You're stuck. I know because everyone gets stuck there. Renoir—or more accurately, the Eldest of the Black Rabbit Brotherhood—is the literal gatekeeper of Malum District. He’s the big guy with the giant cleaver and the "Renoir" tag on his grave-marker shield. If you came here looking for a cheese, I’ve got bad news. He doesn't cheese easily. You actually have to fight him. Honestly, the biggest mistake people make is treating this like a 1v4 gank fight. It isn't. It’s a 1v1 duel with three annoying interruptions.
If you try to spread your damage across the whole family, you're dead. Seriously. The battle revolves entirely around the big man’s posture and your ability to count to three.
The Core Strategy to Beat Renoir Without Losing Your Mind
Most players walk through that fog gate and immediately panic when the younger siblings jump into the arena. Don't. The AI in Lies of P is actually programmed with a bit of "honor" here. When a sibling is out, the Eldest—Renoir—becomes significantly less aggressive. He’ll hang back, paced out, and occasionally try to overhead slam you while you’re busy with his sister or the spear-wielder.
The secret? Break his weapon. If you use the Perfect Guard mechanic consistently on his overhead swings, his giant cleaver will eventually shatter. Once that sword breaks, his reach drops by nearly 40% and his damage becomes laughable. It turns a nightmare fight into a cakewalk. I recommend using the Aegis Legion Arm if your timing is shaky. It lets you "pulse" the block button while holding it up to fish for Perfect Guards. It feels kinda cheap, but it works.
🔗 Read more: Free games free online: Why we're still obsessed with browser gaming in 2026
Dealing with the Siblings
The siblings join the fray at specific HP thresholds. The first (Youngest) jumps in at about 80% health. The second (Eccentric) at 60%, and the third (Battle Maniac) at 40%.
- The Youngest (Dual Blades): She is fast. She’s annoying. But she has zero poise. Use a heavy blade or a high-stagger handle like the Booster Glaive Handle to just keep her flat on her back.
- The Eccentric (Spear): He loves to poke from off-screen. This is where most people die. Keep him between you and the Eldest. If you can’t see the big guy, you’re about to get hit by a charge.
- The Battle Maniac: He uses a rapier and pulls you in with a wire. Just dodge-roll sideways when he starts spinning his arm.
Backstabs are your best friend here. The siblings are all human-sized enemies, which means they are incredibly vulnerable to the "circle-strafe and stab" method. While you're backstabbing the little ones, you are invincible for a few frames, which helps avoid the Eldest’s massive swings.
Why Your Build Might Be Failing You
Let's talk gear. If you are running a glass-cannon Motivity build, you’re probably getting stunned too often. You need physical damage reduction. The Iron Wall Amulet is almost mandatory for this fight if you aren't a parry god.
💡 You might also like: Catching the Blue Marlin in Animal Crossing: Why This Giant Fish Is So Hard to Find
I’ve seen a lot of players try to use fire against him because, well, everything in Malum District is weak to fire, right? Sorta. He’s a carcass-adjacent human, so Acid is actually your best bet. The Pandemonium Legion Arm or the Acidic Crystal Spear will melt his health bar while you focus on parrying.
Also, check your weight. If you’re at "Slightly Heavy" (over 60%), your stamina regeneration is taking a massive hit. In this fight, stamina is life. If you can't dodge the Eldest's 5-hit combo because you're waiting for a bar to fill up, you've already lost. Drop some armor. Wear the Blue Guardianship Amulet to bump your stats if you have to.
The "Wall" Tactic
There is a literal pile of debris in the arena. Use it. It’s not just flavor text for the environment. By kiting the Eldest around the central junk pile, you can force him to clip his attacks into the terrain. This gives you a massive window to heal or sharpen your blade. Just be careful—his overhead slam can sometimes clip through the geometry if you’re standing too close to the edge.
📖 Related: Ben 10 Ultimate Cosmic Destruction: Why This Game Still Hits Different
Common Misconceptions About the Black Rabbit Brotherhood
People think you should kill the siblings immediately. Actually, that's not always true. If you leave a sibling alive with just a sliver of health, the next one won't spawn yet. Use that time to whittle down the Eldest's health. You want to spend as little time as possible fighting two people at once.
Another mistake? Summoning the Specter and thinking he'll carry you. The Specter is a literal sponge in this fight. He will die within the first two minutes because he doesn't know how to block the Eldest’s "whirlwind" attack. If you use a Specter, you need to use the Friendship Wishstone to keep him alive until at least the third sibling arrives. Otherwise, you’re stuck fighting a buffed Boss (because summons increase boss HP) all by yourself in the second half.
Practical Next Steps for Success
To beat Renoir and the Brotherhood today, follow this exact sequence:
- Preparation: Equip the Acidic Crystal Spear or apply Acid Abrasives to your heaviest weapon. Ensure your weight is under 60%.
- Phase 1: Focus entirely on Perfect Guarding the Eldest. Do not even try to attack until his weapon glows with a purple hue or breaks.
- Phase 2 (The Siblings): When a sibling enters, kite them away from the Eldest. Use the debris in the room to keep the big guy at a distance. Backstab the siblings—do not trade hits.
- The Finisher: Once the third sibling is down, the Eldest will start using his "Charge" move more frequently. Dodge into the swing, not away. This puts you behind him for two free hits.
- Consumables: Keep a few Shot Puts in your quick-slot. When his health bar has a white glow (meaning he's staggered), throw a Shot Put. It will instantly trigger the stagger, allowing you to get a Fatal Attack without risking a heavy charged hit.
Go back to Hotel Krat, respect your P-Organ to prioritize "Link Dodge" and "Increase Staggerable Window," and head back in. You’ve got this.