You’re standing in the aisle. It’s overwhelming. There are roughly four thousand shades of "off-white" staring you down, and honestly, they all look identical under those buzzing fluorescent lights. You know you need a sample. You’ve heard the horror stories of people painting an entire living room "Passive" only to realize it looks like a cold hospital wing once the sun hits it. So, you wonder, how much is a paint sample at Sherwin Williams anyway?
The short answer? Expect to pay about $10 to $12 for a single quart-sized container.
But it’s rarely that simple. If you walk into a Sherwin Williams in downtown Chicago, you’re going to see a different price tag than if you’re shopping in a small town in rural Ohio. Prices fluctuate based on regional overhead and, occasionally, whether there’s a massive sale running. It’s not like the old days when you could snag a tiny pot for five bucks.
The Price of Not Messing Up Your Living Room
Let’s talk about the "Color to Go" jugs. That’s what Sherwin Williams calls their samples. They aren't those tiny little 2-ounce jars you might find at a boutique hardware store or a craft shop. They are substantial. You get a full quart.
Why a quart?
Because Sherwin Williams is betting on the fact that you need to see the paint in action. You need to paint a massive 2x2 foot square on every single wall in the room. Why? Because the light changes. That "Sea Salt" green looks like a beachy dream at 10:00 AM but might turn into a muddy gray by 4:00 PM. Spending twelve dollars now is a hedge against spending six hundred dollars on five gallons of the wrong color later.
I’ve seen people try to skip this step. They buy the "Peel and Stick" samples—which Sherwin Williams also sells through partners like Samplize—for around $6 to $10. Those are great because there’s no mess. No brushes to wash. But they don't have the texture of real paint. There is something tactile about the "Color to Go" quart that just gives you more confidence.
What You Are Actually Buying
Here is a weird quirk most people don't realize: the paint inside a Sherwin Williams sample is not "real" paint.
✨ Don't miss: How to Sign Someone Up for Scientology: What Actually Happens and What You Need to Know
Wait, what?
It’s true. It is a lower-grade, thin, flat latex paint. It is designed specifically for color representation, not for durability or coverage. You cannot—and I mean absolutely cannot—use these samples to touch up your trim or paint a small piece of furniture like a birdhouse. Well, you could, but it’s going to peel, fade, and look terrible within months. It lacks the binders and resins found in their high-end lines like Emerald or Duration.
It’s basically colored water and chalk. Expensive colored water.
But that's okay. You aren't buying a finish; you’re buying a visual. You’re paying for the pigment accuracy. Sherwin Williams uses a proprietary tinting system that is incredibly precise. When you finally decide on "Agreeable Gray" and go back to buy the expensive gallon, the color match will be identical because the sample used the same tinting computer.
The Math of a Sale
Sherwin Williams is famous for their sales. They have "Super Sales" where everything is 30% or 40% off. If you time it right, that $11.50 sample drops down to about $7.50.
If you’re doing a whole house? That adds up.
Most DIYers grab three or four samples at a time. If you’re staring at "Naval," "In the Navy," and "Anchors Aweigh," you’re going to spend $45 just to find the right blue. It feels steep. It feels like a racket. But compare that to the labor of repainting a vaulted ceiling because the blue you chose looked too much like a denim jacket. Suddenly, $45 feels like a bargain.
🔗 Read more: Wire brush for cleaning: What most people get wrong about choosing the right bristles
The Hidden Alternatives
Some folks swear by the Samplize route. These are 9x14.75 inch stickers. They cost about $9.95 each. They use real Sherwin Williams paint, but they are applied to a peel-and-stick backing.
Is it cheaper? Not really.
Is it cleaner? Absolutely.
If you are a renter, Samplize is the way to go. You can’t exactly go painting giant squares of "Peppercorn" on walls you don't own. But if you’re a homeowner, get the quart. Get a cheap brush. Slap it on the wall. See how the drywall texture interacts with the pigment.
