That sickening grind. The screwdriver slips, the metal shavings fall like tiny gray snowflakes, and suddenly, the neat cross or line on the head of that screw is a smooth, useless crater. You’ve just learned how to loosen a stripped screw the hard way—by making it nearly impossible to move.
Honestly, it’s a moment that can ruin a whole afternoon. You feel that surge of frustration because a five-cent piece of hardware is now holding your entire project hostage. But here’s the thing: pros deal with this constantly. Whether it's a rusted bolt on a 1960s Chevy or a soft brass screw in a piece of IKEA furniture, there is almost always a way out. You just have to stop turning the screwdriver immediately before you make the hole even deeper.
The Physics of Why Screws Strip
Before we get into the "how-to," we have to talk about why this happens. Most people think they just aren't strong enough. In reality, it’s usually the opposite. You’re applying too much torque and not enough downward pressure. This is a phenomenon called "cam-out."
Phillips head screws were actually designed to cam-out. Back in the day, when automated factories were new, they wanted the tool to slip out of the screw head rather than snap the screw or damage the product if the machine applied too much force. Great for a 1940s assembly line; terrible for you trying to take apart a deck in 2026.
When the metal of the driver is harder than the metal of the screw, the driver wins. It eats the screw alive. Cheap screws, often made of soft zinc or low-grade aluminum, are the biggest culprits. If you’re using a power drill on a high speed setting, you’re basically running a tiny milling machine on your fastener.
First Aid: The Rubber Band Trick and Other Hacks
If the screw is only slightly damaged, you don't need heavy machinery. You need friction.
The most famous "dad hack" in the book is the rubber band. Grab a wide, flat rubber band (the kind they put around broccoli is perfect). Lay it flat over the stripped head and then insert your screwdriver. The rubber fills the gaps where the metal has been chewed away, giving the driver something to bite into. It’s simple. It’s cheap. It works about 40% of the time.
If that fails, look for some valve grinding compound or even a bit of kitchen cleanser like Bar Keepers Friend. These products contain tiny abrasives. A drop of abrasive paste on the tip of your screwdriver can provide just enough "grit" to stop the slipping.
Then there's the hammer method. If you’re using a manual screwdriver, give the end of the handle a sharp whack with a hammer while it’s seated in the screw. This does two things: it helps break any corrosion (especially if the screw is "frozen" or rusted) and it can sometimes re-seat the metal of the screw head just enough to get a grip.
How to Loosen a Stripped Screw with Real Tools
When the rubber band fails, you have to move up the food chain. You need to stop treating it like a screw and start treating it like a piece of stuck metal.
🔗 Read more: Why Putting Plastic Forks in the Garden Actually Works
The Power of Vise-Grips
If the screw head is sitting even a millimeter above the surface, stop trying to use a screwdriver. You’re wasting your time. Grab a pair of locking pliers—Vise-Grips are the industry standard here. Clamp them onto the outside of the screw head as tightly as humanly possible. You want them so tight that it hurts your hand to lock them. Once they are locked on, turn the pliers horizontally. This bypasses the stripped internal "socket" entirely.
Manual Impact Drivers
Don't confuse this with your battery-powered impact wrench. A manual impact driver is a heavy steel tool that you hit with a hammer. When you strike the back, the internal mechanism converts that downward force into a powerful, high-torque burst of rotation. It forces the bit into the screw at the exact same millisecond it tries to turn it. This is how mechanics get rusted-on rotors off cars. It’s an essential tool for anyone who does DIY.
Screw Extractors (The "Easy-Out")
If the head is totally gone or flush with the wood, you’re looking at an extractor. These are reverse-threaded drill bits.
- Drill a small pilot hole directly into the center of the stripped screw. Use a cobalt drill bit if the screw is high-grade steel.
- Insert the extractor bit.
- Turn it counter-clockwise.
