It starts with a feeling of being untouchable. You've seen it. A company dominates the market for a decade, their name becomes a verb, and then, suddenly, they’re filing for Chapter 11 or getting swallowed up for pennies on the dollar. Jim Collins, the guy who wrote Good to Great, spent years obsessing over this. He didn’t just want to know why some companies win; he wanted to know why the winners eventually lose.
The result was his book How the Mighty Fall.
Honestly, it’s a bit of a dark read. Collins himself joked that he was "turning to the dark side" by studying failure instead of success. But it’s probably one of the most practical business books ever written because it proves that decline is mostly self-inflicted. It’s not just "bad luck" or a "bad economy." It’s a sequence of predictable stages.
Stage 1: Hubris Born of Success
This is the sneakiest part. You’d think a company falls because they get lazy or complacent. Nope. Collins found that the mighty often fall because they become arrogant. They start thinking their success is a right, not something they have to earn every single day.
When a company reaches Stage 1, they stop asking why they are successful. They just assume they are great because they are "them." They lose that "childlike curiosity" and start ignoring the specific conditions that made their initial flywheel spin. It's the "we're so good we can do anything" trap.
Stage 2: The Undisciplined Pursuit of More
Hubris leads directly into Stage 2. Since you think you’re invincible, you start overreaching. This is where companies go on crazy acquisition sprees or jump into industries where they have no business being.
Think about Ames Department Stores. They were doing great in small towns, but then they decided to buy Zayre—a massive chain they couldn't handle. They grew faster than they could find "the right people" to manage that growth.
- Growth for growth’s sake: If you can’t fill key seats with the right people, stop growing.
- The "What" replaces the "Why": Leaders focus on what they’re doing (buying companies, launching products) rather than why it matters.
- Declining cost discipline: When cash is easy, people get sloppy.
The "Right People" Problem
One of the biggest red flags Collins mentions is a declining proportion of key seats filled with the right people. If you have a leadership vacuum or you're hiring just to fill a box on an org chart, you’re basically inviting Stage 2 to ruin your life.
Stage 3: Denial of Risk and Peril
By now, things are actually starting to go wrong. The data is looking a bit "meh." But because the company still looks strong on the outside, the leaders just explain it away. They blame the "cyclical economy" or a "temporary setback."
📖 Related: Finding the Right Schedule 1 Organization Name Ideas Without Getting In Trouble
In Stage 3, the culture shifts. Instead of having healthy, confrontational debates based on facts, people start "polishing the turd." They amplify the good news and bury the bad. If you're in a meeting and nobody is allowed to say "this is failing," you are deep in the denial stage.
Stage 4: Grasping for Salvation
This is where the fall becomes public. Everyone can see the ship is sinking. So, what does leadership do? They look for a "silver bullet."
Usually, this looks like hiring a "charismatic savior" CEO from the outside. Or it’s a "game-changing" acquisition. Or a "radical cultural transformation."
🔗 Read more: Conversion of SEK to USD: What Most Travelers and Investors Get Wrong
The problem is these moves are often frantic. They have no "flywheel" effect. They might provide a temporary bump in the stock price, but they don't fix the underlying rot. Collins points out that companies in Stage 4 tend to lurch from one "miracle" program to the next, never sticking with one long enough to see results.
Stage 5: Capitulation to Irrelevance or Death
Eventually, you just run out of money or spirit. The company is sold off, goes bankrupt, or becomes a ghost of its former self. Think Zenith or Motorola. These were the kings of their worlds once. Now? Not so much.
Is Decline Inevitable?
Actually, no. That’s the "well-founded hope" Collins talks about. You can be in Stage 4 and still claw your way back. But you don't do it with a silver bullet. You do it by going back to the disciplined management and "hedgehog concept" that made you great in the first place.
Take IBM in the 90s. They were circling the drain, but they managed to pivot by refocusing on their core strengths rather than just chasing every shiny new thing. It took time. It wasn't a miracle; it was a grind.
Your Actionable Checklist: How to Stay "Mighty"
If you're worried your organization (or even your career) is slipping, here is how you stop the bleed:
- Check your Ego: Are you still asking "why" things work, or are you just assuming you're a genius? If the "questions to statements" ratio in your meetings is low, you have a hubris problem.
- Audit Your "Key Seats": Identify the 10 most important roles in your company. Are they filled by people you would enthusiastically re-hire? If not, stop expanding until you fix that.
- Face the Brutal Facts: Look at your worst-performing metric today. Don't explain it away. Don't blame the market. Ask: "What did we do to cause this?"
- Kill the Silver Bullet: Stop looking for the one big move that will "save" everything. Focus on getting the flywheel turning again with small, disciplined wins.
The biggest takeaway from How the Mighty Fall is pretty simple but hard to swallow: Whether you prevail or fail depends more on what you do to yourself than what the world does to you.
✨ Don't miss: SPDR Dow Jones Global Real Estate UCITS ETF GLRE Factsheet: What Most Investors Miss
Next steps for you: Identify which of the five stages your current project or company is in. If you're in Stage 1 or 2, you have plenty of time to fix it—but only if you’re honest enough to admit the decline has already started.