Smelt are weird. They are tiny, shimmering silver needles that show up in massive runs during the spring, usually in the Great Lakes or along the Atlantic and Pacific coasts. If you've ever been to a "smelt fry" in a VFW hall in Wisconsin or a small town in Ontario, you know the vibe. It’s loud, greasy, and incredibly nostalgic. But honestly, most people are terrified of cooking them at home because they worry about two things: the "fishy" smell and the fact that you’re basically eating the whole animal, bones and all.
You shouldn't be scared. Smelt are actually one of the cleanest-tasting fish you can find if you handle them right. They have this strange, almost cucumber-like scent when they’re fresh. Seriously. Take a whiff of a fresh rainbow smelt and it smells like a garden, not a dock.
When you're figuring out how to cook smelt fish, you have to decide if you’re a "heads-on" or "heads-off" person. Purists will tell you that the head adds flavor and crunch. My grandma used to say that's where the vitamins are. Most modern eaters, however, prefer to snip the heads off with kitchen shears and squeeze out the innards. It takes five seconds. You don't even need a knife. Just snip, squeeze, and rinse.
The Secret to the Perfect Crispy Fry
Most people fail at frying smelt because they treat them like a heavy piece of cod or haddock. That’s a mistake. These are delicate. If you use a thick beer batter, you’re just eating a fried dough stick with a tiny bit of protein in the middle. You want a light coating.
Basically, you want a mix of all-purpose flour and yellow cornmeal. The cornmeal provides that gritty, satisfying crunch that holds up against the oil. I usually go with a 2-to-1 ratio of flour to cornmeal. Season it heavily. I’m talking salt, cracked black pepper, and maybe a dash of cayenne or Old Bay. Smelt can handle salt. They need it.
Get your oil hot. I mean really hot—about 375 degrees Fahrenheit. Because the fish are so small, they cook in about two to three minutes. If your oil is too cool, the fish will just soak up the grease and turn into a soggy, limp mess. Nobody wants a limp smelt.
Drop them in small batches. If you crowd the pan, the temperature drops, and you’re back to Soggy Town. When they turn golden brown and the tails look like potato chips, they're done. Drain them on a wire rack, not a paper towel. Paper towels trap steam, and steam is the enemy of crispy skin.
👉 See also: Sleeping With Your Neighbor: Why It Is More Complicated Than You Think
Why Freshness is Everything
According to the Great Lakes Fishery Commission, rainbow smelt are an invasive species in some areas, but they are also a staple of the local ecology. Because they are oily fish, they degrade fast. If you buy smelt that smells like "fish," they’re already too old.
Look for clear eyes. Look for firm flesh. If you're catching them yourself during a midnight dip-netting session, keep them on ice immediately. The difference between a smelt that was iced immediately and one that sat in a bucket for two hours is night and day. One tastes like a crisp spring morning; the other tastes like a wet basement.
Beyond the Deep Fryer: Roasting and Air Frying
Believe it or not, you don't have to submerge these guys in a vat of bubbling oil. If you’re trying to be somewhat healthy, or if you just hate the cleanup of deep frying, the air fryer is actually a godsend for smelt.
Toss the cleaned fish in a tiny bit of olive oil, lemon zest, and breadcrumbs. Set the air fryer to 400 degrees. Shake the basket halfway through. In about six or seven minutes, they come out remarkably crunchy. It’s not quite the same as a deep fry, but it’s 90% of the way there with 10% of the mess.
You can also roast them. Mediterranean styles often involve laying them out on a sheet pan with sliced lemons, garlic, and a lot of parsley. High heat is still the rule. You want the skin to blister.
Dealing with the Bones
This is the part that trips everyone up. "Do I eat the bones?" Yes. You do.
✨ Don't miss: At Home French Manicure: Why Yours Looks Cheap and How to Fix It
When smelt are cooked at high heat, the bones soften and become almost undetectable, adding a nice little boost of calcium to your diet. If the fish is larger than about six or seven inches, you might notice the spine, but for the standard four-inch "fries," you won't even feel them. It’s like eating a sardine, but much milder.
If the idea of bones absolutely revolts you, you can butterfly them. Run a thumb along the spine after the head is removed and pull the bone out in one piece. It’s tedious. It’s messy. Honestly, it’s probably not worth the effort for a fish this small. Just eat the bone. Trust me.
The Cultural Significance of the Smelt Run
In places like Escanaba, Michigan, or Duluth, Minnesota, the smelt run is a legitimate event. It’s a community bonding experience. People stand in freezing cold water at 2:00 AM with nets, pulling in buckets of these silver fish.
It’s one of the few remaining "wild" food traditions that hasn't been completely commercialized. You can't really find "fancy" smelt in a five-star restaurant. It’s a humble food. It’s a blue-collar delicacy.
James Beard, the legendary chef, actually loved small oily fish. He often championed the idea that we should eat lower on the food chain. Smelt are sustainable, they’re fast-growing, and they’re packed with Omega-3 fatty acids. They are basically a superfood that happens to taste great with a cold lager and a side of tartar sauce.
Common Mistakes to Avoid
One: Overcooking. These are not steaks. If you leave them in the heat for five minutes, they will turn into dry, chalky sticks. Watch them like a hawk.
🔗 Read more: Popeyes Louisiana Kitchen Menu: Why You’re Probably Ordering Wrong
Two: Not drying the fish. Before you toss them in flour, pat them dry with paper towels. If they are wet, the flour turns into a paste. Paste doesn't get crispy. Paste gets gummy.
Three: Skimping on the acid. You need lemon. Or malt vinegar. Or a very sharp tartar sauce with extra pickles. The fat from the frying needs something to cut through it.
The Dipping Sauce Debate
In the Midwest, it's almost always tartar sauce. Usually the cheap kind from a plastic squeeze bottle. But if you want to elevate how you cook smelt fish, try a spicy remoulade or even a Japanese-style ponzu dip.
A simple garlic aioli—basically just mayo, smashed garlic, and lemon juice—works wonders. The creaminess of the mayo against the crunch of the cornmeal is a top-tier food pairing.
Actionable Steps for Your First Smelt Fry
If you’re ready to try this, don't overcomplicate it. Follow these steps for the best results:
- Source the fish: Check your local fishmonger in March or April. If you're buying frozen, make sure they are "flash frozen" to preserve the texture.
- Prep work: Use kitchen shears to snip the heads off and run your finger down the belly to clear the entrails. Rinse in cold water and dry them thoroughly.
- The Coating: Mix 1 cup of flour, 1/2 cup of cornmeal, 1 tablespoon of salt, and a teaspoon of black pepper in a gallon-sized Ziploc bag.
- The Fry: Heat two inches of vegetable oil in a heavy cast-iron skillet until it reaches 375°F.
- Small Batches: Fry about 10 fish at a time for 2-3 minutes until golden.
- Drain and Season: Move them immediately to a wire cooling rack and hit them with one more tiny pinch of salt while the oil is still wet on the surface.
- Serve: Serve with lemon wedges and a cold drink. Eat them while they’re hot. Smelt do not microwave well the next day. They are a "right now" food.
Eating smelt is an experience. It's tactile, it's messy, and it’s deeply satisfying. Once you get past the initial "whole fish" hurdle, you'll realize why people wait all year for the ice to melt and the runs to start. It’s a taste of the season that you just can’t get from a filet of farm-raised salmon.