Because the extractor has left-handed threads, the harder you turn it to "unscrew" it, the deeper it bites into the hole you drilled. Eventually, the friction of the extractor overcomes the friction of the screw threads, and the whole thing backs out.
Heat, Cold, and Chemicals
Sometimes the metal isn't just stripped; it's bonded. This is common in plumbing or automotive work where "galvanic corrosion" occurs—basically, two different metals have a tiny chemical party and fuse together.
Penetrating oils are your best friend here. Don't use WD-40. It’s a great water displacer, but it’s a mediocre penetrant. You want something like PB Blaster, Liquid Wrench, or Kroil. These oils have incredibly low surface tension. They actually "climb" up into the threads through capillary action. Spray it on, walk away, and have a coffee. Let it sit for at least 30 minutes.
If it's still stuck, get a propane torch. Heat the area around the screw (if the material isn't flammable). Heat causes metal to expand. When it cools, it contracts. This microscopic movement is often enough to break the seal of rust. Just don't burn your house down over a stripped hinge screw.
The "Nuclear" Options
If you’ve tried the extractors and the pilot hole snapped off or the screw is just too far gone, you have to get creative.
One trick is using a Dremel or a rotary tool with a thin cutting disk. You can carefully cut a deep, straight slot across the top of the stripped head. Now, you’ve turned a stripped Phillips screw into a brand-new flathead screw. Use the biggest flathead screwdriver you have and lean into it with all your body weight.
What if the head snaps off entirely? Now you have a "stud" buried in the material. At this point, you are likely going to have to drill the entire screw out. Use a bit that is slightly smaller than the diameter of the screw's body. Once you've hollowed it out, you can sometimes pick the remaining "coils" of thread out with a needle-nose pliers or a pick. Or, just drill a larger hole and use a "plug" or a "helicoil" to repair the wood or metal.
Common Mistakes to Avoid
Most people make the situation worse because they are in a hurry.
- Using the wrong bit size: A #2 Phillips bit in a #3 screw head is the fastest way to strip it. Ensure the fit is perfect.
- Spinning the drill fast: High speed equals high heat. Heat softens the metal. If the screw isn't moving, stop.
- Ignoring the "Left-Loosey" rule: It sounds stupid, but in a cramped space or when looking at a screw from the back, people often tighten the screw further, stripping it instantly. Double-check your direction.
Real-World Advice from the Pros
I spoke with Mike, a contractor with 30 years of experience in home restoration. He told me that 90% of his stripped screw problems come from people using the "wrong" type of screw for the job.
✨ Don't miss: What Is a Barbarian? Why Everything You Know Is Basically a Greek Prank
"People use drywall screws for everything," Mike says. "Drywall screws are brittle. They’re meant to hold paper and gypsum. If you drive them into an old oak stud, the head is going to snap or strip almost every time. Use structural screws or deck screws with a Torx (star) head. They almost never strip because the bit has six points of contact instead of four."
He’s right. If you have the choice, always switch to Torx or Robertson (square) drive screws. The design makes it physically difficult for the tool to slip.
The Path Forward
Dealing with a stripped screw is a test of patience more than a test of skill.
Actionable Next Steps:
- Stop immediately the moment the driver slips. Do not try "one more time" with the same tool.
- Assess the depth. If it's shallow, try the rubber band or an abrasive powder.
- Check for clearance. If the head is exposed, use locking pliers (Vise-Grips).
- Apply chemicals. If there's any hint of rust, use a dedicated penetrating oil like PB Blaster and wait 20 minutes.
- Switch to an extractor. If the head is flush or deeply gouged, use a dedicated screw extractor kit.
- Replace with better hardware. Once the screw is out, throw it away. Replace it with a Torx-head screw of the same size to ensure this never happens again.
Don't let a small piece of metal win. Most of the time, the solution isn't more muscle—it's more friction. Take a breath, grab the right tool, and you'll have that screw out in five minutes. Case closed.