You’re sitting at a dinner table, staring down a steaming plate of garlic-infused pasta. You take a bite. It’s incredible. But here is the weird part: your tongue isn't actually doing most of the heavy lifting. If you’ve ever wondered how much of taste is smell, you might have heard the common "80 percent" figure thrown around in biology classes or food blogs. Honestly? That number is a bit of a simplification, but it's not far from the truth. Without your nose, that pasta would basically just be a salty, slightly acidic mush.
Taste is boring. There, I said it. Your tongue is a blunt instrument. It only identifies five basic qualities: sweet, sour, salty, bitter, and umami (that savory, meaty depth). Everything else—the "strawberry-ness" of a strawberry, the "smokiness" of a brisket, the "floral notes" of an Earl Grey tea—is actually flavor, not taste. And flavor is almost entirely a construction of your olfactory system.
The Big Lie About Your Tongue
For decades, we were taught the "tongue map." You know the one—the diagram showing sweet at the tip, bitter at the back, and sour on the sides. It’s total nonsense. Researchers like Linda Bartoshuk at the University of Florida have spent years debunking this. Receptors for all tastes are scattered all over your mouth. But even with those receptors working perfectly, they can’t tell the difference between a slice of apple and a slice of onion if your nose is clamped shut.
Try it. Seriously.
Hold your nose, close your eyes, and have someone give you a jellybean. You’ll feel the chewiness. You’ll taste the sugar. But you won’t know if it’s cherry or lime until you let go of your nose and take a breath. That rush of air carries volatile organic compounds from the back of your throat up into your nasal cavity. This is called retronasal olfaction. It’s the secret sauce of the human dining experience.
Retronasal vs. Orthonasal: The Two Ways You Smell
Most people think smelling happens through the nostrils. That’s orthonasal olfaction. It’s what you do when you sniff a rose or a bottle of wine. It’s an external warning or invitation.
But when you’re eating, the "smell" travels from the mouth upward through the back of the throat. This is retronasal olfaction. Dr. Gordon Shepherd, a neuroscientist at Yale, actually coined the term "neurogastronomy" to describe this. He argues that our brains are hardwired to prioritize these internal smells because they signal that we are currently consuming nutrients.
Why your brain gets confused
Your brain is a master of deception. It performs a trick called "olfactory referral." When those smell signals hit your olfactory bulb at the same time your tongue feels the texture of food, your brain "refers" the smell to your mouth. You think you’re tasting the vanilla in your ice cream with your tongue. You aren't. Your brain is just projecting the smell data onto the physical sensation of the cold cream on your palate.
📖 Related: Why the 45 degree angle bench is the missing link for your upper chest
It’s a seamless integration.
If you lose your sense of smell—a condition called anosmia—the world turns gray. People who suffered from loss of smell during recent global health events realized very quickly that while they could still "taste" salt or vinegar, the joy of food vanished. They weren't just losing a nose; they were losing the ability to perceive 70% to 90% of what we call flavor.
The Chemistry of a Perfect Bite
Let’s look at coffee.
Coffee has over 800 volatile compounds. When you sip it, those compounds vaporize in the warmth of your mouth. They travel up. They hit the olfactory epithelium, a postage-stamp-sized patch of tissue packed with millions of sensory neurons.
- Aldehydes give you those fruity or herbaceous notes.
- Pyrazines provide the roasted, nutty smell.
- Sulfur compounds can make it smell like toasted bread or, if there's too much, like rotten eggs.
Your tongue detects the caffeine (bitter) and maybe some acidity. That’s it. The entire "experience" of a Morning Joe is a high-speed data transfer between your throat and your brain’s smell center.
Why Texture and Temperature Mess With Your Perception
Ever notice how melted ice cream tastes way sweeter than the frozen stuff? Or how a warm soda feels cloying, but a cold one is refreshing?
Temperature changes how molecules move. Heat makes molecules move faster, which means more of them vaporize and reach your nose. This is why cheap beer is served ice cold; the cold suppresses the "skunky" volatile compounds, leaving you with just the basic sensation of cold, bubbly liquid. As it warms up, the smells become more apparent, and you realize you’re drinking swill.
