How to exercise your traps: Why your shrugs aren't working and what to do instead

How to exercise your traps: Why your shrugs aren't working and what to do instead

Most people think their traps are just those little hills of muscle sitting between their neck and shoulders. They walk into the gym, grab the heaviest dumbbells they can find, and start spamming short, jerky shrugs. It looks painful. Honestly, it usually is. But here's the thing: your trapezius is actually a massive, diamond-shaped muscle that spans almost the entire middle of your back. If you only shrug, you’re ignoring about two-thirds of the muscle.

Building big traps isn't just about looking like a linebacker. It’s about shoulder stability. It’s about posture. If you spend all day hunched over a laptop, your lower traps are probably screaming for help while your upper traps are tight enough to snap a guitar string. Learning how to exercise your traps properly means understanding that this muscle moves in three different directions.

We need to talk about anatomy for a second, but I'll keep it quick. You’ve got the upper fibers (the ones that shrug), the middle fibers (the ones that pull your shoulder blades together), and the lower fibers (the ones that pull your shoulder blades down). If you want that thick, "3D" look, you have to hit all of them. Most gym-goers are chronically overdeveloped in the upper traps and dangerously weak in the lower portions. This imbalance is a one-way ticket to impingement town.

The problem with the standard dumbbell shrug

Stop me if you've seen this: a guy holding 100-pound dumbbells, chin tucked to his chest, rolling his shoulders in circles.

First off, don't roll your shoulders. Your traps aren't designed to move in a circle; they elevate and depress. Rolling just creates unnecessary friction in the glenohumeral joint. It's a waste of energy. Also, the range of motion on a standard shrug is tiny. If you want to know how to exercise your traps for actual growth, you need to think about the "line of pull."

The upper trapezius fibers don't just run straight up and down. They actually run at an angle. This is why many trainers, like Dr. Mike Israetel from Renaissance Periodization, suggest leaning forward slightly during shrugs. By tilting your torso about 10 to 15 degrees forward, you align the muscle fibers better with the resistance. It feels different. It feels harder.

Try using a cable machine instead of dumbbells sometimes. Cables provide constant tension. When you use dumbbells, the tension is highest at the top, but it sort of disappears if you don't control the descent. With a cable, you can pull slightly outward and upward, which matches the natural orientation of the upper traps much better than just fighting gravity straight down.

Why heavy carries are the "cheat code"

You don't always have to "move" the weight to grow. The traps are incredibly responsive to isometric tension. Think about the last time you carried all the grocery bags in one trip. Your traps were on fire, right?

The Farmer’s Walk is arguably the best trap builder nobody does enough of. When you carry heavy objects, your traps have to work overtime just to keep your arms from being pulled out of their sockets. This is called "eccentric loading under stretch," and it is a massive stimulus for hypertrophy.

📖 Related: Burger King Impossible Whopper Nutrition: What Most People Get Wrong

  • The Cue: Don't just let the weights hang. Imagine you're trying to grow "tall" through your crown.
  • The Weight: Use something that makes your grip fail around the 45-second mark.
  • The Secret: Try the "Kirk Shrug." Named after legendary powerlifter Kirk Karwoski, this is a shrug performed with a barbell held at the hips using a thumbless grip, pulling the bar up to the navel using only the traps. It’s brutal.

How to exercise your traps for mid-back thickness

If the upper traps are for show, the middle and lower traps are for go. This is the area between your shoulder blades. When people ask about how to exercise your traps, they usually forget that horizontal pulling—rows, basically—is a trap exercise.

But you have to row correctly. If you just pull with your biceps, your back stays flat. To hit the mid-traps, you need "scapular retraction." This means your shoulder blades should actually touch (or try to) at the peak of the movement.

The Face Pull is the king here. Use a rope attachment on a cable machine. Pull the center of the rope toward your forehead while pulling the ends apart. Most people mess this up by using too much weight and leaning back. Don't do that. Keep your chest up and focus on the "squeeze" in the center of your back. Research by Jeff Cavaliere often emphasizes the importance of external rotation during this move. As you pull back, your thumbs should end up pointing behind you. This hits the mid-traps and the rear delts simultaneously.

The neglected lower traps

Lower trap weakness is a plague. It causes your shoulders to dump forward and your neck to strain. To fix this, you need overhead movements.

🔗 Read more: Why Chickpea Pasta Protein Actually Lives Up to the Hype

The "Y-Raise" is the gold standard. You can do these on an incline bench. Lay face down, arms hanging, and lift them up into a "Y" shape. Do not use heavy weights. Seriously. Five-pound dumbbells will feel like fifty if you're doing them right. You are training the muscle to pull the scapula down and back, which is essential for shoulder health when you're doing heavy overhead presses or snatches.

Putting it all together: A better trap routine

You don't need a "trap day." That’s overkill. Instead, sprinkle these movements into your back or shoulder days. The traps are resilient; they can handle a lot of volume because they are postural muscles used to working all day long.

A smart approach involves one "heavy" movement and one "finesse" movement per session.

Monday could be your heavy day. After your deadlifts or rows, throw in three sets of heavy Barbell Shrugs with a two-second pause at the top. This pause is non-negotiable. If you can't hold it at the top, the weight is too heavy and you're just using momentum.

Thursday could be the "functional" day. Use Face Pulls and Y-Raises. Focus on the mind-muscle connection. You want to feel the tissue stretching and contracting. It’s not about moving the pin on the cable stack; it’s about making the muscle work.

Avoid the "Alpha" trap mistakes

There is a weird tendency in gyms to treat trap training like a competition of who can look the most like a confused turtle.

👉 See also: Where to Buy Saline Solution for Piercings Without Ruining Your New Jewelry

  1. Stop the ego-shrugging: If your head is jutting forward like a tortoise to meet the traps halfway, you are asking for a cervical spine injury. Keep your neck neutral.
  2. Stop using straps for everything: Your grip strength and trap strength should grow together. Only use straps on your absolute heaviest sets of Farmer's Walks.
  3. Don't ignore the stretch: The bottom of a shrug is just as important as the top. Let the weight pull your shoulders down comfortably to get a full stretch before the next rep.

Moving forward with your training

To see real change, you need to track your progress. Don't just "do some shrugs" at the end of your workout. Treat them like any other primary lift. If you did 225 lbs for 10 reps last week, aim for 11 reps or 230 lbs this week.

Start your next session with a "scapular warm-up." Hang from a pull-up bar and just practice shrugging your body up without bending your elbows. These are called scapular pull-ups. They prime the traps to actually fire during your heavier sets.

The real secret to how to exercise your traps isn't a magical machine or a secret supplement. It’s variety. Combine the heavy isometric holds of the Farmer's Walk with the targeted isolation of the Kelso Shrug (shrugging while bent over a bench). Change your angles. Change your grips. Most importantly, stop thinking of your traps as just those bumps next to your ears and start treating them like the massive back-spanning powerhouse they actually are.

Focus on the squeeze. Control the negative. Stop rolling your shoulders. Your neck—and your t-shirts—will thank you.