You’re standing at the seafood counter, staring at a slab of wild-caught salmon and wondering if you're doing your heart a favor or accidentally micro-dosing yourself with heavy metals. It’s a weirdly stressful internal debate. On one hand, you’ve got the American Heart Association (AHA) basically shouting from the rooftops that we need more omega-3s. On the other, there are those persistent headlines about mercury and "forever chemicals" like PFAS lurking in our waterways.
So, let's get into it. How much fish per week should you actually eat to hit that sweet spot of maximum health benefits without the toxic baggage?
The short answer used to be a simple "two servings." But honestly, that’s kinda lazy advice. It doesn't account for the fact that a six-ounce portion of sardines is a whole different beast compared to a six-ounce portion of King Mackerel. We need to look at the nuance.
The "Two Serving" Rule and Why It's Just a Starting Point
For years, the standard recommendation from the FDA and EPA has been eight to twelve ounces of a variety of seafood per week. That’s roughly two to three servings. If you're pregnant or nursing, the guidelines get a bit more protective, but for the average adult, that’s the baseline.
Why two servings?
It mostly comes down to those long-chain omega-3 fatty acids: eicosapentaenoic acid (EPA) and docosahexaenoic acid (DHA). Your brain is essentially a giant blob of fat, and it thrives on this stuff. Research, including a massive meta-analysis published in JAMA, shows that consuming about 250 to 500 milligrams of EPA and DHA per day is linked to a significantly lower risk of dying from heart disease.
But here’s where it gets tricky.
If you eat two servings of tilapia, you aren't getting nearly the same omega-3 hit as you would from two servings of salmon. Tilapia is lean, which is fine for protein, but it’s pretty weak on the healthy fats. Conversely, if you eat two servings of swordfish, you’re hitting your omega-3 targets but also spiking your mercury intake.
The Mercury Problem Nobody Likes Talking About
Mercury isn't just a "maybe" risk; it’s a real neurotoxin that accumulates in the tissue of fish over time. It’s a process called biomagnification.
Small fish eat plankton.
Bigger fish eat the small fish.
The biggest fish eat everything else.
By the time you get to a shark or a marlin, that fish has been collecting mercury from every single thing it’s ever eaten its entire life. This is why the how much fish per week question can't be answered without talking about species.
High-Mercury Offenders to Watch
You really want to limit or completely avoid the "Big Four" if you’re eating fish regularly. These are:
- King Mackerel
- Shark
- Swordfish
- Tilefish (specifically from the Gulf of Mexico)
If you’re eating these once a month, you’re probably fine. If you’re eating them once a week? You might want to rethink that. Bigeye tuna is also a heavy hitter in the mercury department. If you're a sushi lover who strictly orders maguro, you are likely consuming more mercury than someone who sticks to salmon rolls.
Let’s Talk About Canned Tuna
This is where most people trip up. Canned tuna is the ultimate "gym bro" staple. It’s cheap. It’s pure protein. It’s convenient. But "Light" tuna and "Albore" (White) tuna are not created equal.
👉 See also: Why hot guys having sex with guys is redefining modern sexual health and wellness
Skipjack, often sold as "Chunk Light," is a smaller fish. It lives a shorter life and stays lower on the food chain. This means it has significantly less mercury. You can usually get away with two or three cans of this a week. Albacore, however, is a larger fish. It has about three times as much mercury as Skipjack. The FDA suggests limiting Albacore to just six ounces a week.
Think about that. One standard can is five ounces. If you eat one tuna salad sandwich made with Albacore, you’re basically done for the week.
The SMASH List: Your Safe Harbor
If you want to maximize your health and stop worrying about a calculator, you need to memorize the SMASH acronym. This was popularized by various functional medicine experts and nutritionists to identify fish that are high in healthy fats but low in contaminants.