👉 See also: The Truth Behind RFK Autism Destroys Families Claims and the Science of Neurodiversity
Texture matters too. This is "mouthfeel." If you have a head cold and your nose is stuffed, a crisp apple might still be satisfying because of the "crunch" (auditory and tactile feedback), even if you can’t "taste" the fruitiness. The somatosensory system—which handles touch, temperature, and pain (like the burn of chili peppers)—works alongside smell and taste to create the total package.
The Genetics of Flavor
We don't all live in the same flavor world. About 25% of the population are "supertasters." They have more papillae (the bumps on your tongue) and are more sensitive to bitter compounds like PROP (6-n-propylthiouracil). For these people, the "smell" component of food has to compete with a very loud, very intense signal from the tongue.
Then you have "non-tasters" who need a lot of seasoning and heavy aromas to get any satisfaction from a meal.
Then there’s the cilantro thing. For some, cilantro tastes like fresh citrus. For others, it tastes like hand soap. This isn't a "taste" issue in the traditional sense; it’s a genetic variation in olfactory receptors (specifically the OR6A2 gene) that makes some people highly sensitive to the aldehydes in the plant that also appear in soaps.
The Role of Memory and Emotion
The olfactory bulb is directly connected to the amygdala and the hippocampus. These are the parts of your brain that handle emotion and memory. This is why a specific smell—like cinnamon or roasting chicken—can trigger a vivid childhood memory faster than a photo or a song.
This emotional connection is part of why we crave certain foods when we’re stressed. We aren't just looking for the glucose hit (the taste); we’re looking for the olfactory "hug" of a familiar aroma.
How to Hack Your Senses
If you want to truly understand how much of taste is smell, you have to change how you eat.
✨ Don't miss: Medicine Ball Set With Rack: What Your Home Gym Is Actually Missing
Most people chew and swallow too fast. They don't give the volatile compounds time to reach the back of the nose. To maximize flavor, try the "professional taster" method. Take a bite, chew slowly, and exhale through your nose while the food is still in your mouth. This forces the air from your throat up into the nasal cavity. You will suddenly notice layers of flavor you never knew existed.
This is exactly what wine sommeliers do when they slurp. That loud, slightly annoying slurping sound isn't just for show; it’s aerating the liquid, turning those wine molecules into a gas that can be easily "read" by the brain.
Is the "80 Percent" Figure Actually Accurate?
Scientists generally agree that smell contributes the vast majority of what we perceive as flavor. Whether it’s 75%, 80%, or 90% is almost a moot point because the two systems are so inextricably linked. You can't really have one without the other and still call it "eating."
Think of taste as the rhythm section of a band—it provides the structure and the beat (sweet, salty, etc.). Smell is the lead singer and the guitar. It provides the melody, the lyrics, and the soul. Without the rhythm, the song falls apart. But without the melody, it's just a repetitive thumping.
Practical Steps for Better Flavor
Stop ignoring your nose. If you want to improve your health or your enjoyment of food, focus on the olfactory side of the equation.
- Smell your food before you eat it. This primes the brain and starts the digestive process through the cephalic phase response.
- Clear your sinuses. If you have chronic allergies, you are effectively eating in black and white. Using a saline rinse can literally make your food taste better.
- Vary temperatures. Experiment with eating leftovers cold versus hot to see which aromas come forward.
- Mindful Chewing. Spend five extra seconds per bite. Give the retronasal path a chance to work.
- Watch the salt. We often add salt because we think a dish is "bland," but usually, it just lacks aromatic depth. Try adding fresh herbs or citrus zest—things high in volatile oils—instead of reaching for the salt shaker.
Understanding the massive role smell plays in your "taste" isn't just a fun party trick. It’s a way to reconnect with what you're putting in your body. When you realize your nose is the real chef in the kitchen, you start to appreciate the complexity of even the simplest meals. Next time you're eating a piece of chocolate, pinch your nose halfway through. You'll feel the exact moment the "magic" disappears, leaving you with nothing but a bit of fat and sugar. That transition is the clearest proof you'll ever need.