Why the Price Varies So Much
Inflation has hit the paint industry hard. Between 2021 and 2025, the cost of raw materials—specifically titanium dioxide and various resins—skyrocketed.
In the "before times," you could find these samples for $8. Those days are gone. Today, the price is driven by:
- Logistics: Moving heavy liquid is expensive.
- Labor: It takes just as much time for a store associate to mix a quart as it does a gallon. You are paying for their time.
- The Container: Even the plastic jug costs the company more than it used to.
If you walk into a store and the price is $13, don't be shocked. Higher-rent districts pass those costs down. Conversely, if you have a Pro account (even a basic one), you might see a slight discount, though usually, pro discounts are weighted toward the high-volume gallons rather than the one-off samples.
💡 You might also like: Images of Thanksgiving Holiday: What Most People Get Wrong
Making the Most of That $12 Jug
Since you’re dropping ten to twelve bucks, don’t waste it. Don't just paint one tiny stripe.
Paint near the window. Paint in the darkest corner. Paint next to your flooring. If you have honey oak cabinets, paint the sample right against the wood. Colors are reactive; they change based on what is next to them. "Alabaster" next to dark walnut looks crisp; "Alabaster" next to yellow-toned oak can look like old butter.
Also, keep the lid tight. These quarts dry out faster than the high-end cans because the seal isn't as robust. If you're debating between colors for a week, make sure you hammer that plastic lid down with a rubber mallet.
Real World Cost Comparison
| Option | Estimated Price | Best For |
|---|---|---|
| Color to Go Quart | $10.50 - $12.50 | Seeing real texture and large-scale light testing. |
| Samplize Sticker | $9.95 | Renters or people who hate cleaning brushes. |
| Color Chips | Free | Initial narrowing down of colors only. |
The free chips are a trap. They are printed, not painted. They lie. The ink on a piece of cardboard will never behave the same way as liquid latex on a porous wall. Use the free chips to get in the ballpark, but don't buy five gallons based on a 2-inch square of paper. That's a recipe for a very expensive Saturday mistake.
The Verdict on the Value
So, how much is a paint sample at Sherwin Williams? It's about the price of a fancy burrito bowl.
It feels pricey for what it is—low-grade paint in a plastic tub—but it’s the only way to be certain. If you’re on a budget, wait for the 30% off coupons that hit the mailers or your email inbox every few weeks. They are almost constant.
Just remember: you are paying for the "Color to Go" convenience. You get to walk out of the store with a custom-mixed color in ten minutes. It’s the gold standard for a reason.
Actionable Next Steps for Your Project
- Check the Sale Cycle: Before heading out, check the Sherwin Williams website. If a sale starts Friday, wait. You’ll save $3-4 per sample.
- Buy a Cheap Multi-Pack of Brushes: Don't use your $25 Purdy brush for samples. Grab a $5 pack of foam brushes or disposable 2-inch brushes. The sample paint is "flat" and messy; you don't want to spend twenty minutes cleaning a good brush just for a test patch.
- Label Your Walls: If you are testing three different grays, write the name of the color in pencil directly on the wall above the paint patch. Once it dries, "Agreeable Gray" and "Repose Gray" look shockingly similar to the untrained eye.
- Live With It: Leave the samples on the wall for at least 48 hours. Watch them at night under your actual light bulbs. If you use 2700K "Warm" LED bulbs, your paint will look yellow. If you use 5000K "Daylight" bulbs, it will look blue. The sample will reveal this truth before it’s too late to change your mind.
- Recycle the Leftovers: Since you can't use the sample for actual painting projects, check your local municipality for paint recycling. Don't just toss a half-full quart in the trash; the high pigment load isn't great for the landfill.
Painting is 90% preparation and 10% execution. Buying that sample is the most important part of the prep. Spend the twelve bucks. Your future self, sitting in a perfectly colored living room, will thank you.