You’re staring at a crusty, corroded metal ring at the bottom of your sink. It’s gross. It’s probably leaking, or maybe you’re just tired of looking at that chipped finish from 1994. Whatever the reason, you need to figure out how to get sink drain out without calling a plumber who’s going to charge you $200 just to show up. Honestly, it looks intimidating. There’s plumber's putty that has turned into literal stone and a giant nut underneath that hasn't moved since the Clinton administration. But here's the thing: it’s just a mechanical connection. You can beat it.
Most people think you just grab a pair of pliers and twist. Don't do that. You’ll end up Marring the porcelain or, worse, snapping the tailpiece and turning a twenty-minute job into a three-hour hardware store odyssey. You need to understand the anatomy of what you're fighting.
Why Sink Drains Get Stuck in the First Place
Metal hates water. It’s a design flaw of planet Earth. Over time, the constant exposure to moisture, soap scum, and drain cleaners causes a process called galvanic corrosion. This basically welds the metal components together. When you're trying to figure out how to get sink drain out, you aren't just fighting a screw; you’re fighting years of chemical bonding.
Then there’s the plumber's putty. This stuff is supposed to stay pliable, but after a decade, it dries out. It becomes like ceramic. It grips the underside of the drain flange and the sink surface like industrial adhesive. If you try to force it, you might crack a thin stainless steel sink or chip a heavy cast iron one. Neither is a good Saturday afternoon.
The Tools You Actually Need (And the Ones You Don’t)
Don't reach for the WD-40 yet. It's not a miracle worker here. You need leverage.
Specifically, you need a drain wrench (sometimes called a "dumbell wrench"). This is a simple, cheap piece of metal that fits into the crosshairs of the drain. Without it, you're trying to grip a smooth circle from the top, which is impossible. You’ll also need a large pair of tongue-and-groove pliers—everyone calls them Channel Locks—and maybe a hammer. A hammer? Yes. Sometimes things need a gentle (or not so gentle) reminder to move.
If you’re working on a kitchen sink, the basket strainer is a different beast than a bathroom pop-up drain. Bathroom drains usually involve a long horizontal rod and a pivot nut. Kitchen drains involve a massive locknut that is almost always seized. Knowing which one you have determines your strategy.
Step-by-Step: How to Get Sink Drain Out Without Breaking Anything
First, clear everything out from under the sink. You need room to breathe. Lay down a towel because even if you think the water is off, there’s always a "presents" left in the P-trap.
- Disconnect the P-Trap. This is the U-shaped pipe. Use your pliers to loosen the slip nuts. Be ready for the smell. It’s bad. That’s just life.
- Remove the Tailpiece. This is the vertical pipe connecting the drain to the trap. If it’s plastic, it should unscrew by hand. If it’s metal and it’s crumbling, just break it off. You’re replacing it anyway.
- The Big Nut. This is the boss fight. Underneath the sink, there is a large nut holding the drain assembly to the basin. If it won't budge with pliers, try this: take a flathead screwdriver, place it against one of the ridges on the nut, and tap the end of the screwdriver with a hammer. You’re using the vibration and the impact to break the seal of the corrosion.
- The Top Side. Once the bottom nut is off, the drain might still be stuck to the sink because of that hardened putty. Use your drain wrench here. Stick it into the crosshairs from the top. Use a screwdriver through the holes in the wrench for leverage and turn counter-clockwise.
What if the Crosshairs Break?
This happens. You put the wrench in, you twist, and snap. The old, cheap pot metal of the drain flange just gives way. Now you have a smooth hole and no way to grip it. This is where most people give up and call a professional.
Don't.
You can use a hacksaw blade—just the blade, wrapped in a rag for a handle—to carefully cut two notches into the drain flange from the top. Be extremely careful not to cut the sink itself. Once you’ve cut through the metal ring, you can use a hammer and screwdriver to peel the metal inward like a tuna can lid. It’s tedious. It’s annoying. But it works.
Another trick is using a "faucet and sink installer" tool (those long orange plastic tubes you see at Home Depot). They often have specialized attachments for when the standard methods fail. According to the experts at Family Handyman, heat is also your friend. A hair dryer or a heat gun (on low) can soften old putty just enough to let the parts slide. Just don't go overboard and melt your PVC pipes.
Dealing with the Leftover Mess
Once the drain is finally out, you'll see a ring of black, gray, or brown gunk on the sink. This is the old putty. Do not just put the new drain on top of this. Take a plastic putty knife—metal can scratch—and scrape every bit of it off. Use some rubbing alcohol or a mild abrasive cleaner to get the surface perfectly smooth. If the surface isn't clean, your new drain will leak, and you’ll have to do this whole miserable process over again next week.
Real-World Nuance: Metal vs. Plastic Drains
There’s a debate in the plumbing world about whether to replace your old metal drain with another metal one or go with plastic. Metal looks better. It feels higher quality. But plastic doesn't corrode. If you live in an area with hard water, a high-quality plastic pop-up assembly for a bathroom sink might actually outlast a cheap chrome-plated brass one.
Professional plumbers like those featured on This Old House often suggest using 100% silicone instead of plumber's putty for the install. Why? Because silicone doesn't dry out and crack like putty does. However, if you ever have to take it out again, silicone is a nightmare to remove. Putty is traditional; silicone is modern. Most DIYers find putty easier to work with because you can just roll it into a "snake" and go.
👉 See also: The 1972 fifty cent piece worth: Why your pocket change probably isn't a gold mine (but might be)
Actionable Next Steps for a Successful Project
If you're ready to tackle this, don't just wing it. Start by spraying the underside of the drain with a penetrating oil like PB Blaster the night before. Let it soak into those threads.
Go to the store and buy a "Dumbbell Drain Wrench." It costs less than ten dollars and is the difference between a successful job and a total meltdown. Also, buy a new P-trap kit while you're there. Chances are, once you take the old one off, you’ll realize it’s too gross to put back on.
Finally, remember that patience is your most important tool. If the nut doesn't turn, don't just pull harder. Tap it. Heat it. Soak it. The goal is to get the sink drain out, not to buy a brand-new sink because you cracked the old one in a fit of rage. Clean the mounting surface until it shines, apply a generous bead of new putty, and tighten the new assembly until it’s snug—but don't over-tighten, or you'll squeeze all the sealant out. Wipe away the excess, reconnect your pipes, and test for leaks with a full basin of water.