You just bought a sleek new external hard drive. You plug it into your MacBook, ready to offload those massive 4K video files, and then—nothing. Or rather, you can see the files, but you can’t move, delete, or edit a single thing. It’s the classic "Read Only" trap. This happens because Windows uses a file system called NTFS, and Apple, well, Apple doesn't really like playing nice with Microsoft’s proprietary tech. Honestly, it's one of the most annoying hurdles for people jumping between PC and Mac.
If you’re trying to format NTFS on Mac, you’ve probably realized by now that Disk Utility is acting a bit weird. It’ll let you erase the drive and turn it into something else, but it won’t let you "create" an NTFS partition out of thin air. macOS can read NTFS just fine, but writing to it? That’s where the software wall hits you.
🔗 Read more: EA-18G Growler: Why Modern Air Wars Start (and End) With This Jet
Why macOS and NTFS are Frenemies
Microsoft introduced NTFS (New Technology File System) back in the early 90s. It’s robust. It handles huge files. It has permissions that keep IT managers happy. Apple, on the other hand, pivoted from HFS+ to APFS (Apple File System) a few years ago. Because NTFS is a closed, proprietary format owned by Microsoft, Apple would have to pay licensing fees to bake full "write" support into every Mac sold. They haven't done that.
Instead, macOS includes a very hidden, very experimental NTFS write driver. It’s buggy. It’s unstable. It’s so hidden that you have to use Terminal commands just to wake it up, and frankly, I wouldn't trust it with my tax returns, let alone a lifetime of photos.
The Problem With "Just Formatting"
When people say they want to format NTFS on Mac, they usually mean one of two things. Either they want to wipe the drive and make it compatible with Mac, or they desperately need to keep it as NTFS so they can use it on their office PC later.
If you just want the drive to work on your Mac and don't care about Windows, you should stop looking for NTFS solutions and just format it to APFS or ExFAT. ExFAT is the "peace treaty" of file systems. It works on both Windows and Mac without any extra software. But it’s not perfect—it’s prone to data corruption if you yank the cable out without ejecting properly.
Your Realistic Options for Managing NTFS
You have three real paths here. None of them are "perfect," but one will definitely fit your workflow.
1. The Professional Driver Route (Paid)
If you’re a pro—say a video editor or a photographer—don't mess around with free workarounds. Tools like Paragon NTFS for Mac or Tuxera NTFS are the gold standard. They basically sit in the background and trick your Mac into thinking NTFS is a native language.
I’ve used Paragon for years. It’s fast. You forget it’s even there. It handles the mount/unmount process gracefully, and you won’t get those terrifying "Disk Not Ejected Properly" errors that lead to heart attacks. It usually costs around $20, which is a small price to pay to avoid losing a terabyte of data.
2. The Open Source Headache (Free)
Then there’s macFUSE and NTFS-3G. This is for the tinkerers. It’s free, but it’s a massive pain to install on modern versions of macOS (like Sonoma or Sequoia). Since Apple introduced "System Integrity Protection" (SIP) and shifted to Apple Silicon (M1, M2, M3 chips), installing unsigned third-party drivers requires booting into Recovery Mode and lowering your Mac's security settings.
Unless you're comfortable with a command line and potentially bricking your OS install, stay away. Seriously. It’s slow, too. Writing a 10GB file via NTFS-3G feels like watching paint dry in a rainstorm.
3. The Format-and-Forget (The ExFAT Alternative)
If you just want to format NTFS on Mac to make the drive usable for both worlds, use Disk Utility to change it to ExFAT.
- Open Disk Utility.
- Select the drive (make sure you've backed up the data, because this wipes everything).
- Click Erase.
- Choose ExFAT under the Format dropdown.
- Choose GUID Partition Map for the Scheme.
The Terminal Trick: Why You Should Probably Avoid It
There is a way to force macOS to write to NTFS using the Terminal. You edit the /etc/fstab file. You tell the system to mount a specific UUID with "rw" (read-write) permissions.
Don't do it.
Apple keeps this feature disabled for a reason. It is notorious for corrupting the file index. I’ve seen people use this "hack" only to find that half their folders turned into 0KB files after a week. If the data on your drive matters at all, the Terminal method is a gamble you’ll eventually lose.
Formatting a Drive Specifically to NTFS on Mac
Wait, what if you actually need to format a brand-new drive to NTFS while using your Mac? Disk Utility won't give you "NTFS" as an option in the dropdown menu. It's just not there.
To actually format NTFS on Mac, you must have one of those third-party drivers installed (like Paragon or Tuxera). Once the driver is installed, "Microsoft NTFS" magically appears as an option in Disk Utility.
Without those drivers, you’re stuck. You’d have to find a friend with a Windows PC, plug the drive in there, and format it. Or, use a Virtual Machine (like Parallels or VMware Fusion) to pass the USB drive through to a virtual Windows environment. It’s a lot of hoops to jump through for a file system.
Hardware Matters: M1/M2/M3 vs Intel
If you are on an Intel Mac, the old tricks still mostly work. But if you're on Apple Silicon, the security architecture is much tighter. Kernel extensions (KEXTs) are being phased out in favor of "System Extensions." Most free NTFS tools still rely on the old KEXT method, which is why they are so unstable on newer MacBooks.
Actionable Next Steps
If you’re staring at a drive right now and can’t write to it, here is exactly what you should do:
- Check your data: If there’s nothing on the drive, don't bother with NTFS. Open Disk Utility, hit Erase, and pick ExFAT. You're done in 30 seconds and it’ll work on your PC too.
- Evaluate your frequency: If you have to work with NTFS drives from clients every single day, go buy Paragon NTFS for Mac. It is the only way to ensure your Mac won't corrupt their files.
- The "Cloud" Workaround: If you only need to move a few files, honestly, just use a cloud service like Google Drive or Dropbox. Upload it from the PC, download it on the Mac. Skip the hardware headache entirely.
- Avoid the "Free" Apps: Be careful with random "NTFS Mounter" apps on the Mac App Store. Many are just wrappers for the unstable Apple experimental driver and can be just as dangerous as the Terminal hack.
Managing file systems feels like 1995 tech support, but until Microsoft and Apple decide to share their toys, these workarounds are all we've got. Keep your backups current, eject your drives properly, and maybe keep a cheap Windows laptop in the closet just for these moments. It saves a lot of swearing at your monitor.