- Sardines
- Mackerel (Atlantic or Pacific, not King)
- Anchovies
- Salmon
- Herring
These fish are short-lived and eat low on the food chain. They are the "cleanest" options available. Honestly, if your how much fish per week routine consists entirely of wild-caught salmon and sardines, you could probably eat them four or five times a week and be incredibly healthy.
What About Farmed vs. Wild?
This is a massive point of contention. For a long time, the narrative was "Wild is Good, Farmed is Evil."
It’s more complicated now.
Farmed salmon often contains more fat than wild salmon because the fish don't have to swim against currents and are fed a calorie-dense diet. This means they can actually have more omega-3s per ounce. However, older farming practices led to higher levels of PCBs (polychlorinated biphenyls) and antibiotics.
The industry has cleaned up a lot in the last decade. Brands like Verlasso or fish labeled with the Aquaculture Stewardship Council (ASC) seal are generally considered safe and sustainable. That said, wild-caught Sockeye or Coho remains the gold standard for purity if your budget allows for it.
The Selenium Safeguard
There is a fascinating bit of biochemistry that often gets overlooked in the "mercury scare." It’s called the Selenium-to-Mercury ratio.
Selenium is a mineral that actually binds to mercury and prevents it from doing damage in the human body. As long as a fish has more selenium than mercury, the risk is significantly mitigated. Most ocean fish actually have a very favorable ratio. The ones that don't? Those Big Four mentioned earlier—shark, swordfish, king mackerel, and certain whales.
This is why eating a variety is so important. If you’re getting plenty of selenium from other sources (like Brazil nuts or eggs), your body is better equipped to handle the occasional high-mercury meal.
Real-World Math: A Weekly Sample
What does this actually look like on your plate? Let’s map out a "high-performance" week for an average adult.
Monday: A salad topped with a 4-ounce tin of sardines. (High omega-3, very low mercury).
Wednesday: A 6-ounce fillet of baked cod. (Lean protein, low mercury, moderate omega-3).
Friday: Two fish tacos using grilled shrimp or tilapia. (Low mercury, low fat).
In this scenario, you've hit three servings. You’ve stayed well under the safety limits for toxins. You’ve fueled your brain. You’re winning.
The Under-Discussed Risk: PFAS
Mercury is the old-school villain. The new kid on the block is PFAS—per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances. These are the "forever chemicals" found in non-stick pans and fire-fighting foam.
A recent study published in Environmental Research highlighted that freshwater fish (fish from lakes and rivers) can have incredibly high levels of PFAS. In some cases, eating just one freshwater fish caught in a contaminated US lake was equivalent to drinking water laced with PFAS for a month.
If you are a recreational fisherman, check your local state advisories. This is not a joke. While ocean-caught fish are generally lower in PFAS due to the sheer volume of the ocean diluting the chemicals, inland fish are a different story.
Actionable Steps for Your Grocery Run
Don't let the "analysis paralysis" stop you from eating seafood. The benefits of the protein and healthy fats almost always outweigh the risks for the general population.
- Prioritize the "small guys." If the fish is smaller than your hand (sardines, anchovies, herring), it's almost certainly safe to eat multiple times a week.
- Check the label for "Light" vs "White" tuna. Stick to Skipjack (Light) for your daily lunches and save the Albacore for a rare treat.
- Diversify your protein. Don't just eat salmon every single day. Rotate in shrimp, scallops, clams, and mussels. Shellfish are generally very low in mercury and provide essential minerals like zinc and B12.
- Be wary of "Local" catches. Unless you’ve checked the EPA's local water quality reports, assume that large fish from local lakes should be eaten sparingly—maybe once a week at most.
- Look for the seals. Marine Stewardship Council (MSC) for wild and ASC for farmed. These aren't perfect, but they are a hell of a lot better than buying "mystery fish."
The goal isn't to be perfect. The goal is to move the needle toward a diet that supports your heart and brain without overloading your liver with heavy metals. Two to three servings of low-mercury fish is the sweet spot. If you're going over that, just make sure those extra servings are coming from the very bottom of the food chain.