Let’s be real for a second. Isabelle is a stickler. You’ve spent three hundred hours terraforming a multi-level waterfall entrance, your house is a sprawling mansion filled with rare ironwood furniture, and you’ve finally kicked out that one villager who always wore the fitness tank top. Yet, you walk into Resident Services, ask about your island eval, and she hits you with a four-star rating and some vague nonsense about "too many items cluttering the ground." It’s frustrating. It feels personal. But honestly, the math behind how to get 5 stars in Animal Crossing is actually pretty cold and calculated.
Your island isn't a piece of art to the game's code; it's a spreadsheet. To hit that perfect rating and finally snag the DIY recipe for the Golden Watering Can, you have to stop thinking like a designer and start thinking like an accountant.
The secret points system Isabelle won't tell you about
Most players think a five-star rating is about "vibes" or beauty. It isn't. The game tracks two specific scores: Development and Scenery. To hit the peak, you need at least 665 Development points and 450 Scenery points. If you’re even one point short in either category, you’re stuck at four stars.
Development is basically anything man-made. Bridges, inclines, fences, and furniture you bought or crafted all fall here. Scenery is the natural stuff—trees, flowers, and shrubs. The trick is that these two scores have to grow in tandem. You can’t just carpet-bomb your island with 5,000 flowers and expect a trophy. Isabelle will just tell you the island is too "wild." Conversely, if you build a concrete jungle with zero greenery, she’ll complain about the lack of nature.
Why your "dropped" items are killing your score
This is the biggest hurdle for people trying to figure out how to get 5 stars in Animal Crossing. There is a "clutter" check. If the game detects more than 15 "dropped" items in a 64-tile block, your rating is capped.
Note the word "dropped."
✨ Don't miss: Appropriate for All Gamers NYT: The Real Story Behind the Most Famous Crossword Clue
If you place a DIY recipe on the ground to trade with a friend later, that’s a dropped item. If you have a "take one, leave one" area with fruit or tools sitting out, those are dropped items. Even naturally occurring things like branches or stones count toward this limit if you don't pick them up. However, if you "place" an item—like putting a piece of furniture down—it counts toward your points and doesn't trigger the clutter penalty. Basically, if it looks like a leaf or a small icon on the ground, it's hurting you. Pick up your trash.
Furniture placement: It’s a numbers game
To max out your Development score, you need furniture. Lots of it. But not all furniture is created equal in the eyes of the Nooklings.
Expensive items give you more points. If an item costs more than 20,000 Bells, it provides a significantly higher boost to your score than a simple wooden chair. Also, the game rewards variety. Placing 50 identical hay beds might technically raise your score, but the game has a "redundancy" penalty. If you have too many of the same item in one area, the point value starts to drop.
Spread things out. Every 8x8 tile grid on your island should have some sort of decoration. You don't need a masterpiece in every corner, but you do need "stuff." Think about adding:
- A lighthouse or a pool (high-value Nook Stop items).
- Streetlamps every few dozen paces.
- Fencing. Oh man, Isabelle loves fencing.
Fencing is the fastest way to cheese your way to five stars. Every single piece of fence counts as 0.2 points toward your Development score. If you're struggling to hit the threshold, just start walling off your villager houses or creating little garden plots. It adds up incredibly fast.
🔗 Read more: Stuck on the Connections hint June 13? Here is how to solve it without losing your mind
The Great Tree Debate
You might love your dense, mysterious forest, but the game might hate it. There is such a thing as "too many trees." If you have more than 220 trees on your island, Isabelle will tell you that the island feels "over-wooded" and residents are getting lost. This includes fruit trees, cedar, bamboo, and even those tiny saplings you just planted.
If you're getting this feedback, you have to chop some down. It’s painful, I know. But if you want that Lily of the Valley to sprout on your cliffs, you’ve got to thin the herd.
Flowers: The Scenery backbone
Flowers are the easiest way to juice your Scenery score. Each fully grown flower is worth 1 point. That sounds small, but consider that you can fit dozens of flowers into a tiny space. Hybrids don't actually give you more points than basic red, white, or yellow flowers, which is a common misconception. A basic red mum is worth the same as a rare blue rose for the purpose of the 5-star calculation.
If you’re stuck at four stars, go to Leif, buy three hundred seeds, and just plant them in a massive grid on the back of your island where nobody can see them. It's ugly, but it works. Once you hit five stars and get your Golden Watering Can recipe, you can dig them up and actually design something nice.
Bridges and Inclines
These are the heavy hitters. Each bridge and incline you build adds 15 points to your Development score. You can have up to 10 of each (after the 2.0 update). While they are expensive and take a day to build, they are the most permanent and stable way to keep your rating high. A 5-star island usually has at least 4 or 5 of these structures.
💡 You might also like: GTA Vice City Cheat Switch: How to Make the Definitive Edition Actually Fun
What happens when you finally hit it?
Once you hit the 5-star threshold, talk to Isabelle. She’ll act like it’s the greatest day of her life and hand over the DIY for the Golden Watering Can. This is the only way to get Gold Roses, so it’s a big deal for gardeners.
But the real prize is the Lily of the Valley.
This special white flower will randomly spawn on your cliff edges as long as you maintain a 5-star rating. It can’t be picked, it can’t be bred, and it doesn't wilt. It is the ultimate status symbol in New Horizons. If your rating drops to 4 stars (maybe you left too many turnips on the ground), the flowers won't disappear, but new ones won't grow.
Actionable steps to 5 stars tonight
If you're tired of waiting, here is the "brute force" method to get it done:
- Clean the slate: Pick up every single dropped item. Every DIY, every piece of fruit, every weed. Put them in your home storage or sell them.
- Fence it in: Craft about 200 pieces of any fence and place them around your island.
- The Nook Stop splurge: Go to the ATM and buy the big ticket items. The Monster Statue, the Robot Hero (if you have the parts), the Lighthouse, and the Teacup Ride. Place them. They are point magnets.
- Flower bomb: Plant at least 200-300 flowers. Just find an empty patch of grass and fill it.
- Talk to Isabelle: Check your rating. If she mentions "decorating from head to toe," you need more furniture. If she mentions "nature," you need more flowers or fewer trees.
Getting a 5-star island is less about being a professional landscaper and more about meeting a set of hidden quotas. Once you understand that Isabelle is just checking boxes, the process becomes way less stressful. Build the bridges, plant the mums, pick up the trash, and that gold watering can is yours.
To move forward, start by doing a "sweep" of your beaches. We often forget DIYs or shells we’ve dropped there, and those tiny items are usually the reason people stay stuck at 4 stars. Once your beaches are clear, check your cliffside for your first Lily of the Valley tomorrow morning.