You've finally landed in a new city. You’ve got your bags, your itinerary is set, and you walk up to the rental desk feeling like a full-grown adult. Then, the agent asks for your ID. Their face changes. Suddenly, you're not a customer; you're a liability.
Honestly, the question of how old you have to be to rent a car is one of the most frustrating parts of travel planning. People assume 21 is the magic number. It isn't always. Sometimes it’s 25, sometimes it’s 18, and sometimes it’s "we don't rent to you at all." It depends on the state, the company, and how much extra cash you’re willing to set on fire to cover "young driver" surcharges.
The industry treats anyone under 25 like they’re one bad song away from a high-speed chase. It’s annoying. It’s expensive. But it is navigable if you know which companies actually play ball and which ones just want to slap you with a $30-a-day fee for being born in the wrong decade.
The Age 25 Myth and Why It Still Exists
Most people think you can’t rent a car until you’re 25. That’s just flat-out wrong. You can absolutely rent a car at 20 or 21 in almost every state. The "Age 25" thing exists because that's when the insurance companies finally exhale and stop charging "Underage Driver Fees."
Actuaries—the people who spend all day looking at spreadsheets of car crashes—have decided that 25 is the magic year when humans suddenly become less likely to wrap a sedan around a telephone pole. Because of this, rental giants like Hertz, Enterprise, and Avis will let you rent at 21, but they’ll tack on a daily fee that can sometimes cost more than the rental itself. It's a risk mitigation tactic. Basically, they're saying, "We'll trust you with this Toyota Corolla, but you're paying for the privilege of us being nervous about it."
There are exceptions. Michigan and New York are the rebels here. State laws there actually mandate that rental companies provide vehicles to drivers as young as 18. Of course, the companies still find ways to charge you extra, but they can't legally turn you away just because you haven't hit your mid-twenties yet.
Rental Policies by the Big Names
Every company has a different vibe regarding how old you have to be to rent a car, and it changes based on location.
👉 See also: Road Conditions I40 Tennessee: What You Need to Know Before Hitting the Asphalt
Enterprise and National usually set the floor at 21. They are pretty strict about this. If you’re 19 and trying to rent a car for a college road trip, you’re likely out of luck unless you’re in a state that forces their hand. They also restrict younger drivers from renting "specialty" vehicles. Don't expect to roll up and grab a Cadillac Escalade or a Mustang GT if you’re 22. You’ll likely be limited to economy or mid-size cars.
Hertz is slightly more flexible, especially if you have certain memberships. They generally require you to be 20, but the fees for being under 25 are notorious. However, they have a long-standing partnership with AAA. If you are a AAA member and you're between 20 and 24, Hertz will often waive that young driver fee. That’s a huge deal. It can save you $200 on a week-long trip.
Avis and Budget (which are basically the same company under the hood) usually require you to be 21. Like the others, they’ll let you drive, but they’ll charge you. They also tend to have a "no-go" list for younger drivers that includes luxury cars, passenger vans, and large SUVs.
What About the 18-Year-Olds?
If you’re 18, you’re in a tough spot. Unless you are in New York or Michigan, or you are a member of the U.S. Military on official orders, most traditional rental agencies will tell you no. Government employees or military personnel with travel orders are the "Golden Ticket" holders. They can often rent as young as 18 without any extra fees at all. It’s one of the few perks of the job that actually helps during a PCS move or a TDY assignment.
Hidden Fees and the "Young Driver" Tax
Let's talk money. This is where it gets ugly. The "Young Driver Surcharge" isn't a flat rate across the country. It’s a variable mess. In some cities, it might be $15 a day. In Las Vegas or New York City, it could be $50 a day.
Think about that. If the car is $40 a day and the fee is $35, you are paying double what the guy standing behind you in line is paying, just because he's 30 and you're 22. It feels like a scam. It sort of is, but it's one legal enough that everyone does it.
✨ Don't miss: Finding Alta West Virginia: Why This Greenbrier County Spot Keeps People Coming Back
You also need to watch out for the "debit card" trap. Many rental places will let a 25-year-old rent with a debit card, but they might require a 21-year-old to have a major credit card. They want that "hold" on your credit line because they don't trust that your checking account has enough to cover a fender bender. If you only have a debit card, call ahead. Don't assume. You don't want to be stranded at an airport at midnight because your plastic isn't the right color.
