You’ve spent years, maybe decades, working for a state or local government or perhaps a non-profit. You’ve dutifully funneled money into your 457(b) plan. Now, you’re looking at that balance and wondering how much the IRS is going to snatch away when you finally touch it. Honestly, it’s a lot. If you just pull the trigger and take a lump sum, you could lose 20%, 30%, or even more of your hard-earned savings to federal and state taxes.
But here’s the thing. The 457(b) is a weird, beautiful beast. It doesn’t play by the same rules as a 401(k) or a 403(b). If you know the moves, you can navigate how to avoid tax on 457 withdrawal or at least minimize the damage so significantly that it feels like a win.
Most people panic because they think they’ll get hit with the 10% early withdrawal penalty. Good news: if it's a governmental 457(b), that penalty basically doesn't exist for you once you leave your job. You can be 42 years old, quit, and take the money. You'll owe income tax, sure, but no penalty. But "no penalty" isn't the same as "no tax."
The Stealthy Strategy: The Direct Rollover
The most effective way to avoid an immediate tax bill is to never let the money touch your personal bank account. This is the "Direct Rollover" maneuver. If you move your 457(b) funds directly into a Traditional IRA or a new employer’s 401(k), the IRS views this as a non-taxable event.
It stays in the tax-deferred bubble.
You’re not actually "avoiding" the tax forever—let's be real, Uncle Sam always gets his cut eventually—but you are avoiding it now. This allows the full balance to keep compounding. If you take a $100,000 withdrawal, you might only see $70,000 after taxes. If you roll it over, the full $100,000 keeps working for you.
Be careful, though. Once you roll a governmental 457 into an IRA, it takes on the IRA’s rules. That means if you’re under 59½ and suddenly need that money, you just slapped yourself with a 10% penalty that you wouldn't have had if you kept it in the 457. It’s a trade-off. Think about your timeline before you jump.
The Roth Conversion Play
Maybe you want to get the taxes over with. If you think tax rates are going up in the future—and let’s face it, they probably are—you might consider a Roth conversion. You’ll pay the tax now, but every penny of growth after that is tax-free.
🔗 Read more: EUR to JOD Rate: Why the Euro Is Making Moves in Jordan Right Now
This is a "pay now to save later" strategy. It’s particularly effective in a year where you might have lower income than usual. If you retired in June, your income for that year is half of what it normally is. That’s the window. Convert a portion of your 457 to a Roth IRA then. You’re paying tax at a lower marginal rate than you would have while working full-time.
Avoiding the "Tax Bump" with Periodic Payments
Don't take the lump sum. Just don't.
When you take a massive chunk of money out at once, it doesn't just get taxed; it pushes you into a higher tax bracket. You might usually be in the 12% or 22% bracket, but a $200,000 457 withdrawal could catapult you into the 32% or 35% range.
Use periodic payments instead. Most 457 plans allow you to set up a schedule. By taking out only what you need to cover your lifestyle, you keep your taxable income low.
Imagine this: You need $40,000 a year to supplement your pension. By taking only that $40k, you stay in a lower bracket. If you took $200k today and put it in a savings account, you'd pay a premium for the "privilege" of having that cash sit there. It's a math mistake.
The 457(b) for Non-Profits: A Different Animal
We need to talk about the "Top Hat" plans. If you work for a non-profit (a 501(c)), your 457(b) is different from a government one. This is where it gets hairy.
📖 Related: Larry Lindsey Withdraws Fed Chair Nomination: Why the Favorite Just Walked Away
In a non-governmental 457(b), you usually cannot roll the money into an IRA. Yeah, it sucks. Often, you are forced to take the distribution within a certain timeframe after leaving the organization.
If you’re in this boat, how to avoid tax on 457 withdrawal becomes a game of timing. You have to check your specific plan document. Some plans allow you to stretch payments over 5 or 10 years. This is your only real defense against a massive tax hit. If your plan says "lump sum only," you might want to negotiate your exit date to fall at the very beginning of a tax year so you have the rest of the year to manage your other income sources and offset the blow.
Real-World Nuance: The QDRO and Unforeseeable Emergencies
Life isn't a spreadsheet. Sometimes you need the money because things went sideways.
Unforeseeable Emergency Withdrawals: The IRS has a very narrow definition for this. It's not for a new car or a wedding. It's for an illness, a sudden property loss, or imminent eviction. If you qualify, you can take the money while still employed. You’ll still owe the income tax, but it solves the liquidity problem without needing to quit your job.
QDROs: If you’re going through a divorce, a 457(b) can be split via a Qualified Domestic Relations Order. If the money is transferred to an ex-spouse, they become responsible for the taxes when they take it out. It’s not a way to "avoid" tax for the household, but it is a way to shift the liability.
Strategic Charitable Giving
If you are over 70½, you might have heard of Qualified Charitable Distributions (QCDs). While these are generally for IRAs, you can roll your governmental 457 into an IRA and then perform a QCD.
By sending the money directly to a 501(c)(3) charity, the distribution doesn't count as taxable income. You don't get a deduction, but you also don't have to report the income. It’s a wash that keeps your Adjusted Gross Income (AGI) lower, which can help keep your Medicare premiums (IRMAA) from skyrocketing.
The "Bridge" Strategy
This is my favorite move for early retirees.
Say you retire at 55. You have a 401(k) and a 457(b). Most people would touch the 401(k) first, but wait—the 401(k) has a 10% penalty before 59½ (unless you qualify for the Rule of 55, but that's a whole other thing).
The 457(b) is your bridge.
You use the 457(b) to live on from age 55 to 59½. You pay the income tax, but you avoid the penalty. Meanwhile, you let your other accounts—the ones that would penalize you—grow untouched. You are effectively avoiding "unnecessary" taxes (the penalties) by using the right bucket at the right time.
Why You Should Check Your State Laws
Everything I’ve said so far covers federal taxes. But your state might be a different story.
States like Pennsylvania or Mississippi have unique rules about taxing retirement income. Some states don't tax government pensions or 457 distributions at all. Others treat it like any other paycheck. If you’re planning a move to a tax-friendly state like Florida or Nevada, it might be worth waiting to take your 457 withdrawals until after you’ve established residency there. You’d save the 5% to 9% state tax hit entirely.
What to Do Right Now
Don't wait until two weeks before you retire to figure this out.
First, get your "Summary Plan Description." This is the legal document that governs your 457. It will tell you if you're in a governmental plan (good) or a non-profit plan (trickier).
✨ Don't miss: Bill Chisholm Net Worth 2025: Why This Low-Profile Billionaire Is Buying the Celtics
Second, look at your projected income for the year you plan to stop working. If you retire in December, that’s a high-income year. If you retire in January, that’s a low-income year. That one-month difference could save you thousands in taxes on your first withdrawal.
Third, talk to a tax pro who actually knows what a 457(b) is. Many generalists confuse them with 401(k)s. If they tell you that you’ll owe a 10% penalty for taking money at age 50, they don't know 457s. Find someone who does.
Actionable Steps Summary:
- Confirm your plan type (Governmental vs. Non-Governmental).
- Map out your "Bridge" years to see if the 457 can cover you until age 59½.
- Calculate the tax bracket impact of a lump sum versus a 10-year payout.
- Investigate your state's specific stance on 457(b) distributions.
- Set up a direct rollover if you don't need the cash immediately to keep the tax-deferred growth alive.