Alternatives That Don't Care (As Much) About Your Age
If the big agencies are being difficult, you have to look elsewhere. The "Peer-to-Peer" rental market has changed the game for younger travelers.
Turo is the big one. It's basically Airbnb for cars. On Turo, you can often rent as young as 18, though Turo themselves will charge a "Young Driver Fee" for anyone under 25. The difference? Sometimes the base price of the car is so much lower that it still works out cheaper. Plus, you get to pick the actual car, not just a "or similar" mystery vehicle.
Then there’s Zipcar. Zipcar is great for students. They have partnerships with hundreds of universities. If you’re a student at a participating school, you can often join Zipcar at 18. It’s designed for short trips—running to Target or a quick weekend getaway—and it includes insurance and gas. For a 19-year-old in a dorm, this is usually the smartest way to get wheels.
The International Wildcard
If you think the US is complicated, try going to Europe. The rules for how old you have to be to rent a car in Italy or Greece are a fever dream of local regulations.
In many European countries, the minimum age is 21, but they also have a "Maximum Age." Yeah, really. Some places won't rent to you if you're over 70 or 75. Also, if you’re under 25, you might be forced to buy the highest level of insurance they offer. You can’t just rely on your credit card’s secondary coverage. They’ll want to see you’re fully covered before they hand over the keys to a manual-transmission Fiat.
🔗 Read more: The Gwen Luxury Hotel Chicago: What Most People Get Wrong About This Art Deco Icon
How to Get Around the Age Requirements (Legally)
You aren't totally stuck. There are a few "pro-gamer moves" to avoid the fees or the age barriers.
- Join AAA: As mentioned, the Hertz/AAA partnership is the best-kept secret for 20-24 year olds. The membership pays for itself in two days of car rental.
- Corporate Codes: If you’re traveling for work, use your company’s corporate code. Most big companies have negotiated contracts that waive underage fees. Just make sure you’re actually allowed to use it for personal travel, or things get awkward if you crash.
- USAARP (for the young?): Actually, AARP allows people under 50 to join. While it doesn’t always waive the age fee, it can sometimes get you discounts that offset it.
- Rent a Truck: Believe it or not, U-Haul will rent to 18-year-olds. It’s not the most stylish way to show up to a wedding, but if you just need to get from point A to point B and you're 19, a pickup truck from U-Haul is often the only option that won't break the bank.
Realities of Insurance for Young Drivers
If you are under 25, your personal car insurance probably covers you for rentals, but you better check. If you only have "Liability" on your beat-up 2010 Honda at home, that’s all you have on the brand-new rental. If you total the rental, you're on the hook for the value of the car.
Rental companies know you’re nervous. They will try to sell you the Collision Damage Waiver (CDW). For a younger driver, this is sometimes actually worth it for the peace of mind, even if it’s a rip-off. It’s the only way to walk away from a wreck with zero debt.
Practical Steps Before You Book
Don't just click "Reserve" on Expedia and hope for the best. Follow this checklist to make sure you actually get a car:
- Check the specific branch rules. A Hertz at an airport might have different age rules than a Hertz in a suburban strip mall.
- Calculate the "Total" price. The search engine says $30/day. The underage fee is $25/day. Your real price is $55. Compare that "Real Price" across different sites.
- Get a Credit Card. If you're 21 and trying to build a travel life, get a travel credit card. It makes the rental process 100% smoother.
- Verify your license. If you have a provisional license or a "Junior" license, many companies will reject you regardless of age. You need a full, unrestricted license.
The bottom line is that while 25 is the industry's "safe zone," the door isn't closed if you're younger. You just have to be willing to do more paperwork and pay a bit more for the "youth" tax. Check the AAA route first—it's almost always the cheapest path for anyone in that 20-24 bracket. If you're 18 or 19, look toward Turo or U-Haul, or stick to New York and Michigan where the law is on your side.
Avoid the big-name "deals" that look too good to be true; once they see your birth year, those deals usually evaporate into a cloud of surcharges. Get your membership cards in order, bring a real credit card, and always read the "Terms and Conditions" link that everyone else skips. It’s where the real age rules are hiding.